脊髓脑膜瘤硬膜附着切除与电凝的比较:一项更新的系统评价与Meta分析
该系统评价与Meta分析纳入54项研究共3334例脊髓脑膜瘤患者,比较Simpson I级与II级硬膜处理方式的结局。结果显示I级与II级在肿瘤复发、术后神经功能缺损及手术相关并发症上均无显著差异,而I、II级肿瘤复发显著低于III、IV级。
要点
- Simpson I级与II级在肿瘤复发、术后神经功能缺损及并发症上均无显著差异。
- Simpson I、II级肿瘤复发显著低于III、IV级,且III级优于IV级。
- 作者认为当切除硬膜并发症风险较高时,硬膜电凝可能优于切除。
核心结论
- Simpson I级在任何结局上均不优于II级,但两者在肿瘤复发方面均优于III级和IV级。
- 作者认为当硬膜切除并发症风险较高时,硬膜电凝可能优于切除。
研究设计与样本
- 按照PRISMA声明系统检索PubMed、EMBASE和Web of Science,纳入涉及接受Simpson I、II、III或IV级手术的脊髓脑膜瘤患者的研究。
- 共纳入54项研究,总计3334例患者。
- Simpson I、II、III、IV级分别 performed 于674例(20%)、2205例(66%)、254例(8%)和201例(6%)患者。
- 随访时间为9至192个月,95.4%的肿瘤为WHO 1级。
主要发现
- Simpson I级与II级在影像学肿瘤复发上无差异(OR 0.80,95% CI:0.46-1.36,P=0.41;I²=0%)。
- Simpson I级与II级在术后神经功能缺损上无差异(OR 0.74,95% CI:0.32-1.75,P=0.50;I²=0%)。
- Simpson I级与II级在手术相关并发症上无差异(OR 2.22,95% CI:0.80-6.13,P=0.12;I²=3%)。
- 所有Simpson级别相互比较时,术后神经功能缺损或手术相关并发症均无显著差异。
- Simpson I和II级影像学肿瘤复发显著低于III和IV级,Simpson III级优于IV级(OR 0.19,95% CI:0.09-0.40,P<0.01;I²=0%)。
关键数值与推荐
- Simpson I级与II级肿瘤复发OR 0.80(95% CI:0.46-1.36,P=0.41;I²=0%)。
- Simpson I级与II级术后神经功能缺损OR 0.74(95% CI:0.32-1.75,P=0.50;I²=0%)。
- Simpson I级与II级手术相关并发症OR 2.22(95% CI:0.80-6.13,P=0.12;I²=3%)。
- Simpson III级与IV级肿瘤复发OR 0.19(95% CI:0.09-0.40,P<0.01;I²=0%)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The Simpson grading scale assumes dural resection (grade I) is more effective against recurrence than coagulation (grade II). However, the results of recent studies have raised doubts about this effectiveness in spinal meningiomas. Therefore, we aimed to perform a meta-analysis comparing outcomes between Simpson grades I and II in spinal meningiomas. METHODS: According to the PRISMA statement, we systematically searched PubMed, EMBASE, and Web of Science for studies involving patients with spinal meningiomas who underwent Simpson grades I, II, III, or IV. Outcomes were radiological tumor recurrence, postoperative neurological deficits, and procedure-related complications. RESULTS: We included 54 studies with a total of 3334 patients. Simpson grades I, II, III, and IV were performed in 674 (20%), 2205 (66%), 254 (8%), and 201 (6%) patients, respectively. The follow-up ranged from 9 to 192 months, and 95.4% of all tumors were WHO grade 1. There was no difference in radiological tumor recurrence (OR 0.80, 95% CI: 0.46-1.36, P = 0.41; I2 = 0%), postoperative neurological deficits (OR 0.74, 95% CI: 0.32-1.75, P = 0.50; I2 = 0%) or procedure-related complications (OR 2.22, 95% CI: 0.80-6.13, P = 0.12; I2 = 3%) between Simpson grades I and II. Furthermore, no significant difference in postoperative neurological deficits or procedure-related complications was detected when comparing all Simpson's to each other. However, radiological tumor recurrences in Simpson I and II were significantly lower than in III and IV, with Simpson III outperforming IV (OR 0.19, 95% CI: 0.09-0.40, P < 0.01; I2 = 0%). CONCLUSION: Simpson grade I is not more effective than grade II in any outcome, although both are superior to III and IV in tumor recurrence. Our results might suggest that dural coagulation is preferable over resection when the latter carries a higher risk of complications.
引用
- de Oliveira MPR, Sandes PHF, de Oliveira Piñeiro GT, et al. Resection vs. coagulation of dural attachment in patients with spinal meningioma: an updated systematic review and meta-analysis. Acta Neurochir (Wien). 2024. PMID: 39167255. doi:10.1007/s00701-024-06235-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。