重新审视徒手脑室造瘘术的规则:一项虚拟现实分析
该研究从本机构DICOM库随机选取50例脑室与颅骨解剖正常且未行脑室穿刺患者的CT,用5×5厘米额部网格25个入点模拟8000次虚拟脑室造瘘。仅少数入点与特定轨迹配对时命中同侧侧脑室前角(ILAH)率超过80%,同侧内眦作为轨迹目标命中率低,不应推荐。
要点
- 最佳命中率:理想轨迹86%,标志点轨迹84%,90°垂直轨迹83%,但仅见于特定入点。
- 入点距中线3或4厘米需配合指向对侧眦的轨迹;距中线1或2厘米需配合指向鼻根的轨迹。
- 同侧内眦作为常用轨迹目标命中率低,不应推荐作为轨迹目标。
核心结论
- 仅少数入点与特定轨迹配对时命中同侧侧脑室前角(ILAH)率可超过80%,入点与轨迹配对变异性很小。
- 同侧内眦作为常报道的轨迹目标命中率低,不应推荐作为轨迹目标。
研究设计与样本
- 从本机构DICOM库随机选取50例脑室与颅骨解剖正常且未行脑室穿刺患者的CT扫描。
- 采用以鼻根为参考的5×5厘米额部网格25个入点,模拟8000次三维虚拟现实脑室造瘘。
主要发现
- 命中ILAH的最佳命中率:理想轨迹86%,标志点轨迹84%,90°垂直轨迹83%,但仅见于特定入点。
- 最高命中率见于距中线3或4厘米入点配合指向对侧眦的轨迹,以及距中线1或2厘米入点配合指向鼻根的轨迹。
- 矢状面入点与轨迹同样存在配对关系。
- 90°垂直轨迹的最佳入点为距中线3-5厘米且鼻根前3厘米,或距中线4厘米且鼻根前2厘米。
关键数值与推荐
- 理想轨迹命中ILAH的最佳命中率为86%。
- 标志点轨迹命中ILAH的最佳命中率为84%。
- 90°垂直轨迹命中ILAH的最佳命中率为83%。
- 距中线3或4厘米入点需配合指向对侧眦的轨迹。
- 距中线1或2厘米入点需配合指向鼻根的轨迹。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为仅少数入点与特定轨迹配对时命中同侧侧脑室前角率可超过80%。
- 作者认为同侧内眦不应推荐作为轨迹目标。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE Frontal ventriculostomy is one of the most frequent and standardized procedures in neurosurgery. However, many first and subsequent punctures miss the target, and suboptimal placement or misplacement of the catheter is common. The authors therefore reexamined the landmarks and rules to determine the entry point and trajectory with the best hit rate (HtR). METHODS The authors randomly selected CT scans from their institution's DICOM pool that had been obtained in 50 patients with normal ventricular and skull anatomy and without ventricular puncture. Using a 5 × 5-cm frontal grid with 25 entry points referenced to the bregma, the authors examined trajectories 1) perpendicular to the skull, 2) toward classic facial landmarks in the coronal and sagittal planes, and 3) toward an idealized target in the middle of the ipsilateral anterior horn (ILAH). Three-dimensional virtual reality ventriculostomies were simulated for these entry points; trajectories and the HtRs were recorded, resulting in an investigation of 8000 different virtual procedures. RESULTS The best HtR for the ILAH was 86% for an ideal trajectory, 84% for a landmark trajectory, and 83% for a 90° trajectory, but only at specific entry points. The highest HtRs were found for entry points 3 or 4 cm lateral to the midline, but only in combination with a trajectory toward the contralateral canthus; and 1 or 2 cm lateral to the midline, but only paired with a trajectory toward the nasion. The same "pairing" exists for entry points and trajectories in the sagittal plane. For perpendicular (90°) trajectories, the best entry points were at 3-5 cm lateral to the midline and 3 cm anterior to the bregma, or 4 cm lateral to the midline and 2 cm anterior to the bregma. CONCLUSIONS Only a few entry points offer a chance of a greater than 80% rate of hitting the ILAH, and then only in combination with a specific trajectory. This "pairing" between entry point and trajectory was found both for landmark targeting and for perpendicular trajectories, with very limited variability. Surprisingly, the ipsilateral medial canthus, a commonly reported landmark, had low HtRs, and should not be recommended as a trajectory target.
引用
- Raabe C, Fichtner J, Beck J, et al. Revisiting the rules for freehand ventriculostomy: a virtual reality analysis. J Neurosurg. 2017. PMID: 28524798. doi:10.3171/2016.11.JNS161765
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。