文献速递脊柱脊髓外科

职业橄榄球运动员创伤性颈椎损伤后重返赛场:美国国家橄榄球联盟脊柱外科专家的意见

Return to play in professional football players following traumatic cervical spine injury: expert opinions from the National Football League spine surgeons.
PubMed 文献 · J Neurosurg Spine · 2024-12-20

该研究向美国国家橄榄球联盟(NFL)全部脊柱损伤专科顾问医师发放横断面在线问卷,覆盖神经根病、脊髓病、单侧小关节骨折、单侧小关节脱位及颈部疼痛伴MRI韧带STIR信号五类颈椎损伤情景。共26名来自21支球队(66%)的医师回复,结果显示前路手术最常用于椎间盘突出所致神经根病或脊髓病(分别为73%和88%),重返赛场决策受症状改善、无痛活动度及影像学融合或骨折愈合影响。

要点

  • 椎间盘突出致神经根病或脊髓病时,前路手术最常被推荐(分别为73%和88%)。
  • 无移位单侧小关节骨折初次处理首选硬质颈托(68%),单侧小关节脱位首选单节段前路融合(56%)。
  • 神经根病后重返赛场的常见标准包括查体正常(85%)、术后影像学融合(58%)和无痛活动度(50%)。

核心结论

  • 职业橄榄球运动员颈椎损伤后重返赛场的决策复杂,受症状改善、无痛活动度和影像学融合或骨折愈合证据影响。
  • 受访者倾向于对椎间盘突出所致神经根病和脊髓病行前路颈椎间盘切除融合术,对单侧小关节骨折使用硬质矫形器,对单侧小关节脱位行手术。

研究设计与样本

  • 横断面在线问卷研究,发放给所有专攻脊柱损伤管理的NFL顾问医师。
  • 问卷覆盖五类颈椎损伤临床情景:神经根病、脊髓病、单侧小关节骨折、单侧小关节脱位、颈部疼痛伴MRI韧带STIR信号。
  • 共26名来自32支球队中21支(66%)的医师回复。

主要发现

  • 椎间盘突出致神经根病时前路手术推荐率为73%,致脊髓病时为88%。
  • 无移位单侧小关节骨折初次处理中68%的专家偏好硬质颈托,单侧小关节脱位中56%偏好单节段前路融合。
  • 神经根病后重返赛场的常见标准包括查体正常(85%)、术后影像学融合(58%)和无痛活动度(50%)。
  • 重返赛场的禁忌包括持续狭窄(35%)、不稳定(31%)、多节段融合(27%)和持续脊髓信号改变(23%)。
  • 小关节骨折或脱位后重返赛场的附加标准包括影像学骨折愈合证据(分别为32%和24%)和正常屈伸位X线片(分别为24%和32%);孤立韧带STIR信号改变者中36%要求MRI表现消退后方可重返赛场。

关键数值与推荐

  • 椎间盘突出致神经根病时前路手术推荐率73%,致脊髓病时88%。
  • 无移位单侧小关节骨折初次处理中硬质颈托偏好率68%,单侧小关节脱位中单节段前路融合偏好率56%。
  • 神经根病后重返赛场标准:查体正常85%、术后影像学融合58%、无痛活动度50%。
  • 重返赛场禁忌:持续狭窄35%、不稳定31%、多节段融合27%、持续脊髓信号改变23%。
  • 小关节骨折或脱位后重返赛场附加标准:影像学骨折愈合证据分别为32%和24%,正常屈伸位X线片分别为24%和32%;孤立韧带STIR信号改变者中36%要求MRI表现消退。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: There is a paucity of high-quality return-to-play (RTP) data following treatment of cervical spine injuries in contact sports. In this study, the authors gathered insights from National Football League (NFL) team spine surgeon consultants to highlight current practices in treating cervical spine injuries and report decision-making regarding RTP in professional American football players. METHODS: A cross-sectional, online survey was distributed to all NFL consulting physicians specializing in the management of spine injuries. The survey covered the following five clinical vignettes of cervical spine injuries: 1) radiculopathy, 2) myelopathy, 3) unilateral facet fracture, 4) unilateral facet dislocation, and 5) neck pain with MRI showing a ligamentous STIR signal. Participants were asked about management options and criteria to clear players for RTP using a combination of multiple-choice and open-ended answers. RESULTS: A total of 26 physicians from 21 of 32 (66%) teams responded. Anterior surgery was most commonly recommended for cervical disc herniation causing radiculopathy or myelopathy (73% and 88%, respectively). A rigid cervical orthosis was preferred by 68% of experts for initial management of nondisplaced unilateral facet fracture, but single-level anterior fusion was preferred by 56% for a unilateral facet dislocation. Common criteria to clear players for RTP with cervical disc herniation causing radiculopathy included a normal examination (85%), radiographic fusion postoperatively (58%), and pain-free range of motion (50%). Contraindications for RTP included persistent stenosis (35%), instability (31%), multilevel fusion (27%), and persistent cord signal change (23%). Additional criteria for RTP in players with facet fractures or dislocations included radiographic evidence of fracture healing (32% and 24%, respectively) and normal flexion/extension radiographs (24% and 32%, respectively). Finally, for players with isolated ligamentous STIR signal changes, resolution of MRI findings was required by 36% of responding physicians prior to RTP. CONCLUSIONS: Decision-making regarding RTP after cervical spine injuries in professional football players is complex and influenced by improvement of symptoms, pain-free range of motion, and radiographic evidence of fusion or fracture healing. Respondents preferred anterior cervical discectomy and fusion for disc herniations causing cervical radiculopathy and myelopathy, rigid orthosis for unilateral facet fractures, and surgery for unilateral facet dislocations. The results of this study provide insight into how surgeons serving as consultants to professional football teams may counsel players who sustain cervical spine injuries.

来源:J Neurosurg Spine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. White MD, Hersh AM, Weber-Levine C, et al. Return to play in professional football players following traumatic cervical spine injury: expert opinions from the National Football League spine surgeons. J Neurosurg Spine. 2024. PMID: 39705704. doi:10.3171/2024.8.SPINE24421

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。