发作间期颅内脑电图的格兰杰因果分析预测癫痫灶及最终切除范围
该研究对25例连续患者的20分钟发作间期基线颅内脑电图进行格兰杰因果分析,构建因果网络图并与常规手术计划定量比较。25例中16例的发作间期格兰杰因果排序低于随机预测(P<.05),最高格兰杰因果电极至发作期活跃电极集和切除区的距离平均为4 mm和6 mm(Wilcoxon P<.001)。结论认为格兰杰因果分析有潜力从发作间期数据帮助定位发作网络。
要点
- 25例中16例发作间期格兰杰因果排序低于随机预测(P<.05)。
- 最高格兰杰因果电极至发作期活跃电极集平均距离4 mm,至切除区平均6 mm(Wilcoxon P<.001)。
- 格兰杰因果分析有潜力从发作间期数据帮助定位发作网络。
核心结论
- 格兰杰因果分析有潜力从发作间期数据帮助定位发作网络。
研究设计与样本
- 研究分析了25例连续患者的20分钟发作间期基线颅内脑电图数据。
- 通过秩排序和笛卡尔距离统计将格兰杰因果图与常规构建的手术计划进行定量比较。
主要发现
- 25例中16例的发作期活跃电极集的发作间期格兰杰因果排序低于随机预测(P<.05)。
- 仅凭随机匹配的总体概率非常小(P<10-20),提示发作间期格兰杰因果图与发作网络相关。
- 最高格兰杰因果电极至发作期活跃电极集的距离平均为4 mm,至切除区的距离平均为6 mm(Wilcoxon P<.001)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A critical conceptual step in epilepsy surgery is to locate the causal region of seizures. In practice, the causal region may be inferred from the set of electrodes showing early ictal activity. There would be advantages in deriving information about causal regions from interictal data as well. We applied Granger's statistical approach to baseline interictal data to calculate causal interactions. We hypothesized that maps of the Granger causality network (or GC maps) from interictal data might inform about the seizure network, and set out to see if "causality" in the Granger sense correlated with surgical targets. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether interictal baseline data could produce GC maps, and whether the regions of high GC would statistically resemble the topography of the ictally active electrode (IAE) set and resection. METHODS: Twenty-minute interictal baselines obtained from 25 consecutive patients were analyzed. The "GC maps" were quantitatively compared to conventionally constructed surgical plans, by using rank order and Cartesian distance statistics. RESULTS: In 16 of 25 cases, the interictal GC rankings of the electrodes in the IAE set were lower than predicted by chance (P < .05). The aggregate probability of such a match by chance alone is very small (P < 10-20) suggesting that interictal GC maps correlated with ictal networks. The distance of the highest GC electrode to the IAE set and to the resection averaged 4 and 6 mm (Wilcoxon P < .001). CONCLUSION: GC analysis has the potential to help localize ictal networks from interictal data.
引用
- Park EH, Madsen JR. Granger Causality Analysis of Interictal iEEG Predicts Seizure Focus and Ultimate Resection. Neurosurgery. 2018. PMID: 28472428. doi:10.1093/neuros/nyx195
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。