术中CT血管造影与术后DSA检测未破裂颅内动脉瘤夹闭术后残留:临床相关性与随访
该研究分析了2012年11月至2019年12月在本中心接受择期动脉瘤夹闭术的270例患者,评估术中CT血管造影(iCTA)检测残留的价值及术后DSA随访结果。iCTA检测Sindou III-IV级残留的敏感度75%、特异度100%、准确率98.6%,可术中发现大残留并调整手术策略;术后DSA显示Sindou I-II级残留11.9%、III-V级3.0%,平均随访29个月期间所有Sindou I-II级及5例III-V级残留均未出现增大或破裂。
要点
- iCTA检测Sindou III-IV级残留的敏感度75%、特异度100%、准确率98.6%。
- iCTA组检出3/74例(4.1%)大残留,其中2例重新夹闭、1例建议血管内治疗。
- 术后DSA检出Sindou I-II级残留32/270例(11.9%)、III-V级8/270例(3.0%),3例需再治疗。
核心结论
- 夹闭术后动脉瘤残留少见且多为小型(Sindou I-II级),短期随访未发现增大或破裂风险。
- 术中CTA可检测大型动脉瘤残留(Sindou III-IV级),并可能促使个别病例调整手术策略。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心回顾性分析,纳入2012年11月至2019年12月在本中心接受择期动脉瘤夹闭术的患者,2024年1月进行随访。
- 共270例患者纳入分析(367例入组、97例排除),其中74例使用了术中CT血管造影(iCTA)。
- 所有患者均接受吲哚菁绿视频血管造影(ICGVA)和术后数字减影血管造影(pDSA)。
- 2016年10月iCTA实施后,多数患者额外接受iCTA。
- 分析基线特征、治疗相关并发症/结局、有无iCTA的不同队列中由此产生的手术决策,以及按Sindou分类的残留管理。
主要发现
- 12/270例(4.5%)患者因ICGVA结果行夹闭调整,iCTA进一步在3/74例(4.1%)患者中术中检测到大残留,其中2例重新夹闭、1例建议血管内治疗。
- iCTA检测Sindou III-IV级残留的敏感度为75%、特异度为100%、准确率为98.6%。
- 术后DSA检出Sindou I-II级残留32/270例(11.9%)、Sindou III-V级残留8/270例(3.0%),3/270例需再治疗(1例再手术、2例血管内治疗)。
- iCTA组与非iCTA组Sindou I-V级残留频率分别为10.8%与16.3%(p < 0.173),III-V级残留频率分别为1.4%与3.6%(p < 0.306),iCTA组略低但未达统计学显著。
- 平均随访29个月,所有Sindou I-II级残留及5例Sindou III-V级残留均未出现增大或破裂。
临床怎么用
- 术中CTA可检测大型动脉瘤残留(Sindou III-IV级),并可能促使个别病例调整手术策略。
- 夹闭术后动脉瘤残留少见且多为小型(Sindou I-II级),短期随访未发现增大或破裂风险。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Aneurysm clipping is routinely performed with high efficacy and low complication rates in specialized neurovascular centers. Postoperative aneurysm remnants bear the risk of growth/rupture. Study aim was to analyze remnants in postoperative angiography (pDSA) and follow-up (FU) and to evaluate whether use of intraoperative CT-angiography (iCTA) can intraoperatively detect remnants and enable therapeutic consequences. METHODS: All patients undergoing elective aneurysm clipping at our center between 11/2012 and 12/2019 were included for FU in 01/2024. All patients received Indocyanin-green-videoangiography (ICGVA) and postoperative angiography (pDSA). After iCTA implementation in 10/2016, the majority of patients received additionally iCTA. Baseline characteristics, treatment-related morbidity/outcome, resulting operative conclusions in distinct cohorts with/without iCTA, and management of remnants according to Sindou classification were analyzed. RESULTS: 270 patients (367 enrolled/97 excluded) were clipped using iCTA in 74 patients. In 12/270 patients (4.5%) clip repositioning was performed due to ICGVA results, but iCTA further detected large remnants intraoperatively in 3/74 patients (4.1%) correctly resulting in re-clipping in two patients and recommendation for endovascular therapy in one patient. The specificity, sensitivity, and accuracy for detection of Sindou grade (SG) III-IV remnants by iCTA were 100%, 75%, and 98.6%, respectively. Overall, pDSA detected SG I-II remnants in 32/270 (11.9%) and SG III-V remnants in 8/270 (3.0%) patients with 3/270 requiring retreatment (n = 1 resurgery, n = 2 endovascular therapy). Frequency of SG I-V and III-V remnants were slightly lower in iCTA than non-iCTA group (10.8 vs. 16.3%, p < 0.173 and 1.4 vs. 3.6%, p < 0.306). All SG I-II and five SG III-V remnants did not reveal growth/rupture after a mean FU of 29 months. CONCLUSIONS: Aneurysm remnants after clipping are rare and predominantly small (SGI-II)-not harbouring a risk of growth/rupture during short-term FU. Intraoperative CTA can detect large aneurysm remnants (SG III-IV) and may prompt adjustment of surgical strategy in individual cases.
引用
- Thorsteinsdottir J, Schwarting J, Forbrig R, et al. Detection of remnants in clipped unruptured intracranial aneurysms by intraoperative CT-angiography and postoperative DSA: clinical relevance and follow-up. Acta Neurochir (Wien). 2025. PMID: 40240681. doi:10.1007/s00701-025-06518-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。