脑与脊髓海绵状血管畸形诊断和临床管理指南:基于系统文献综述的共识推荐——治愈海绵状血管畸形联盟临床咨询委员会专家组
治愈海绵状血管畸形联盟召集多学科专家组,系统综述2014年10月1日至2023年3月15日间2672篇文献并筛选234篇,围绕流行病学与自然史、基因检测与咨询、诊断标准与影像标准、神经外科考量、神经内科考量5个主题制定53条管理推荐,经德尔菲法达成一致共识,按美国心脏协会/美国卒中协会标准评级:1级18条(34%)、2级31条(58%)、3级4条(8%);证据级别A级3条(6%)、B级19条(36%)、C级31条(58%)。
要点
- 专家组系统综述2014年10月1日至2023年3月15日文献,筛选234篇制定53条推荐。
- 53条推荐经德尔菲法达成一致共识,按美国心脏协会/美国卒中协会标准评级。
- 推荐等级:1级18条(34%)、2级31条(58%)、3级4条(8%);证据级别A级3条(6%)、B级19条(36%)、C级31条(58%)。
核心结论
- 当前证据支持既往及新的海绵状血管畸形管理推荐,但许多推荐为中等推荐等级和低证据级别,需进一步研究以更好指导临床实践。
研究设计与样本
- 治愈海绵状血管畸形联盟召集多学科专家写作组,聚焦流行病学与自然史、基因检测与咨询、诊断标准与影像标准、神经外科考量、神经内科考量5个主题。
- 在2014年10月前证据推荐基础上,系统综述2014年10月1日至2023年3月15日间2672篇符合关键词标准的文献,按预设标准筛选234篇强制引用文献。
- 写作组评估证据、制定推荐,经德尔菲法达成一致共识,按美国心脏协会/美国卒中协会标准评级,并列出知识空白与争议。
主要发现
- 从2672篇文献中筛选234篇用于证据推荐。
- 共形成53条管理推荐,经德尔菲法达成一致共识。
- 推荐等级:1级18条(34%)、2级31条(58%)、3级4条(8%)。
- 证据级别:A级3条(6%)、B级19条(36%)、C级31条(58%)。
关键数值与推荐
- 推荐等级按美国心脏协会/美国卒中协会标准分为1级18条(34%)、2级31条(58%)、3级4条(8%)。
- 证据级别按美国心脏协会/美国卒中协会标准分为A级3条(6%)、B级19条(36%)、C级31条(58%)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出具体临床推荐。
局限性
- 许多推荐为中等推荐等级和低证据级别,需进一步研究以更好指导临床实践。
- 写作组列出了剩余知识空白与争议以指导未来研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Despite many publications about cavernous malformations (CMs), controversy remains regarding diagnostic and management strategies. To update evidence-based guidelines for the clinical management of brain and spinal cord CMs. METHODS: The Alliance to Cure CMs, the patient support group in the United States advocating on behalf of patients and research in CM, convened a multidisciplinary writing group comprising expert CM clinicians to help summarize the existing literature related to the clinical care of CM, focusing on 5 topics: (1) epidemiology and natural history, (2) genetic testing and counseling, (3) diagnostic criteria and imaging standards, (4) neurosurgical considerations, and (5) neurological considerations. Building on prior evidence-based recommendations reflecting literature review through October 2014, the group conducted a systematic review of the more recent literature, identified references for mandatory citation, rated evidence, developed recommendations, and established consensus according to a prespecified protocol. Finally, the writing group outlined remaining knowledge gaps and controversies to guide future research. RESULTS: From 2672 publications published between October 1, 2014, and March 15, 2023, and meeting key word criteria, 234 were selected based on prearticulated criteria for mandatory consideration in evidence-based recommendations. Topic authors used these and other supporting references to summarize current knowledge and arrive at 53 management recommendations, with unanimous consensus based on a Delphi process. These were rated by class (strength of recommendation) and level (quality of evidence) per the American Heart Association/American Stroke Association criteria. Eighteen recommendations were class 1 (34%), class 2 in 31 (58%), and class 3 in 4 (8%). Three were level A (6%), 19 (36%) were level B, and 31 (58%) were level C. CONCLUSION: Current evidence supports prior and new recommendations for the management of CMs, but many reflect moderate classes and low levels, mandating further research to better inform clinical practice.
引用
- Akers AL, Albanese J, Alcazar-Felix RJ, et al. Guidelines for the Diagnosis and Clinical Management of Cavernous Malformations of the Brain and Spinal Cord: Consensus Recommendations Based on a Systematic Literature Review by the Alliance to Cure Cavernous Malformation Clinical Advisory Board Experts Panel. Neurosurgery. 2025. PMID: 40396744. doi:10.1227/neu.0000000000003459
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。