我们还需要智商分数吗?髓母细胞瘤患儿神经认知结局的误导性解读:一项回顾性研究
该回顾性研究纳入37例髓母细胞瘤患儿,于诊断后0-3年用韦氏智力量表评估,并以连线测验A式测信息加工速度与视运动功能。作者发现全量表智商(FIQ)受加工速度和视运动协调影响明显,导致许多患儿总体认知表现被低估,诊断后1年规范偏离最大时该效应似达高峰,故主张采用全面神经心理测验组合,若用智商测验则需对分测验做详细分析。
要点
- FIQ受加工速度和视运动协调影响明显,可低估患儿总体认知表现。
- 诊断后1年患儿规范偏离最大时,该影响似达高峰。
- 作者认为全面神经心理测验组合对理解认知结局是必要的。
核心结论
- FIQ受加工速度与视运动协调的明显影响,导致许多患儿的总体认知表现被低估,单用智商分数可能误导临床解读。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,样本为37例髓母细胞瘤患儿,于诊断后0-3年使用韦氏智力量表评估,并以连线测验A式测量信息加工速度与视运动功能。
主要发现
- FIQ受加工速度和视运动协调影响明显,导致许多患儿总体认知表现被低估。
- 诊断后1年患儿规范偏离最大时,该效应似乎达到高峰。
关键数值与推荐
- 作者指出,若使用智商测验,针对加工速度影响的详细分测验分析似乎是必要的;否则患儿可能面临错误决策的风险,尤其在教育指导方面。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,正如国际指南已推荐的那样,全面神经心理测验组合对充分理解认知结局是必要的。
- 作者指出,若使用智商测验,针对加工速度影响的详细分测验分析似乎是必要的,否则患儿可能面临错误决策的风险,尤其在教育指导方面。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Over the past decades, many studies used global outcome measures like the IQ when reporting cognitive outcome of pediatric brain tumor patients, assuming that intelligence is a singular and homogeneous construct. In contrast, especially in clinical neuropsychology, the assessment and interpretation of distinct neurocognitive domains emerged as standard. By definition, the full scale IQ (FIQ) is a score attempting to measure intelligence. It is established by calculating the average performance of a number of subtests. Therefore, FIQ depends on the subtests that are used and the influence neurocognitive functions have on these performances. Consequently, the present study investigated the impact of neuropsychological domains on the singular "g-factor" concept and analysed the consequences for interpretation of clinical outcome. The sample consisted of 37 pediatric patients with medulloblastoma, assessed 0-3 years after diagnosis with the Wechsler Intelligence Scales. Information processing speed and visuomotor function were measured by the Trailmaking Test, Form A. Our findings indicate that FIQ was considerably impacted by processing speed and visuomotor coordination, which leaded to an underestimation of the general cognitive performance of many patients. One year after diagnosis, when patients showed the largest norm-deviation, this effect seemed to be at its peak. As already recommended in international guidelines, a comprehensive neuropsychological test battery is necessary to fully understand cognitive outcome. If IQ-tests are used, a detailed subtest analysis with respect to the impact of processing speed seems essential. Otherwise patients may be at risk for wrong decision making, especially in educational guidance.
引用
- Wegenschimmel B, Leiss U, Veigl M, et al. Do we still need IQ-scores? Misleading interpretations of neurocognitive outcome in pediatric patients with medulloblastoma: a retrospective study. J Neurooncol. 2017. PMID: 28779461. doi:10.1007/s11060-017-2582-x
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。