AI评估模拟肿瘤切除中不同深度手术技术适应性的病例系列研究
本研究使用AI实时性能评估系统,在模拟脑肿瘤切除任务中评估神经外科医生、高级住院医师、初级住院医师和医学生的表现,测试专家在不同深度维持专家水平而学员分数随深度下降的假设。结果显示神经外科医生在各深度维持表现,高级住院医师分数随深度增加而下降,但医学生和初级住院医师在更深部位复合分数反而升高(仍属新手范围),且无论专业水平如何出血风险随深度增加呈上升趋势。
要点
- 神经外科医生在0-15mm各深度间维持专家级表现分数。
- 高级住院医师分数随手术深度增加而下降。
- 医学生和初级住院医师在更深部位复合分数升高但仍属新手范围。
核心结论
- 各专业水平在不同深度呈现独特反应,提示需要适应学员技能水平和个体学习曲线的自适应训练模块。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性单中心病例系列研究,最终分析45名参与者(神经外科医生14名、高级住院医师14名、初级住院医师10名、医学生12名),排除5名左利手参与者。
- 使用智能持续专长监测系统(AI驱动实时性能评估系统)在虚拟现实模拟复杂脑肿瘤切除任务中评估手术表现。
主要发现
- 神经外科医生在各深度维持表现分数,展现专家水平。
- 高级住院医师分数随深度增加而下降。
- 医学生和初级住院医师在更深手术部位复合分数升高,但分数仍在新手范围。
- 出血风险随深度增加呈上升趋势,与专业水平无关。
关键数值与推荐
- 测量指标包括器械尖端分离距离、出血风险、健康组织损伤风险、吸引器施加力、双极电凝施加力及总体复合分数。
- 每个深度区间(0-15 mm)各指标的平均分数按专业水平计算用于统计比较。
临床怎么用
- 可利用AI实时评估系统识别学员在不同深度的手术技术薄弱点。
- 训练模块应适应学员技能水平和个体学习曲线,以掌握挑战性任务所需能力。
局限性
- 回顾性单中心分析。
- 排除左利手参与者以避免手优势混杂。
- 样本量有限(最终分析45名参与者)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Surgical procedures involving varying tissue depths present challenges to surgeons regarding accessibility and precision, restricting instrument movement and increasing the risk of tissue injury. Understanding how experts navigate varying depths is essential, yet research on this issue is limited. Artificial intelligence (AI)-powered systems enable real-time analysis of 3D psychomotor performance during virtual reality simulation tasks. In this study, the authors evaluated performance in a complex brain tumor resection simulation, testing two hypotheses: 1) neurosurgeons' performance scores would remain at an expert level across varying depths, and 2) trainees' scores would decline as they navigated into deeper and more challenging areas. METHODS: Participants included neurosurgeons (n = 14), senior trainees (n = 14), junior trainees (n = 10), and medical students (n = 12). Five left-handed participants were excluded to avoid confounding due to hand dominance, resulting in a final analyzed sample of 45 participants. The Intelligent Continuous Expertise Monitoring System, an AI-powered real-time performance assessment system, assessed surgical performance and measured metrics such as instrument tip separation distance, bleeding risk, healthy tissue injury risk, aspirator force applied, bipolar cautery force applied, and an overall composite score. An average score for each metric at each depth interval (0-15 mm) was calculated across expertise levels for statistical comparison in a retrospective single-center analysis. RESULTS: Neurosurgeons maintained their performance score across varying depths, demonstrating their expertise. Senior trainees had lower scores with increased depth. Surprisingly, increased depth resulted in higher composite scores among medical students and junior trainees, as they had to adapt better instrument techniques in deeper surgical sites. However, their scores remained in the novice spectrum. There was an increasing trend in bleeding risk with greater depth regardless of the expertise level, indicating the more challenging nature of deeper sites. CONCLUSIONS: The unique responses observed at varying depths at each expertise level indicate the necessity for adaptive training modules that accommodate trainee skill set levels and individual learning curves, ensuring development of the competencies required for mastering challenging tasks.
引用
- Filiz M, Yilmaz R, Tee T, et al. AI assessment of surgical technical skill adaptation across depth levels in simulated tumor resection: a case series study. J Neurosurg. 2026. PMID: 42066367. doi:10.3171/2025.12.JNS251528
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。