基于证据的神经创伤指南的依从性:一项全球调查
研究通过24项问卷全球调查233名神经外科医生对创伤性脑损伤指南的依从性。约45%未及时更新指南,48%偏好个人经验,欧洲及美洲医生更倾向循证医学(P=0.021),56%报告管理至少有时偏离推荐。
要点
- 约45%受访者未及时跟进脑创伤基金会指南,48%偏好个人经验而非循证医学指南。
- 欧洲及北美中美南美医生更倾向循证医学,亚洲和非洲医生更依赖个人经验(P=0.021)。
- 56%报告神经创伤管理至少有时偏离推荐指南,58%从不或很少对30 cm³硬膜外血肿保守治疗。
核心结论
- 欧洲及北美中美南美神经外科医生更倾向遵循循证医学指南,亚洲和非洲医生常偏好个体化决策。
研究设计与样本
- 使用谷歌表单创建24项问卷的全球调查研究,涵盖人口学信息、神经创伤培训、循证医学基础知识和手术及院内管理。
- 共收集来自53个不同国家的233名神经外科医生的回复。
主要发现
- 约45%受访者报告未及时跟进脑创伤基金会指南,48%表示偏好依赖自身经验而非循证医学指南。
- 亚洲和非洲神经外科医生更可能依赖个人经验,欧洲及北美中美南美医生更倾向循证医学(P=0.021)。
- 56%受访者报告其神经创伤管理至少有时偏离推荐指南。
- 58%从不或很少对30 cm³硬膜外血肿进行保守治疗,45%有时、经常或总是对硬膜下血肿进行保守治疗,即使循证医学推荐手术。
- 24%至少有时对格拉斯哥昏迷评分小于9分或下降2分及以上的患者进行保守治疗;在小脑血肿中,46%有时仅选择脑室外引流。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Traumatic brain injury management guidelines vary across regions and there is limited research on real-world adherence to these guidelines. We conducted a global survey to assess the adherence of neurosurgeons to traumatic brain injury guidelines and evidence-based medicine (EBM). METHODS: A 24-item survey was created using Google Forms, covering demographic information, neurotrauma training, basic knowledge of EBM, and surgical and in-hospital management. RESULTS: Responses were collected from 233 neurosurgeons across 53 different countries. Approximately 45% of respondents reported not staying up to date with Brain Trauma Foundation guidelines, and 48% indicated a preference for relying on their own experience over EBM guidelines. Neurosurgeons from Asia and Africa were more likely to rely on personal experience, while those from Europe and North/Central and South America leaned toward EBM (P = 0.021). Additionally, 56% of respondents reported that their neurotrauma management at least sometimes diverged from recommended guidelines. Specifically, 58% never or rarely managed epidural hematoma of 30 cm³ conservatively, and 45% sometimes, often, or always treated subdural hematomas conservatively, even when EBM recommended surgery. Moreover, 24% at least sometimes managed patients conservatively despite a Glasgow Coma Scale score of less than 9 or a decrease of 2 or more points. In cerebellar hematomas, 46% sometimes opted for external ventricular drainage alone. CONCLUSIONS: Neurosurgeons from Europe and North/Central and South America tend to follow EBM guidelines more closely, while those from Asia and Africa often favor individual decision-making approaches.
引用
- Beraldo RF, Pereira MC, Liebl B, et al. Adherence in Evidence-Based Neurotrauma Guidelines: A Worldwide Survey. World Neurosurg. 2025. PMID: 39725284. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2024.123608
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。