伦理与资源对创伤性脑损伤手术分配的影响:低收入与中等收入国家及高收入国家神经外科医生的调查
该调查通过在线问卷收集了63名神经外科医生及学员对创伤性脑损伤手术决策的看法,受访者来自低收入和/或中等收入国家(27%)及高收入国家(73%,n=46)。多数受访者认为患者手术需求是决策的首要患者层面因素(61%,n=35/57),手术室空间是主要系统层面因素(71%,n=35/49);受访者普遍认为最重优先和预后是最公平的资源分配原则。
要点
- 61%(n=35/57)的神经外科医生报告患者手术需求是决策的首要患者层面驱动因素。
- 71%(n=35/49)的神经外科医生报告手术室空间是主要系统层面因素。
- 受访者普遍认为最重优先和预后是最公平的资源分配原则。
核心结论
- 受访者在决定手术时通常优先考虑患者的手术需求、预期获益以及手术室容量等系统因素。
- 在手术容量有限的情况下,受访者同时优先考虑最重的患者和预后最好的患者。
- 未来研究应探索如何在资源匮乏环境中以公正公平的方式达成一致的决策框架。
研究设计与样本
- 对神经外科医生及学员进行的在线调查,询问神经外科容量有限时创伤性脑损伤的手术决策。
- 调查包括患者层面因素(如患者手术需求或死亡率改善潜力)和系统层面因素(如手术室和床位可用性)对决策的影响,以及若干资源分配原则应用于创伤性脑损伤手术时的感知公平性。
- 63名受访者来自低收入和/或中等收入国家(27%)及高收入国家(73%,n=46)。
主要发现
- 多数神经外科医生(61%,n=35/57)报告患者手术需求是决策的首要患者层面驱动因素。
- 手术室空间是主要系统层面因素(71%,n=35/49)。
- 神经外科医生普遍认为最重优先和预后是最公平的资源分配原则。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Scarce resource allocation in traumatic brain injury (TBI) care is ethically challenging. We surveyed neurosurgeons about their views on surgical decision-making in TBI in resource-limited settings. METHODS: Neurosurgeons and trainees completed an online survey about surgical decision-making for TBI when neurosurgical capacity is limited. The survey included questions about the impact of patient-level factors (such as the patient's need for surgery or potential for improvement in mortality) and system-level factors (such as operating theater and bed space availability) on decision-making, as well as the perceived fairness of several resource allocation principles when applied to TBI surgery. RESULTS: The 63 respondents were from low- and/or middle-income countries (27%) and high-income countries (73%, n = 46). Most neurosurgeons (61%, n = 35/57) reported the patient's need for surgery as the primary patient-level driver of decision-making, and operating room space was the main system-level factor (71%, n = 35/49). Neurosurgeons generally thought sickest-first and prognosis were the fairest resource allocation principles. CONCLUSIONS: Respondents generally prioritized their patients' need for surgery, projected benefits, and system considerations such as operating theater capacity in their decision to operate. Respondents prioritized both the sickest patients and those with the best prognosis in the setting of limited surgical capacity. Future research should explore how to work towards an agreed-upon framework for decision-making in resource-scarce settings in a just and equitable way.
引用
- Hughes JG, Spears CA, Kelly-Hedrick M, et al. The Impact of Ethics and Resources on the Allocation of Traumatic Brain Injury Surgery: A Survey of Neurosurgeons Within Low- and Middle-Income Countries and High-Income Countries. World Neurosurg. 2025. PMID: 40180036. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2025.123950
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。