320排非减影与减影容积CT血管造影评估小脑动脉瘤的准确性
研究纳入662例疑似脑动脉瘤患者,以3D DSA为参考标准,评估320排非减影与减影VCTA检测<3 mm小动脉瘤的诊断准确性。减影VCTA敏感度96.9%、特异度99.2%、准确率98.6%,与3D DSA无差异(p=1.000);非减影VCTA敏感度89.8%,显著低于3D DSA(p=0.039)和减影VCTA(p=0.016)。
要点
- 减影VCTA诊断小动脉瘤的敏感度96.9%、特异度99.2%、准确率98.6%,与3D DSA准确率无差异(p=1.000)。
- 非减影VCTA敏感度89.8%,显著低于3D DSA(p=0.039)和减影VCTA(p=0.016)。
- 非减影VCTA漏诊的小动脉瘤几乎均位于颈内动脉、邻近骨组织处。
核心结论
- 减影320排VCTA敏感度足以替代3D DSA诊断<3 mm小脑动脉瘤。
- 非减影VCTA准确率低于减影VCTA和3D DSA,尤其在评估邻近颅底的颈内动脉小动脉瘤时。
研究设计与样本
- 662例疑似脑动脉瘤患者接受320排VCTA和3D DSA检查。
- 5名神经放射科医生独立阅评VCTA和3D DSA图像,以3D DSA为参考标准。
- 分析非减影与减影VCTA检测小动脉瘤的敏感度、特异度和准确率,p<0.05为差异有统计学意义。
主要发现
- 3D DSA在662例中的90例识别出98个小脑动脉瘤。
- 非减影VCTA检出90个小动脉瘤,漏诊10个、误诊2个;按动脉瘤计算敏感度89.8%、特异度99.2%、准确率96.5%。
- 减影VCTA检出97个小动脉瘤,漏诊3个、误诊2个;按动脉瘤计算敏感度96.9%、特异度99.2%、准确率98.6%。
- 减影VCTA与3D DSA准确率无差异(p=1.000);非减影VCTA敏感度显著低于3D DSA(p=0.039)和减影VCTA(p=0.016)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE The study aimed to assess the diagnostic accuracy of 320-detector row nonsubtracted and subtracted volume CT angiography (VCTA) in detecting small cerebral aneurysms (< 3 mm) compared with 3D digital subtraction angiography (3D DSA). METHODS Six hundred sixty-two patients underwent 320-detector row VCTA and 3D DSA for suspected cerebral aneurysms. Five neuroradiologists independently reviewed VCTA and 3D DSA images. The 3D DSA was considered the reference standard, and the sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of nonsubtracted and subtracted VCTA in depicting small aneurysms were analyzed. A p value < 0.05 was considered a significant difference. RESULTS According to 3D DSA images, 98 small cerebral aneurysms were identified in 90 of 662 patients. Nonsubtracted VCTA depicted 90 small aneurysms. Ten small aneurysms were missed, and 2 small aneurysms were misdiagnosed. The missed small aneurysms were located almost in the internal carotid artery, near bone tissue. The sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of nonsubtracted VCTA in depicting small aneurysms were 89.8%, 99.2%, and 96.5%, respectively, on a per-aneurysm basis. Subtracted VCTA depicted 97 small aneurysms. Three small aneurysms were missed, and 2 small aneurysms were misdiagnosed. The sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of subtracted VCTA in depicting small aneurysms were 96.9%, 99.2%, and 98.6%, respectively, on a per-aneurysm basis. There was no difference in accuracy between subtracted VCTA and 3D DSA (p = 1.000). However, nonsubtracted VCTA had significantly less sensitivity than 3D DSA and subtracted VCTA (p = 0.039 and 0.016, respectively). CONCLUSIONS Subtracted 320-detector row VCTA is sensitive enough to replace 3D DSA in the diagnosis of small cerebral aneurysms (< 3 mm). The accuracy rate of nonsubtracted VCTA was lower than that of subtracted VCTA and 3D DSA, especially in the assessment of small internal carotid artery aneurysms adjacent to the skull base.
引用
- Chen W, Xing W, He Z, et al. Accuracy of 320-detector row nonsubtracted and subtracted volume CT angiography in evaluating small cerebral aneurysms. J Neurosurg. 2016. PMID: 27813462. doi:10.3171/2016.8.JNS16238
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。