脑室腹腔分流与经皮内镜下胃造瘘的系统综述:一种安全的组合
该系统综述纳入10项成人研究共208例患者,评估脑室腹腔分流(VPS)是否为经皮内镜下胃造瘘(PEG)的禁忌证。汇总分析显示VPS感染26例(12.5%),分流管功能障碍4例(4.4%)。先置VPS后置PEG者感染率4.4%,先置PEG后置VPS者21.8%,同期置入者50%,但研究异质性大,无法进行统计学比较。作者认为VPS不应被视为PEG的禁忌证,PEG宜在VPS之后放置。
要点
- VPS不应被视为PEG置管的禁忌证
- PEG管宜在VPS置入之后放置
- VPS置入与PEG之间等待7-10天似乎合理,但本综述无法证实
核心结论
- VPS置入联合PEG具有较高但可接受的VPS并发症发生率
- VPS置入不应被视为PEG管放置的禁忌证
- PEG管宜在VPS之后放置
- VPS置入与PEG之间等待7-10天似乎合理,但本综述无法证实
研究设计与样本
- 按照PRISMA标准进行的系统综述
- 检索PubMed和Embase数据库,使用「ventriculo-peritoneal shunt」和「percutaneous (endoscopic) gastrostomy」的变体词
- 检索得到70项研究,其中9项相关,交叉引用后另发现1项,最终纳入10项研究
- 10项相关研究均为成人队列,共纳入208例患者
- 除1项研究外,其余均为回顾性研究,总体质量较差
主要发现
- 在具有相关数据的研究中,VPS感染26例(占208例的12.5%),VPS功能障碍4例(占90例的4.4%)
- 137例患者先置VPS后置PEG管,VPS感染率为4.4%
- 55例患者先置PEG后置VPS,VPS感染率为21.8%,高于先置VPS后置PEG者
- 16例患者同期置入PEG管和VPS,VPS感染率为50%
- 研究间异质性过大,无法对VPS与PEG管置入时机进行统计学比较
临床怎么用
- VPS置入不应被视为PEG管放置的禁忌证
- PEG管宜在VPS之后放置
- VPS置入与PEG之间等待7-10天似乎合理,但本综述无法证实
局限性
- 10项研究中除1项外均为回顾性研究
- 研究总体质量较差
- 研究间异质性过大,无法对VPS与PEG管置入时机进行统计学比较
- VPS置入与PEG之间等待7-10天似乎合理,但本综述无法证实
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE Various international and national gastrointestinal guidelines take different positions on whether ventriculoperitoneal shunt (VPS) insertion is a contraindication to percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy (PEG). The objective of this meta-analysis was to try to answer the question of whether VPS insertion is a contraindication to PEG. METHODS A systematic review of the literature was performed according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) criteria. Electronic databases PubMed and Embase were searched using variations of the terms "ventriculo-peritoneal shunt" and "percutaneous (endoscopic) gastrostomy." This search resulted in 70 studies, 9 of which were relevant. These were cross-referenced, and 1 additional study was found, resulting in 10 studies in this systematic review. RESULTS The 10 relevant studies in adult cohorts included 208 patients. All studies save one were retrospective and, in general, poor quality. Among the studies with relevant data, there were 26 (12.5% of 208 cases) VPS infections and 4 (4.4% of 90 cases) VPSs that malfunctioned. In 137 patients the VPS had been placed before the PEG tube, with a VPS infection rate of 4.4%. More VPS infections occurred among the 55 patients who first had a PEG and a subsequent VPS (21.8%) and in the 16 patients who had simultaneous PEG tube and VPS placement (50%). The heterogeneity of the studies in this analysis prohibited statistical comparisons of the timing of VPS and PEG tube placement. CONCLUSIONS This systematic review indicated that VPS placement in combination with a PEG has a high but acceptable VPS complication rate. Therefore, VPS insertion should not be considered a contraindication to the placement of a PEG tube. Preferably, a PEG tube should be placed after the VPS. Waiting 7-10 days between VPS insertion and a PEG seems reasonable, but this could not be corroborated in this review.
引用
- Oterdoom LH, Marinus Oterdoom DL, Ket JCF, et al. Systematic review of ventricular peritoneal shunt and percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy: a safe combination. J Neurosurg. 2016. PMID: 27911231. doi:10.3171/2016.8.JNS152701
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。