指南与共识

尊敬的培训主任:神经外科住院医师申请推荐信中内隐偏见的评估

Dear Program Director: An Evaluation of Implicit Bias in Letters of Recommendation for Neurosurgery Residency.
指南 / 共识 · Neurosurgery · 2024-05-21

该研究回顾性分析单机构2014至2020年NRMP匹配周期中218份神经外科住院医师申请者的827封推荐信,使用LIWC软件评估内隐性别偏见。结果显示男性申请者推荐信词数更多(331 vs 297,差值34,95%CI 9-61,P=0.008)且更常提及Alpha Omega Alpha荣誉医学会(1.17 vs 0.778,差值0.4,95%CI 0.13-0.67,P=0.023),女性申请者USMLE Step 1分数较低(241 vs 247,差值6,95%CI 2-10,P=0.004),语言评估各分类无显著性别差异。

要点

  • 男性申请者推荐信词数多于女性(331 vs 297,差值34,95%CI 9-61,P=0.008)。
  • 男性申请者推荐信更常提及Alpha Omega Alpha荣誉医学会(1.17 vs 0.778,差值0.4,95%CI 0.13-0.67,P=0.023)。
  • 女性申请者USMLE Step 1分数低于男性(241 vs 247,差值6,95%CI 2-10,P=0.004)。

核心结论

  • 推荐信对神经外科住院医师申请至关重要,男性和女性申请者数据存在一些差异,但推荐信差异很少,与既往神经外科研究结果一致。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性分析单机构2014至2020年NRMP匹配周期中神经外科申请者推荐信,共审查218份申请、827封信,使用LIWC软件评估。

主要发现

  • 男性申请者推荐信词数多于女性(331 vs 297,差值34,95%CI 9-61,P=0.008)。
  • 男性申请者推荐信更常提及Alpha Omega Alpha荣誉医学会(1.17 vs 0.778,差值0.4,95%CI 0.13-0.67,P=0.023)。
  • 女性申请者USMLE Step 1分数低于男性(241 vs 247,差值6,95%CI 2-10,P=0.004)。
  • 语言评估中男性和女性推荐信在所有评估分类上无显著差异。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Despite comprising half of medical students, women represent only 29.6% of neurosurgery applicants and 17% of residents, suggesting a "leak" in the career pipeline for women neurosurgeons. Surveys persistently show that neurosurgery programs identify United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE®) Step 1 score and letters of recommendation (LORs) as the most important factors in selecting applicants to interview. A previous study in neurosurgery found no differences in LORs. However, multiple studies in other specialties have demonstrated implicit gender bias in LORs, which may influence resident selection. Our objective is to evaluate neurosurgery residency LORs for evidence of implicit gender bias. METHODS: Retrospective analysis of LORs for interviewed neurosurgery applicants at a single institution during the 2014 to 2020 National Residency Matching Program (NRMP®) match cycles. Letters were evaluated using Linguistic Inquiry & Word Count (LIWC) software (Pennebaker Conglomerates), and additional applicant data were obtained from candidate applications. LIWC (Pennebaker Conglomerates) output data included custom dictionary categories and terms that were analyzed using Prism 10 and Rstudio. RESULTS: Two hundred eighteen applications were reviewed for a total of 827 letters. LIWC (Pennebaker Conglomerates) analysis showed significant differences in word count (331 vs 297, difference = 34, 95% CI: 9-61, P = .008). LORs for applicants who were men were more likely to mention Alpha Omega Alpha Honor Medical Society (1.17 vs 0.778, difference = 0.4, 95% CI: 0.13-0.67, P = .023). USMLE® Step 1 scores were significantly lower for women (241 vs 247, difference = 6, 95% CI: 2-10, P = .004). There was no significant difference between letters for men and women for all categories evaluated in the linguistic evaluation. CONCLUSION: LORs are vital to the neurosurgical residency application process. The data exhibit some differences between the men and women applicants but few differences in their LORs, consistent with the results of the previous neurosurgical study.

来源:Neurosurgery,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Coyle A, Graves EKM, Hannah TC, et al. Dear Program Director: An Evaluation of Implicit Bias in Letters of Recommendation for Neurosurgery Residency. Neurosurgery. 2024. PMID: 38771088. doi:10.1227/neu.0000000000003002

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。