环钻术或为早期颅内减压的可行形式
本文为历史神经外科学术综述,重新解读史前环钻术的功能目的。作者提出部分史前环钻可能是有意义的早期经验性颅内减压。最强定量证据来自秘鲁库斯科系列:66 例环钻个体共 109 处穿孔,26 例(39%)有多个开口。古希腊、瑞士晚期铁器时代、法国新石器时代、西班牙铜石并用时代及加那利群岛材料提供趋同但方法学异质的证据。
要点
- 秘鲁库斯科系列 66 例环钻个体共 109 处穿孔,26 例(39%)有多个开口。
- 多部位、重复环钻提示反复颅骨干预在人群中并非个别现象。
- 存活、重复干预、技术改进与创伤关联支持环钻曾起减压作用。
核心结论
- 部分史前环钻术可能是早期经验性的颅内减压手段,是颅骨减压历史长链中的经验性前身。
研究设计与样本
- 历史神经外科学解释性综述,汇总秘鲁库斯科、古希腊、瑞士晚期铁器时代、法国新石器时代、西班牙铜石并用时代及加那利群岛的环钻材料。
主要发现
- 库斯科地区秘鲁系列中 66 例环钻个体共 109 处穿孔,26 例(39%)有多个开口。
- 古希腊、瑞士晚期铁器时代、法国新石器时代与西班牙铜石并用时代报道了重复或多处颅骨干预,证据趋同但方法学异质。
- 加那利群岛材料独立支持与存活相容的有意颅骨操作的合理性,近期关契人发现提示前西班牙时期颅骨手术可能包含不止一种干预形式。
关键数值与推荐
- 库斯科系列:66 例环钻个体、109 处穿孔、26 例(39%)有多个开口。
- 作者判断依据为存活、重复干预、技术改进与创伤关联的综合证据,而非正式颅内压概念。
临床怎么用
- 为理解颅骨减压的历史演变提供视角,提示环钻在部分个案中可能具有减压功能,但不改变现代神经外科减压指征与操作规范。
局限性
- 各古代人群证据方法学异质,无法统一量化比较。
- 古代施术者缺乏正式颅内压概念,功能推断属解释性而非直接证据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Trepanation is widely recognized as the earliest known cranial operation, yet its functional purpose remains debated. Traditional interpretations have emphasized ritual practice, treatment of cranial trauma, or empirical responses to neurological symptoms. We propose a focused historical-neurosurgical interpretation: that a meaningful subset of prehistoric trepanations may represent a plausible early empirical form of cranial decompression. The strongest quantitative evidence comes from the Cusco-region Peruvian series, in which 66 trepanned individuals accounted for 109 perforations and 26 individuals (39%) had multiple openings, suggesting that repeated cranial intervention was epidemiologically meaningful rather than anecdotal. Additional reports from ancient Greece, Late Iron Age Switzerland, Neolithic France, and Chalcolithic Spain provide convergent, though methodologically heterogeneous, evidence of repeated or multiple cranial intervention across independent populations. Canary Islands material independently supports the broader plausibility of intentional cranial procedures compatible with survival, while recent Guanche findings suggest that prehispanic cranial surgery may have included more than one form of intervention. Although ancient practitioners lacked a formal concept of intracranial pressure, the combined evidence of survival, repeated intervention, technical refinement, and trauma association supports the view that, in at least some cases, trepanation functioned as a pragmatic pressure-relieving cranial procedure and may represent an early empirical antecedent in the long historical arc of cranial decompression.
引用
- Castañeyra-Ruiz L, Castañeyra-Ruiz M, Velasco-Vázquez J, et al. Trepanation as a Plausible Early Form of Cranial Decompression. World Neurosurg. 2026. PMID: 42498229. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2026.125206
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。