神经外科新闻稿的科学准确性在公众报道中是否受损?
该研究评估了EurekAlert!上100篇神经外科相关新闻稿,使用经过验证的spin分类模型分析误导性报道。结果显示73%的新闻稿存在至少一种spin形式,37%的标题具有误导性,在体外或动物研究中50%不当外推至人类。作者呼吁提高研究者对公众沟通准确性的认识。
要点
- 73%的神经外科新闻稿存在至少一种spin形式。
- 37%的新闻稿标题具有误导性,常夸大发现或暗示超出研究范围的临床意义。
- 体外或动物研究中50%不当外推至人类。
核心结论
- 神经外科新闻稿可能为吸引公众关注而歪曲科学研究,误导性新闻稿可能给患者及家属带来虚假希望或导致不良健康决策。
研究设计与样本
- 使用检索词「Neurosurgery」在EurekAlert!上识别2022年10月至2024年10月间发表的100篇符合纳入标准的神经外科相关新闻稿,由三名研究人员独立提取数据并用共识解决分歧。
主要发现
- 功能神经外科是代表性最强的亚专业(43%),其次为脑肿瘤(14%)、血管(9%)、脊柱(6%)、儿科(6%)和技术/人工智能(6%)。
- 37%的新闻稿标题具有误导性,常夸大发现或暗示超出研究范围的临床意义。
- 在描述体外或动物研究的新闻稿中,50%不当外推结果至人类。
- 93%的新闻稿包含文章作者的引述。
- 总体73%的新闻稿包含至少一种spin形式,最常见为误导性报道(44%)、误导性声明(29%)和不当外推(22%)。
临床怎么用
- 神经外科研究者应意识到新闻稿可能歪曲研究,并主动参与公众沟通以确保准确性。
- 临床医生可提醒患者及家属谨慎解读神经外科研究新闻稿,避免基于误导信息做出健康决策。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Press releases describing medical research are commonly used by academic medical centers to present their research to public audiences. Press releases may be written by public relations teams who lack formal scientific training and aim to generate publicity surrounding new research. To the authors' knowledge, press releases on neurosurgery have not been assessed for their presentation and potential misrepresentation of scientific findings. METHODS: Using the search term <Neurosurgery>, the authors identified the 100 most recent press releases published on EurekAlert! (eurekalert.org) between October 2022 and October 2024 that met inclusion criteria. Each was evaluated using a validated spin classification model to assess for misleading reporting, claims, or inappropriate extrapolation. Titles, article authors, quotations, and study limitations were also reviewed. Three members of the research team independently extracted data on predefined variables and resolved discrepancies by consensus. RESULTS: The authors identified 100 eligible neurosurgery-related press releases. Functional neurosurgery was the most frequently represented subspecialty (43%), followed by brain tumor (14%), vascular (9%), spine (6%), pediatrics (6%), and technology/AI (6%). About one-third of press release titles (37%) were misleading, often exaggerating findings or implying clinical implications beyond the scope of the research. Among press releases describing in vitro or animal studies, 50% inappropriately extrapolated results to humans. Quotations from article authors appeared in 93% of press releases. Overall, 73% of press releases contained at least one form of spin-most commonly misleading reporting (44%), misleading claims (29%), and inappropriate extrapolation (22%). CONCLUSIONS: Press releases may misrepresent scientific research for the sake of generating publicity. Patients may rely on press releases for a simplified summary of research. Misleading press releases could give patients and their families false hope and/or cause patients to make adverse decisions about their health. The authors hope that these results will increase awareness among researchers in neurosurgery about the way their work is communicated to the public and inspire the release of more accurate neurosurgery press releases in the future.
引用
- Sugarmann LR, Sternberg-Sher J, Feler JR, et al. Press releases in neurosurgery: is scientific accuracy compromised in public reporting of neurosurgery research? J Neurosurg. 2026. PMID: 42398109. doi:10.3171/2026.1.JNS251863
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。