指南与共识功能神经外科

理解标准化推荐信在减少2020年神经外科匹配申请者性别偏见中的作用

Understanding the role of standardized letters of recommendation in reducing gender bias for applicants to the neurosurgery match 2020.
指南 / 共识 · J Neurosurg · 2025-05-02

本研究回顾性分析单中心神经外科培训项目2020年收到的910封叙述性推荐信和566封标准化推荐信,用MATLAB脚本进行定量语言分析。女性申请者更常收到最低保证信(5% vs 1%)和被教学类词语描述(p=0.0038),标准化推荐信叙述部分仍存在该差异;百分位排名和匹配率无差异。作者认为标准化推荐信可能有助于减少叙述性偏见。

要点

  • 女性申请者收到最低保证信比例高于男性(5% vs 1%)。
  • 女性申请者被教学类词语描述的比例更高(p=0.0038)。
  • 百分位排名和匹配率无性别差异。

核心结论

  • 女性在叙述性推荐信中更常收到最低保证信并被教学类词语描述,提示存在性别偏见。
  • 匹配数据质量差难以确定该偏见是否影响匹配结果,但本研究提示无影响。
  • 标准化推荐信可能有助于减少已发现的叙述性偏见。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性分析单中心神经外科培训项目2020年电子住院医师申请服务系统提交的申请。
  • 共分析910封叙述性推荐信和566封标准化推荐信。
  • 申请者中71%为男性,29%为女性。
  • 使用自定义MATLAB脚本进行定量语言分析,并比较美国医师执照考试第一步成绩。

主要发现

  • 推荐信长度、每位申请者推荐信总数及第一步成绩无性别差异。
  • 女性申请者更常收到最低保证信(5% vs 1%)。
  • 女性申请者更常被教学类词语描述(p=0.0038),该差异在仅评估标准化推荐信叙述部分时持续存在。
  • 百分位排名或匹配率无差异。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 匹配数据质量差,难以确定性别偏见是否影响匹配结果。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: Women are underrepresented in neurosurgical training, with progressively fewer women in successive ranks. Letters of recommendation (LORs) are crucial for granting residency interviews, but data suggest they are biased by the applicant's gender, with women applicants receiving lower-quality letters. This study examines whether the standardized LOR (SLOR) format, introduced in the 2020 neurosurgery match, reduces gender bias. METHODS: The authors reviewed Electronic Residency Application Service applications submitted to a single neurosurgery training program in 2020. LORs were separated by applicant gender and subjected to quantitative linguistic analysis using a custom MATLAB script. LORs were assessed for length, classification as letters of minimal assurance, and gendered stereotypic adjectives. An LOR provides an overall assessment of a candidate's potential and typically includes a description of the writer's relationship to the applicant, a description of intent as demonstrated by the record of the applicant, and a review of the applicant's accomplishments. Omission of any of these three components gives the reader only a partial grasp of a candidate's qualifications, resulting in a letter of minimal assurance. Gendered stereotypic adjectives are the result of a significant body of research devoted to analysis of gender differences in language. These adjectives fall within five word groups: standout, ability, research, grindstone, and teaching, with the latter two categories more often being used to describe females. SLORs were analyzed by noting the percentile ranking in each category. United States Medical Licensing Examination Step 1 scores were compared. Univariate analysis was performed for each LOR variable, using two-tailed t-tests. The distribution of SLOR percentile rankings was evaluated using a Kolmogorov-Smirnov test. A p value < 0.05 was considered significant. Lastly, match outcome data were analyzed to assess impact on outcome. RESULTS: The authors reviewed 910 narrative LORs (NLORs) and 566 SLORs. Of the applicants, 71% were male and 29% were female. There were no significant differences in LOR length, total letters per applicant, or Step 1 scores by gender. Female applicants were more likely to have received letters of minimal assurance (5% vs 1%) and be described by teaching words (p = 0.0038). This difference persisted when evaluating narrative portions from SLORs alone. There were no differences in percentile rankings or match rates. CONCLUSIONS: Women receive more letters of minimal assurance and are more likely to be described with teaching words in NLORs, indicating a gender bias. Whether this influences match outcome is difficult to determine based on poor match data, but the present research suggests it does not. Nevertheless, SLORs may help to reduce the identified narrative bias.

来源:J Neurosurg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Payne CA, Fontaine D, Hong J, et al. Understanding the role of standardized letters of recommendation in reducing gender bias for applicants to the neurosurgery match 2020. J Neurosurg. 2025. PMID: 40315605. doi:10.3171/2025.1.JNS231903

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。