低级别胶质瘤分割的评估者自身变异性
本研究探讨一名无分割经验的放射科医师对23例低级别胶质瘤术前3D FLAIR图像进行三次分割的评估者自身变异性。Jaccard系数(J2)从最初两次分割的0.87提高至最后两次的0.90(p=0.04),边界清晰的肿瘤变异性显著更低。作者认为从2D转向3D体积评估需制定肿瘤边界与进展的统一标准。
要点
- 无分割经验放射科医师对低级别胶质瘤的系列分割存在相当大的评估者自身变异性。
- J2从最初两次分割的0.87提高至最后两次的0.90(p=0.04),变异性似乎随经验增加而降低。
- 边界清晰的肿瘤J2(p=0.04)与HD(p<0.01)变异性显著更低,作者认为3D体积评估需制定边界与进展标准。
核心结论
- 连续低级别胶质瘤分割的评估者自身变异性可能相当大,但变异性似乎随经验和肿瘤边界清晰度提高而降低。
- 作者认为若从2D转向3D评估低级别胶质瘤的大小和生长,需制定定义肿瘤边界和进展的若干标准。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入23例低级别胶质瘤的术前3D FLAIR图像,由一名无分割经验的放射科医师在3D Slicer软件中分割三次。
- 计算肿瘤体积及分割间的绝对和相对差异,用Jaccard系数(比较两次分割的J2和三次分割的J3)及Hausdorff距离(HD)量化评估者自身变异性。
主要发现
- J2从最初两次分割的0.87提高至最后两次分割的0.90(p=0.04)。
- 最后两次分割间,较大肿瘤的相对体积差异有更小的趋势(p=0.07)。
- 边界清晰的肿瘤J2(p=0.04)和HD(p<0.01)变异性均显著更低。
- 变异性与组织学亚型或表观扩散系数(ADC)无显著关系。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Assessment of size and growth are key radiological factors in low-grade gliomas (LGGs), both for prognostication and treatment evaluation, but the reliability of LGG-segmentation is scarcely studied. With a diffuse and invasive growth pattern, usually without contrast enhancement, these tumors can be difficult to delineate. The aim of this study was to investigate the intra-observer variability in LGG-segmentation for a radiologist without prior segmentation experience. Pre-operative 3D FLAIR images of 23 LGGs were segmented three times in the software 3D Slicer. Tumor volumes were calculated, together with the absolute and relative difference between the segmentations. To quantify the intra-rater variability, we used the Jaccard coefficient comparing both two (J2) and three (J3) segmentations as well as the Hausdorff Distance (HD). The variability measured with J2 improved significantly between the two last segmentations compared to the two first, going from 0.87 to 0.90 (p = 0.04). Between the last two segmentations, larger tumors showed a tendency towards smaller relative volume difference (p = 0.07), while tumors with well-defined borders had significantly less variability measured with both J2 (p = 0.04) and HD (p < 0.01). We found no significant relationship between variability and histological sub-types or Apparent Diffusion Coefficients (ADC). We found that the intra-rater variability can be considerable in serial LGG-segmentation, but the variability seems to decrease with experience and higher grade of border conspicuity. Our findings highlight that some criteria defining tumor borders and progression in 3D volumetric segmentation is needed, if moving from 2D to 3D assessment of size and growth of LGGs.
引用
- Bø HK, Solheim O, Jakola AS, et al. Intra-rater variability in low-grade glioma segmentation. J Neurooncol. 2016. PMID: 27837437. doi:10.1007/s11060-016-2312-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。