格拉斯哥昏迷量表-瞳孔评分对美国创伤中心创伤性硬膜下血肿患者住院死亡率的预测评估
研究基于美国国家创伤数据库(2017-2019年)的196,747例创伤性硬膜下血肿患者,比较GCS-P与GCS预测住院死亡率的能力。整体队列中两者AUC相似(0.825 vs 0.814,p<0.001);在穿透性颅脑损伤亚组(2.4%,n=4,710)中GCS-P的AUC显著更高(0.902 vs 0.851,p<0.001)。作者认为GCS-P对穿透性颅脑损伤的短期预后判断更优,但低GCS-P评分不应成为放弃积极治疗的依据。
要点
- 在整体创伤性硬膜下血肿队列中,GCS-P与GCS预测住院死亡率的AUC分别为0.825和0.814(p<0.001)。
- 在穿透性颅脑损伤亚组(n=4,710)中,GCS-P的AUC显著高于GCS(0.902 vs 0.851,p<0.001)。
- GCS-P评分高估了穿透性颅脑损伤中观察死亡率较高患者的住院死亡风险。
核心结论
- 在穿透性颅脑损伤的创伤性硬膜下血肿患者中,GCS-P评分较单独GCS评分提供更好的短期预后判断。
- GCS-P评分高估了观察死亡率较高的穿透性颅脑损伤患者的住院死亡风险。
- 对于占本硬膜下血肿队列2.4%的穿透性颅脑损伤患者,低GCS-P评分不应成为临床放弃主义或放弃积极治疗的依据。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为基于美国国家创伤数据库(2017-2019年)的队列分析。
- 纳入标准为创伤性硬膜下血肿诊断且具备就诊时GCS评分、瞳孔反应性和出院去向数据。
- 排除标准为就诊时严重多发伤或不可存活颅脑损伤的患者。
- 共纳入196,747例符合研究标准的创伤性硬膜下血肿患者。
主要发现
- 整体队列中,GCS-P与GCS预测住院死亡率的敏感度分别为0.707和0.702,特异度分别为0.821和0.823,AUC分别为0.825和0.814(p<0.001)。
- 校准曲线分析显示GCS评分轻度低估住院死亡风险,而GCS-P评分未出现此现象。
- 在年龄>65岁且为钝性颅脑损伤的患者中(51.9%,n=102,148),GCS-P和GCS评分均低估住院死亡风险。
- 在穿透性颅脑损伤患者中(2.4%,n=4,710),GCS-P的AUC显著高于GCS(0.902 vs 0.851,p<0.001)。
- 在穿透性颅脑损伤亚组中,GCS-P和GCS评分在观察死亡率较低的患者中均低估风险,在观察死亡率较高的患者中均高估风险,且该效应在GCS-P校准曲线中更明显。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The Glasgow Coma Scale-Pupils (GCS-P) score has been suggested to better predict patient outcomes compared with GCS alone, while avoiding the need for more complex clinical models. This study aimed to compare the prognostic ability of GCS-P versus GCS in a national cohort of traumatic subdural hematoma (SDH) patients. METHODS: Patient data were obtained from the National Trauma Data Bank (2017-2019). Inclusion criteria were traumatic SDH diagnosis with available data on presenting GCS score, pupillary reactivity, and discharge disposition. Patients with severe polytrauma or nonsurvivable head injury at presentation were excluded. Sensitivity, specificity, and area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) of GCS-P versus GCS scores for inpatient mortality prediction were evaluated across the entire cohort, as well as in subgroups based on age and traumatic brain injury (TBI) type (blunt vs penetrating). Calibration curves were plotted based on predicted probabilities and actual outcomes. RESULTS: A total of 196,747 traumatic SDH patients met the study inclusion criteria. Sensitivity (0.707 vs 0.702), specificity (0.821 vs 0.823), and AUC (0.825 vs 0.814, p < 0.001) of GCS-P versus GCS scores for prediction of inpatient mortality were similar. Calibration curve analysis revealed that GCS scores slightly underestimated inpatient mortality risk, whereas GCS-P scores did not. In patients > 65 years of age with blunt TBI (51.9%, n = 102,148), both GCS-P and GCS scores underestimated inpatient mortality risk. In patients with penetrating TBI (2.4%, n = 4,710), the AUC of the GCS-P score was significantly higher (0.902 vs 0.851, p < 0.001). In this subgroup, both GCS-P and GCS scores underestimated inpatient mortality risk among patients with lower rates of observed mortality and overestimated risk among patients with higher rates of observed mortality. This effect was more pronounced in the GCS-P calibration curve. CONCLUSIONS: The GCS-P score provides better short-term prognostication compared with the GCS score alone among traumatic SDH patients with penetrating TBI. The GCS-P score overestimates inpatient mortality risk among penetrating TBI patients with higher rates of observed mortality. For penetrating TBI patients, which comprised 2.4% of our SDH cohort, a low GCS-P score should not justify clinical nihilism or forgoing aggressive treatment.
引用
- Ran KR, Alfonzo Horowitz M, Liu J, et al. Evaluation of the Glasgow Coma Scale-Pupils score for predicting inpatient mortality among patients with traumatic subdural hematoma at United States trauma centers. J Neurosurg. 2024. PMID: 38701532. doi:10.3171/2024.2.JNS232695
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。