文献速递神经肿瘤功能神经外科

唤醒状态下胶质瘤手术中术中感知与切除范围估计:克服学习曲线

Intraoperative perception and estimates on extent of resection during awake glioma surgery: overcoming the learning curve.
PubMed 文献 · J Neurosurg · 2017-07-21

该研究回顾性分析了17年间单术者实施的451例唤醒开颅胶质瘤切除术,评估术中感知切除范围(EOR)的准确性。术中判断全切除(GTR)或次全切除(STR)的总体准确率为79.6%,定量感知(与术后MRI相差5%以内)的总体准确率为81.4%。准确率随术者经验积累显著提高,定量感知准确率从1997-2000年的72.2%提升至2009-2013年的93.4%。正确的定量感知与较低的术后运动障碍相关(2.4% vs 8.0%,p=0.029)。

要点

  • 术中判断GTR/STR的总体准确率为79.6%,定量感知EOR的总体准确率为81.4%。
  • 定量感知准确率随年份显著提高:1997-2000年72.2% vs 2009-2013年93.4%(p=0.015)。
  • 岛叶肿瘤的粗感知准确率最高(89.3%),但定量感知准确率最低(61.1%)。

核心结论

  • 研究提示胶质瘤手术中准确评估术中EOR存在学习曲线,可能需要超过十年才能达到真正熟练。
  • 理解与准确评估EOR相关的因素将有助于在最大化肿瘤切除的同时提供更安全的手术。

研究设计与样本

  • 单术者17年间唤醒开颅肿瘤切除术的回顾性综述,共纳入451例患者。
  • 术中EOR估计记录于手术报告,确定性EOR基于术后MRI。
  • 准确性分析包括总体结局(GTR或STR)和定量(与术后MRI相差5%以内)两种方式。

主要发现

  • 总体粗感知(GTR或STR)准确率为79.6%,定量感知(与术后MRI相差5%以内)准确率为81.4%。
  • 粗感知准确率随17年期间显著改善(p=0.049):1997-2000年72.6%,2001-2004年78.5%,2005-2008年80.7%,2009-2013年84.4%。
  • 定量感知准确率随17年期间显著改善(p=0.015):1997-2000年72.2%,2001-2004年69.8%,2005-2008年84.8%,2009-2013年93.4%。
  • 岛叶肿瘤粗感知准确率最高(89.3%;p=0.034),但定量感知准确率最低(61.1%正确;p<0.001),调整术者经验后该趋势仍存在。
  • 正确定量感知与较低的术后运动障碍相关(2.4% vs 8.0%;p=0.029),语言结局无显著差异。

关键数值与推荐

  • 粗感知准确率:1997-2000年72.6%,2001-2004年78.5%,2005-2008年80.7%,2009-2013年84.4%(p=0.049)。
  • 定量感知准确率:1997-2000年72.2%,2001-2004年69.8%,2005-2008年84.8%,2009-2013年93.4%(p=0.015)。
  • 岛叶肿瘤粗感知准确率89.3%(p=0.034),定量感知准确率61.1%(p<0.001)。
  • 无1p19q共缺失与更高的定量感知准确率相关(96.9% vs 81.5%;p=0.051)。
  • 术后新发神经功能障碍发生率8.4%,其中42.1%在3个月随访时持续存在。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为术中准确评估EOR存在学习曲线,可能需要超过十年才能达到真正熟练。
  • 作者指出理解与准确评估EOR相关的因素有助于在最大化肿瘤切除的同时提供更安全的手术。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE There is ample evidence that extent of resection (EOR) is associated with improved outcomes for glioma surgery. However, it is often difficult to accurately estimate EOR intraoperatively, and surgeon accuracy has yet to be reviewed. In this study, the authors quantitatively assessed the accuracy of intraoperative perception of EOR during awake craniotomy for tumor resection. METHODS A single-surgeon experience of performing awake craniotomies for tumor resection over a 17-year period was examined. Retrospective review of operative reports for quantitative estimation of EOR was recorded. Definitive EOR was based on postoperative MRI. Analysis of accuracy of EOR estimation was examined both as a general outcome (gross-total resection [GTR] or subtotal resection [STR]), and quantitatively (5% within EOR on postoperative MRI). Patient demographics, tumor characteristics, and surgeon experience were examined. The effects of accuracy on motor and language outcomes were assessed. RESULTS A total of 451 patients were included in the study. Overall accuracy of intraoperative perception of whether GTR or STR was achieved was 79.6%, and overall accuracy of quantitative perception of resection (within 5% of postoperative MRI) was 81.4%. There was a significant difference (p = 0.049) in accuracy for gross perception over the 17-year period, with improvement over the later years: 1997-2000 (72.6%), 2001-2004 (78.5%), 2005-2008 (80.7%), and 2009-2013 (84.4%). Similarly, there was a significant improvement (p = 0.015) in accuracy of quantitative perception of EOR over the 17-year period: 1997-2000 (72.2%), 2001-2004 (69.8%), 2005-2008 (84.8%), and 2009-2013 (93.4%). This improvement in accuracy is demonstrated by the significantly higher odds of correctly estimating quantitative EOR in the later years of the series on multivariate logistic regression. Insular tumors were associated with the highest accuracy of gross perception (89.3%; p = 0.034), but lowest accuracy of quantitative perception (61.1% correct; p < 0.001) compared with tumors in other locations. Even after adjusting for surgeon experience, this particular trend for insular tumors remained true. The absence of 1p19q co-deletion was associated with higher quantitative perception accuracy (96.9% vs 81.5%; p = 0.051). Tumor grade, recurrence, diagnosis, and isocitrate dehydrogenase-1 (IDH-1) status were not associated with accurate perception of EOR. Overall, new neurological deficits occurred in 8.4% of cases, and 42.1% of those new neurological deficits persisted after the 3-month follow-up. Correct quantitative perception was associated with lower postoperative motor deficits (2.4%) compared with incorrect perceptions (8.0%; p = 0.029). There were no detectable differences in language outcomes based on perception of EOR. CONCLUSIONS The findings from this study suggest that there is a learning curve associated with the ability to accurately assess intraoperative EOR during glioma surgery, and it may take more than a decade to be truly proficient. Understanding the factors associated with this ability to accurately assess EOR will provide safer surgeries while maximizing tumor resection.

来源:J Neurosurg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lau D, Hervey-Jumper SL, Han SJ, et al. Intraoperative perception and estimates on extent of resection during awake glioma surgery: overcoming the learning curve. J Neurosurg. 2017. PMID: 28731401. doi:10.3171/2017.1.JNS161811

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。