文献速递神经肿瘤

眶上入路与内镜下经鼻入路切除嗅沟脑膜瘤的成本最小化研究

Supraorbital Versus Endoscopic Endonasal Approaches for Olfactory Groove Meningiomas: A Cost-Minimization Study.
PubMed 文献 · World Neurosurg · 2017-04-10

该成本最小化研究通过决策树比较眶上开颅与内镜下经鼻入路(EEA)切除嗅沟脑膜瘤的成本,眶上组全切除概率0.8、脑脊液漏0.2来自本中心5例系列,EEA组采用文献报道的全切除0.6、脑脊液漏0.3。眶上开颅为优选策略,期望成本29,423美元,EEA为83,838美元;单因素敏感性分析最小节省46,000美元、最大节省64,000美元,概率敏感性分析最小成本差37,431美元。作者结论认为眶上开颅较EEA可大幅节省成本,鉴于两种入路有效性可能存在差异,应开展成本效果分析。

要点

  • 眶上开颅期望成本29,423美元,EEA为83,838美元。
  • 单因素敏感性分析眶上开颅仍为优选,节省46,000至64,000美元。
  • 概率敏感性分析两种术式最低成本差为37,431美元。

核心结论

  • 与EEA相比,眶上开颅在嗅沟脑膜瘤治疗中可大幅节省成本。
  • 鉴于两种入路有效性可能存在差异,作者认为应开展成本效果分析。

研究设计与样本

  • 成本最小化研究,构建决策树比较眶上入路与内镜下经鼻入路(EEA)联合或不联合开颅切除嗅沟脑膜瘤。
  • 各分支成本取自本院财务部门,采用本中心5例眶上入路系列的全切除概率0.8与脑脊液漏0.2,EEA采用文献报道的全切除0.6与脑脊液漏0.3。
  • 行基础案例分析后对所有参数应用合理范围行多次单因素敏感性分析,并以概率敏感性分析确认结果。

主要发现

  • 本中心5例眶上入路系列平均肿瘤体积54.6 cm3(范围17-94.2 cm3)。
  • 眶上开颅为优选策略,期望值29,423美元,EEA成本83,838美元。
  • 多次单因素敏感性分析中眶上开颅仍为优选策略,最小节省46,000美元、最大节省64,000美元。
  • 概率敏感性分析发现两种术式最低成本差为37,431美元。

关键数值与推荐

  • 眶上开颅全切除概率0.8、脑脊液漏概率0.2,来自本中心5例系列。
  • EEA全切除概率0.6、脑脊液漏概率0.3,为文献报道率。
  • 眶上开颅期望成本29,423美元,EEA成本83,838美元。
  • 单因素敏感性分析节省范围46,000至64,000美元,概率敏感性分析最低成本差37,431美元。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To perform a cost-minimization study comparing the supraorbital and endoscopic endonasal (EEA) approach with or without craniotomy for the resection of olfactory groove meningiomas (OGMs). METHODS: We built a decision tree using probabilities of gross total resection (GTR) and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leak rates with the supraorbital approach versus EEA with and without additional craniotomy. The cost (not charge or reimbursement) at each "stem" of this decision tree for both surgical options was obtained from our hospital's finance department. After a base case calculation, we applied plausible ranges to all parameters and carried out multiple 1-way sensitivity analyses. Probabilistic sensitivity analyses confirmed our results. RESULTS: The probabilities of GTR (0.8) and CSF leak (0.2) for the supraorbital craniotomy were obtained from our series of 5 patients who underwent a supraorbital approach for the resection of an OGM. The mean tumor volume was 54.6 cm3 (range, 17-94.2 cm3). Literature-reported rates of GTR (0.6) and CSF leak (0.3) with EEA were applied to our economic analysis. Supraorbital craniotomy was the preferred strategy, with an expected value of $29,423, compared with an EEA cost of $83,838. On multiple 1-way sensitivity analyses, supraorbital craniotomy remained the preferred strategy, with a minimum cost savings of $46,000 and a maximum savings of $64,000. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis found the lowest cost difference between the 2 surgical options to be $37,431. CONCLUSION: Compared with EEA, supraorbital craniotomy provides substantial cost savings in the treatment of OGMs. Given the potential differences in effectiveness between approaches, a cost-effectiveness analysis should be undertaken.

来源:World Neurosurg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Gandhoke GS, Pease M, Smith KJ, et al. Supraorbital Versus Endoscopic Endonasal Approaches for Olfactory Groove Meningiomas: A Cost-Minimization Study. World Neurosurg. 2017. PMID: 28408255. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2017.03.148

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。