使用琼脂与明胶自制简易装置进行轴内脑肿瘤切除训练
本研究利用琼脂与明胶凝胶自制训练装置,制作硬、中等硬、软三种「肿瘤」置于「脑」凝胶中,并将部分「脑」区域视为功能区,让住院医师尝试完整切除肿瘤并尽量减少脑组织损伤。结果显示,在多数情况下,神经外科医师的残留肿瘤、切除正常脑组织、切除功能区及切除时间均少于住院医师,重复训练使住院医师技能提高,受训者反馈几乎全部为正面。
要点
- 琼脂与明胶混合凝胶可回缩并能被吸引,硬度随溶液浓度变化而改变。
- 训练使用硬、中等硬、软三种「肿瘤」,部分「脑」凝胶视为功能区。
- 多数情况下神经外科医师的残留肿瘤、正常脑组织与功能区切除量及用时少于住院医师。
核心结论
- 作者认为,带不同硬度「肿瘤」的自制装置似乎适合住院医师进行各项手术技能训练。
- 作者表示下一步将尝试制作更实用的三维凝胶模型用于术前模拟。
研究设计与样本
- 研究使用琼脂与明胶凝胶制成的自制装置进行住院医师轴内脑肿瘤切除训练,凝胶硬度随溶液浓度变化。
- 训练中将一块类似肿瘤的凝胶置入另一块类似脑的凝胶内,部分「脑」区域视为功能区,并准备硬、中等硬、软三种「肿瘤」。
主要发现
- 多数情况下,神经外科医师的残留肿瘤、切除正常脑组织、切除功能区及切除时间均少于住院医师。
- 重复训练使住院医师技能提高。
- 受训者反馈几乎全部为正面。
关键数值与推荐
- 凝胶硬度随溶液浓度变化,可制作硬、中等硬、软三种硬度的「肿瘤」。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为该装置似乎适合住院医师进行各项手术技能训练。
- 作者表示下一步将尝试制作更实用的三维凝胶模型用于术前模拟。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Self-made devices composed of agar and gelatin gel were used for resident training in intra-axial brain tumor resection. The mixture gel of agar and gelatin is retractable and can be suctioned. Hardness of the gel depends on the concentration of the solution. Therefore, by changing the concentration, it is easy to make gels of various hardness. METHODS: In this study, a mass of gel that looked like a tumor was placed into another gel that looked like the brain. A part of the "brain" was regarded as the eloquent area. Three types of "tumor" were prepared: hard, moderately hard, and soft tumors. Residents tried to remove the tumor entirely with minimal brain invasion. The training was repeated with 3 types of gel. After resection, the weight of the residual tumor, resected normal brain, and resected eloquent area were measured, and the time taken for removal was recorded. RESULTS: These data were compared between residents and neurosurgeons. We also analyzed how these data improved with repeated practice. In most cases, residual tumor, resected normal brain, resected eloquent area, and time taken for removal were less in neurosurgeons than in residents. Repeated training made residents more skillful. The responses of the trainees were almost all favorable. CONCLUSIONS: Our devices with "tumors" of various hardness appear to be suitable for resident training in each surgical skill. For the next step of this study, we will attempt to fabricate more practical 3-dimensional gel models for presurgical simulation.
引用
- Mashiko T, Oguma H, Konno T, et al. Training of Intra-Axial Brain Tumor Resection Using a Self-Made Simple Device with Agar and Gelatin. World Neurosurg. 2017. PMID: 28987833. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2017.09.162
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。