脑动静脉畸形手术后有意实施术后低血压与术后迟发性出血发生率:一项前瞻性队列研究
本研究纳入641例显微手术治疗的脑动静脉畸形,评估术后有意低血压方案(平均动脉压≤70 mmHg至少7天)对迟发性术后出血的影响。SPC C级患者中,该方案使迟发性出血从29%降至8.2%(p=0.035),多因素分析示未采用方案与出血风险相关(OR 7.5)。SPC B 3.5+级患者中无显著差异(p=0.77)。
要点
- SPC C级脑动静脉畸形术后采用低血压方案可显著降低迟发性出血风险。
- SPC B 3.5+级患者中低血压方案未显示显著降低迟发性出血。
- 迟发性出血患者中66%遗留永久性神经功能缺损,死亡率为13%。
核心结论
- 对SPC C级脑动静脉畸形患者,切除后立即降低血压的方案似乎可降低迟发性术后出血风险。
- 对SPC A和SPC B 3.5-级,可能仅需避免术后高血压。
- 对SPC B 3.5+级,需更大样本量验证低血压方案无获益。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性队列研究,1997年6月引入术后有意低血压方案,比较方案引入前后两个时期及四类bAVM(SPC A、SPC B 3.5-、SPC B 3.5+、SPC C)。
- 方案目标为切除后至少7天内平均动脉压最高≤70 mmHg(脑灌注压>50 mmHg)。
- 共641例显微手术治疗的bAVM,其中162例SPC B 3.5+或SPC C患者接受BP方案。
主要发现
- 641例中识别出32例迟发性术后出血,其中66%(95% CI 48-80)遗留永久性新发神经功能缺损(改良Rankin量表评分2-6),死亡率为13%(95% CI 4.4-29)。
- SPC B 3.5+患者中,引入BP方案后迟发性出血无显著减少(p=0.77)。
- SPC C患者中,引入BP方案后迟发性出血从29%(95% CI 13%-53%)降至8.2%(95% CI 3.2%-18%),差异显著(p=0.035)。
- 多因素logistic回归显示,在SPC C bAVM患者中,未采用BP方案与迟发性出血发展仍显著相关(p=0.011,OR 7.5,95% CI 1.6-36)。
关键数值与推荐
- SPC C患者BP方案引入前迟发性出血29%(95% CI 13%-53%),引入后8.2%(95% CI 3.2%-18%),p=0.035。
- SPC C患者未采用BP方案的OR为7.5(95% CI 1.6-36,p=0.011)。
- SPC B 3.5+患者BP方案引入前后迟发性出血无显著差异(p=0.77)。
临床怎么用
- 对SPC C级bAVM患者,切除后采用降低血压至平均动脉压≤70 mmHg至少7天的方案似乎可减少迟发性术后出血。
- 对SPC A和SPC B 3.5-级bAVM,可能仅需避免术后高血压。
- 对SPC B 3.5+级bAVM,低血压方案的获益尚未证实,需更大样本量研究。
局限性
- 对SPC B 3.5+级bAVM,需要更大数量的患者来测试BP方案无获益的结论。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE The aim of this study was to examine the impact of deliberate employment of postoperative hypotension on delayed postoperative hemorrhage (DPH) for all Spetzler-Ponce Class (SPC) C brain arteriovenous malformations (bAVMs) and SPC B bAVMs ≥ 3.5 cm in diameter (SPC B 3.5+). METHODS A protocol of deliberate employment of postoperative hypotension was introduced in June 1997 for all SPC C and SPC B 3.5+ bAVMs. The aim was to achieve a maximum mean arterial blood pressure (BP) ≤ 70 mm Hg (with cerebral perfusion pressure > 50 mm Hg) for a minimum of 7 days after resection of bAVMs (BP protocol). The authors compared patients who experienced DPH (defined as brain hemorrhage into the resection bed that resulted in a new neurological deficit or that resulted in reoperation during the hospitalization for microsurgical bAVM resection) between 2 periods (prior to adopting the BP protocol and after introduction of the BP protocol) and 4 bAVM categories (SPC A, SPC B 3.5- [that is, SPC B < 3.5 cm maximum diameter], SPC B 3.5+, and SPC C). Patients excluded from treatment by the BP protocol were managed in the intensive care unit to avoid moderate hypertensive episodes. The pooled cases of all bAVM treated by surgery were analyzed to identify characteristics associated with the risk of DPH. These identified characteristics were then examined by multiple logistic regression analysis in both SPC B 3.5+ and SPC C cases. RESULTS From a cohort of 641 bAVMs treated by microsurgery, 32 patients with DPH were identified. Of those, 66% (95% CI 48-80) had a permanent new neurological deficit with a modified Rankin Scale score of 2-6. This included a mortality rate of 13% (95% CI 4.4-29). The BP protocol was used to treat 162 patients with either SPC B 3.5+ or SPC C. For SPC B 3.5+, there was no significant reduction in DPH with the introduction of the BP protocol (p = 0.77). For SPC C, there was a significant (p = 0.035) reduction of DPH from 29% (95% CI 13%-53%) to 8.2% (95% CI 3.2%-18%) associated with the introduction of the BP protocol. Multiple logistic regression analysis found that the absence of the BP protocol (p = 0.011, odds ratio 7.5, 95% CI 1.6-36) remained significant for the development of DPH in patients with SPC C bAVMs. CONCLUSIONS Treating patients with SPC C bAVMs with a protocol that lowers BP immediately after resection seems to reduce the risk of DPH. For SPC A and SPC B 3.5- bAVMs, there is unlikely to be a need to do more than avoid postoperative hypertension. For SPC B 3.5+ bAVMs, a larger number of patients would be required to test the absence of benefit of the BP protocol.
引用
- Morgan MK, Wiedmann MKH, Assaad NNA, et al. Deliberate employment of postoperative hypotension for brain arteriovenous malformation surgery and the incidence of delayed postoperative hemorrhage: a prospective cohort study. J Neurosurg. 2016. PMID: 27982772. doi:10.3171/2016.9.JNS161333
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。