先天性颈椎病变运动员重返运动共识:改良Delphi专家调查
针对先天性颈椎病变运动员重返运动(RTS)决策缺乏推荐的问题,国际神经外科与骨科脊柱外科专家小组开展横断面改良Delphi共识调查,采用≥70%共识阈值。结果显示,C1环异常无神经失用事件、枕化C1、1个运动节段Klippel-Feil综合征及无脊髓空洞的无症状Chiari畸形,达成≥70%共识可重返高冲击/高频率运动;先天性椎管狭窄伴≥2次神经失用事件则共识建议不应重返运动。
要点
- C1环异常无神经失用事件等四种情况共识可重返高冲击/高频率运动。
- 先天性椎管狭窄伴≥2次神经失用事件共识建议不应重返运动。
- 其他情形未达共识,需个体化决策。
核心结论
- C1环异常无神经失用事件、枕化C1、1个运动节段Klippel-Feil综合征及无脊髓空洞的无症状Chiari畸形,达成≥70%共识可重返高冲击/高频率运动。
- 先天性椎管狭窄伴≥2次神经失用事件,达成共识建议不应重返运动。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面改良Delphi共识调查,邀请34名具有运动专长的国际神经外科/骨科脊柱外科医生,问卷完成率100%。
- 采用2×2方案按冲击力和频率将运动风险分为低冲击/低频率、低冲击/高频率、高冲击/低频率和高冲击/高频率四类。
- 共识先验定义为≥70%。
主要发现
- C1环异常且无既往神经失用事件、枕化C1、1个运动节段Klippel-Feil综合征(伴或不伴后凸)及无脊髓空洞的无症状Chiari畸形,达成≥70%共识推荐重返高冲击/高频率运动。
- 先天性椎管狭窄且经历至少2次神经失用事件的运动员,达成共识建议不应重返运动。
- 其他领域未达成共识,文中讨论了值得注意的发现。
关键数值与推荐
- 共识阈值:≥70%。
- 推荐重返高冲击/高频率运动的情形:C1环异常无既往神经失用事件、枕化C1、1个运动节段Klippel-Feil综合征、无脊髓空洞的无症状Chiari畸形。
- 建议不应重返运动的情形:先天性椎管狭窄伴≥2次神经失用事件。
临床怎么用
- 对先天性颈椎病变运动员,可参考本共识对特定情形(如C1环异常无神经失用事件、枕化C1、1个节段Klippel-Feil、无脊髓空洞的无症状Chiari畸形)评估重返高冲击/高频率运动的可行性。
- 先天性椎管狭窄伴≥2次神经失用事件者,应建议不重返运动。
- 未达成共识的情形需结合个体情况多学科评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Recommendations guiding participation in sports for athletes with congenital cervical spine pathology are lacking, and management of these athletes remains challenging. Thus, the objective was to perform a modified Delphi consensus survey of expert opinion on return-to-sport (RTS) decisions in athletes with congenital cervical spine pathologies. METHODS: A cross-sectional, modified Delphi consensus survey investigating RTS decisions in athletes with various types of congenital cervical spine pathology was undertaken. An international panel of neurosurgery/orthopedic spine surgeons with sport expertise was identified. The cervical spine pathologies studied were craniocervical anomalies, Klippel-Feil syndrome, os odontoideum, Chiari malformation, and congenital cervical stenosis. A 2 × 2 scheme was used to classify sport risk based on impact forces and frequency : low impact/low frequency, low impact/high frequency, high impact/low frequency, and high impact/high frequency. Consensus was a-priori defined at ≥70%. Descriptive statistics were performed. RESULTS: Of the 34 sports spine surgeons invited (56% neurosurgeons and 44% orthopedic surgeons), survey completion was 100%. The following scenarios achieved ≥70% consensus to recommend athletes to return-to-play high impact/high frequency sports: C1 ring anomaly and no prior neurapraxic event, occipitalized C1, Klippel-Feil of 1 motion segment with/without kyphosis, and asymptomatic Chiari malformation without syrinx. Consensus was also achieved that an athlete with congenital stenosis who has experienced at least 2 neurapraxic events should be advised not to RTS. Although consensus was not achieved in other areas, notable findings are discussed. CONCLUSION: The following scenarios reached ≥70% consensus recommending athletes to return to high impact/high frequency sports: C1 ring anomaly without a prior neurapraxic event, occipitalized C1, Klippel-Feil syndrome involving 1 motion segment, and asymptomatic Chiari malformation without a syrinx. In addition, consensus was reached advising athletes with congenital stenosis with 2 or more neurapraxic events not to RTS. Although consensus was not obtained in other areas, notable findings are discussed.
引用
- Zuckerman SL, Jo J, Rigney GH, et al. Return-to-Sport Recommendations for Athletes With Congenital Cervical Spine Pathology: A Modified Delphi Consensus Survey of Expert Opinion. Neurosurgery. 2025. PMID: 40576340. doi:10.1227/neu.0000000000003576
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。