透过镜子:比较住院医师与主治医师对胜任力与自主性的看法
本试点研究使用手术自主性项目,通过最近发展区(ZPD)比较住院医师与主治医师对常见小儿神经外科手术(脑室腹腔分流术)胜任力的感知,并通过教学-建议-指导-独立(TAGS)量表比较自主性感知。结果显示两者对胜任力和自主性的评分无显著差异,研究生年级与TAGS评分差异显著相关,经验较少者表现出正向感知差距。住院医师认为ZPD清单是与主治医师沟通并在手术室获得适当自主性的有用工具。
要点
- 住院医师与主治医师对胜任力和自主性的评分无显著差异。
- 研究生年级与TAGS评分差异显著相关,经验较少者表现出正向感知差距。
- 住院医师认为ZPD清单有助于与主治医师沟通并获得适当自主性。
核心结论
- 小儿神经外科受训者与主治医师对住院医师自主性和胜任力的感知一致,提示该工具可作为客观评估神经外科住院医师手术进展的有用方法。
研究设计与样本
- 本试点研究使用手术自主性项目,将最常见的儿童神经外科手术脑室腹腔分流术分解为四个ZPD,术后由住院医师和主治医师分别通过ZPD评定胜任力、通过TAGS量表评定自主性,并比较两者评分。
主要发现
- 住院医师与主治医师对胜任力或自主性的评分无显著差异。
- 研究生年级与TAGS评分差异显著相关,经验较少者表现出正向感知差距。
- 其他协变量(年龄、性别)与评分差异无关。
- 住院医师认为ZPD清单是与主治医师沟通和获得适当自主性的有用工具。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Surgical residencies act as an apprenticeship to train new surgeons, ideally with increasing trainee autonomy and competency. Objective methods of measuring these two qualities are needed. METHODS: The objective of this pilot study is to use the Surgical Autonomy Program to compare resident and attending perception of competency, via Zones of Proximal Development (ZPDs), and autonomy, via Teach, Advise, Guide, Solo (TAGS) scale for a common pediatric neurosurgical procedure. The most common pediatric neurosurgical procedure, a ventriculoperitoneal shunt, was broken down into four ZPDs. After each procedure, the resident and the attending rated the competency of the resident by ZPD and their autonomy using TAGS. These ratings were then compared to see if the attending and the resident agreed on their levels of competency and autonomy. RESULTS: There were no significant differences in the rating of competency or autonomy between the residents and the attendings. Postgraduate year was significantly associated with differences in TAGS ratings with those having less experience showing a positive perception gap. Other covariates (age, gender) were not associated with differences in rating. The residents found that the ZPDs checklist was a useful tool for communicating with the attending and for getting appropriate autonomy in the operating room. CONCLUSIONS: Pediatric neurosurgical trainees and attendings had concordance on their perceptions of resident autonomy and competency, suggesting that this tool could be a useful way of objectively grading the progress of neurosurgical residents in surgery.
引用
- Niznik T, Chen S, Gernsback J, et al. Through the Looking Glass: Comparing Resident and Attending Views on Competency and Autonomy. World Neurosurg. 2024. PMID: 38548051. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2024.03.125
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。