脊柱手术后的医疗过失诉讼
该研究利用VerdictSearch数据库检索1988年2月至2015年5月的脊柱手术相关诉讼案例,分析234例纳入案例的诉讼原因、患者特征与法律结局。结果显示诊断延迟和治疗延迟更易导致原告胜诉或和解,灾难性并发症与原告胜诉及更高赔偿相关,和解赔偿显著低于原告胜诉判决。
要点
- 诊断延迟组原告胜诉或和解比例为72.7%,高于无诊断延迟组的42.9%(P=0.007)。
- 治疗延迟组原告胜诉或和解比例为68.4%,高于无治疗延迟组的43.7%(P=0.03)。
- 灾难性并发症组医生败诉比例为66.7%,高于非灾难性并发症组的37.5%(P<0.001)。
核心结论
- 诊断和治疗延迟可预测有利于原告的法律结局。
- 灾难性并发症与高额赔偿及对医生不利的判决相关。
- 对医生被告而言,和解成本显著低于败诉。
研究设计与样本
- 利用VeridctSearch医疗法律研究服务检索1988年2月至2015年5月期间的「脊柱手术」相关诉讼案例。
- 共检查569例法律案例,排除335例无关或信息不足者,最终纳入234例。
- 收集原告和被告的人口学数据以及手术和法律结局的临床数据,将脊髓损伤、缺氧/缺血性脑损伤和死亡归类为灾难性并发症,其他并发症为非灾难性。
- 使用卡方检验和t检验评估变量对案件结局和赔偿金额的影响。
主要发现
- 234例中,被告胜诉127例(54.2%),原告胜诉61例(26.1%),和解46例(19.6%)。
- 原告胜诉赔偿金额范围为134,000至38,323,196美元(均值4,045,205±6,804,647美元)。
- 和解赔偿金额范围为125,000至9,000,000美元(均值1,930,278±2,113,593美元),显著低于原告胜诉赔偿(P=0.022)。
- 诊断延迟案例较无诊断延迟案例更易导致原告胜诉或和解而非被告胜诉(72.7% vs 42.9%,P=0.007),且更易庭外和解(40.9% vs 17.5%,P=0.008)。
- 治疗延迟案例较无治疗延迟案例更易导致原告胜诉或和解而非被告胜诉(68.4% vs 43.7%,P=0.03),且更易庭外和解(36.8% vs 18.1%,P=0.04)。
局限性
- 该研究可能无法真实代表所有司法管辖区,每个管辖区有不同的医疗过失法律和医疗法律环境。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE Adverse events related to spine surgery sometimes lead to litigation. Few studies have evaluated the association between spine surgical complications and medical malpractice proceedings, outcomes, and awards. The aim of this study was to identify the most frequent causes of alleged malpractice in spine surgery and to gain insight into patient demographic and clinical characteristics associated with medical negligence litigation. METHODS A search for "spine surgery" spanning February 1988 to May 2015 was conducted utilizing the medicolegal research service VerdictSearch (ALM Media Properties, LLC). Demographic data for the plaintiff and defendant in addition to clinical data for the procedure and legal outcomes were examined. Spinal cord injury, anoxic/hypoxic brain injury, and death were classified as catastrophic complications; all other complications were classified as noncatastrophic. Both chi-square and t-tests were used to evaluate the effect of these variables on case outcomes and awards granted. RESULTS A total of 569 legal cases were examined; 335 cases were excluded due to irrelevance or insufficient information. Of the 234 cases included in this investigation, 54.2% (127 cases) resulted in a defendant ruling, 26.1% (61) in a plaintiff ruling, and 19.6% (46) in a settlement. The awards granted for plaintiff rulings ranged from $134,000 to $38,323,196 (mean $4,045,205 ± $6,804,647). Awards for settlements ranged from $125,000 to $9,000,000 (mean $1,930,278 ± $2,113,593), which was significantly less than plaintiff rulings (p = 0.022). Compared with cases without a delay in diagnosis of the complication, the cases with a diagnostic delay were more likely to result in a plaintiff verdict or settlement (42.9% vs 72.7%, p = 0.007) than a defense verdict, and were more likely to settle out of court (17.5% vs 40.9%, p = 0.008). Similarly, compared with cases without a delay in treatment of the complication, those with a therapeutic delay were more likely to result in a plaintiff verdict or settlement (43.7% vs 68.4%, p = 0.03) than a defense verdict, and were more likely to settle out of court (18.1% vs 36.8%, p = 0.04). Overall, 28% of cases (66/234) involved catastrophic complications. Physicians were more likely to lose cases (plaintiff verdict or settlement) with catastrophic complications (66.7% vs 37.5%, p < 0.001). In cases with a plaintiff ruling, catastrophic complications resulted in significantly larger mean awards than noncatastrophic complications ($6.1M vs $2.9M, p = 0.04). The medical specialty of the provider and the age or sex of the patient were not associated with the case outcome or award granted (p > 0.05). The average time to a decision for defendant verdicts was 5.1 years; for plaintiff rulings, 5.0 years; and for settlements, 3.4 years. CONCLUSIONS Delays in the diagnosis and the treatment of a surgical complication predict legal case outcomes favoring the plaintiff. Catastrophic complications are linked to large sums awarded to the plaintiff and are predictive of rulings against the physician. For physician defendants, the costs of settlements are significantly less than those of losing in court. Although this study provides potentially valuable data from a large series of postoperative litigation cases, it may not provide a true representation of all jurisdictions, each of which has variable malpractice laws and medicolegal environments.
引用
- Daniels AH, Ruttiman R, Eltorai AEM, et al. Malpractice litigation following spine surgery. J Neurosurg Spine. 2017. PMID: 28731391. doi:10.3171/2016.11.SPINE16646
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。