家族性Chiari畸形:系统综述与典型病例
本文报告了一对在多伦多西部医院脊髓门诊就诊的症状性Chiari畸形1型(CM-1)伴脊髓空洞症的双卵双胞胎病例,并按PRISMA指南检索EMBASE和MEDLINE(2023年6月27日)系统综述家族性CM研究,最终纳入29篇文章、34个家族,平均每家族3例CM,81例(88%)为CM-1,37例(54%)存在脊髓空洞,最常见的家族成员关系为兄弟姐妹(18例;35%)和单卵双胎/三胎(12例;23%);作者认为存在遗传成分证据,但不符合经典孟德尔遗传模式,建议对一级亲属进行更密切的临床和影像学监测、患者教育并考虑早期基因检测。
要点
- 家族性CM研究共纳入29篇文章、34个家族,平均每家族3例CM。
- 81例(88%)报告为CM-1,37例(54%)存在脊髓空洞。
- 最常见受累家族成员为兄弟姐妹(18例;35%)和单卵双胎/三胎(12例;23%)。
核心结论
- 家族性CM存在遗传成分证据,但不太可能用经典孟德尔遗传模式解释,而更可能是受可变外显率、共分离和非遗传因素影响的多基因架构。
- 作者认为其发现可能影响临床医生对CM患者一级亲属进行更密切的临床和影像学监测、加强患者教育并考虑早期基因检测。
研究设计与样本
- 本文包括一例在多伦多西部医院脊髓门诊就诊的症状性CM-1伴脊髓空洞症的双卵双胞胎病例报告。
- 系统综述于2023年6月27日检索EMBASE和MEDLINE数据库,遵循PRISMA指南。
- 仅纳入英文文献、涉及超过1名人类家庭成员诊断为CM的病例研究、病例系列或文献综述。
- 最终分析纳入29篇文章,共分析34个CM家族。
主要发现
- 所有世代中平均每家族发现3例CM。
- 81例(88%)报告为CM-1,其余11例(12%)报告为CM-0、CM-1.5或小脑扁桃体异位。
- 37例(54%)存在脊髓空洞,其中14例(38%)同时报告骨骼异常,为最常见的合并症。
- 大多数诊断为CM的家庭成员为兄弟姐妹(18例;35%),其次为单卵双胎/三胎(12例;23%)。
- 患者最常表现为头痛、感觉障碍或全身性症状。
关键数值与推荐
- 系统综述纳入标准为英文文献且涉及超过1名人类家庭成员诊断为CM的病例研究、病例系列或文献综述。
- 家族性CM病例中CM-1占81例(88%),CM-0、CM-1.5或小脑扁桃体异位占11例(12%)。
- 脊髓空洞存在于37例(54%)病例中,其中14例(38%)同时报告骨骼异常。
- 家庭成员关系以兄弟姐妹最常见(18例;35%),其次为单卵双胎/三胎(12例;23%)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为其发现可能影响临床医生对CM患者一级亲属进行更密切的临床和影像学监测。
- 作者认为其发现可能影响临床医生加强患者教育并考虑早期基因检测。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Chiari malformations (CMs) are a group of congenital or acquired disorders characterized by hindbrain overcrowding into an underdeveloped posterior cranial fossa. CM is considered largely sporadic-however, there exists growing evidence of transmissible genetic underpinnings. The purpose of this systematic review of all familial studies of CM was to investigate the existence of an inherited component and provide recommendations to manage and monitor at-risk family members. METHODS: This paper includes the following: 1) a unique case report of dizygotic twins who presented at the Toronto Western Hospital Spinal Cord Clinic with symptomatic CM type 1 (CM-1) and syringomyelia; and 2) a systematic review of familial CM. The EMBASE and MEDLINE databases were searched on June 27, 2023, in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. Only articles in the English language concerning the diagnosis of CM in > 1 human family member presented as a case study, case series, or literature review were included. RESULTS: Among the 29 articles included in the final analysis, a total of 34 families with CM were analyzed. An average of 3 cases of CM were found per family among all generations. Eighty-one cases (88%) reported CM-1, whereas the other 11 (12%) cases reported either CM-0, CM-1.5, or tonsillar ectopia. A syrinx was present in 37 (54%) cases, with 14 (38%) of these patients also reporting a skeletal abnormality, the most common comorbidity. Most family members diagnosed with CM were siblings (18; 35%), followed by monozygotic twins/triplets (12; 23%). CONCLUSIONS: Patients most often presented with headaches, sensory disturbances, or generalized symptoms. Overall, there exists mounting evidence for a hereditary component of CM. It is unlikely to be explained by a classic mendelian inheritance pattern, but is rather a polygenic architecture influenced by variable penetrance, cosegregation, and entirely nongenetic factors. For first-degree relatives of those affected by CM, the authors' findings may influence clinicians to conduct closer clinical and radiographic monitoring, promote patient education, and consider earlier genetic testing.
引用
- Dhawan A, Dhawan J, Sharma AN, et al. Familial Chiari malformation: a systematic review and illustrative cases. J Neurosurg Spine. 2024. PMID: 38608294. doi:10.3171/2024.1.SPINE231277
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。