小儿神经外科医生队伍中的性别差异:职业实践、工作与生活平衡及其他
该调查向495名小儿神经外科医生发放问卷,应答率49%(n=241)。结果显示女性占该队伍三分之一,在工作量、工作时长和职业责任上无性别差异,但女性承担更多家庭责任、更频繁遭遇和目睹种族与性别歧视,且工作与生活平衡或工作支持感无性别差异。
要点
- 女性占小儿神经外科队伍的三分之一,在手术量、周工作时长和晚8点后或周末工作上无性别差异。
- 女性更频繁值班(P=.044),更不满意值班安排(P=.012),且在家休息时工作更多小时(P=.050)。
- 女性更频繁报告目睹和经历种族歧视(P=.008;P<.001)与性骚扰(P=.002,P<.001),工作安全感更低(P<.001)。
核心结论
- 尽管工作量和职业责任差异很小,女性承担更多家庭责任,且在工作场所经历和目睹更多种族与性别歧视;工作与生活平衡或工作支持感无性别差异,提示女性神经外科医生特有的因素可能促成该领域持续的性别差异。
研究设计与样本
- 向495名小儿神经外科医生发放调查问卷,评估职业活动、工作与生活平衡、家庭动态、职业满意度及工作场所歧视与骚扰;应答率49%(n=241)。
主要发现
- 女性占小儿神经外科队伍的三分之一,种族/族裔、美国神经外科委员会/美国小儿神经外科委员会认证率或小儿神经外科 fellowship 完成率无性别差异。
- 手术量、周工作时长、晚8点后或周末工作无性别差异;女性值班更频繁(P=.044),男性更可能就职于学术界(P=.004)和获得外部来源的薪酬补贴(P=.026)。
- 女性更可能预计65岁前退休(P=.044),对值班安排更不满意(P=.012),在家休息时工作更多小时(P=.050)。
- 女性更频繁报告目睹和经历种族歧视(P=.008;P<.001)、性骚扰(P=.002,P<.001),工作安全感更低(P<.001)。
- 男性更可能已婚(P=.042)并有1个(P=.004)或更多孩子(P=.034);女性报告在儿童和家务照护方面责任显著更大(P<.001);工作与生活平衡、工作支持感或工作外时间充足性无性别差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Evidence suggests that female neurosurgeons experience unique challenges in the workplace including lack of academic advancement, challenges with work-life balance, harassment, and discrimination. How these factors influence the gender gap in neurosurgery remains unclear. This analysis investigated gender differences in pediatric neurosurgeons in professional and nonprofessional activities and responsibilities. METHODS: A survey examining professional activities, work-life balance, family dynamics, career satisfaction, and workplace discrimination and harassment was administered to 495 pediatric neurosurgeons. Response rate was 49% (n = 241). RESULTS: One-third of the pediatric neurosurgical workforce is female. There were no gender differences in race/ethnicity, American Board of Neurological Surgery/American Board of Pediatric Neurological Surgery certification rates, or pediatric neurosurgery fellowship completion. No gender differences were found in operative caseload, weekly hours worked, or working after 8 pm or weekends. Women took call more frequently than men ( P = .044). Men were more likely to work in academia ( P = .004) and have salary subsidization from external sources ( P = .026). Women were more likely to anticipate retirement by age 65 years ( P = .044), were less happy with call commitments ( P = .012), and worked more hours at home while off ( P = .050). Women more frequently reported witnessing and experiencing racial discrimination ( P = .008; P < .001), sexual harassment ( P = .002, P < .001), and feeling less safe at work ( P < .001). Men were more likely married ( P = .042) with 1 ( P = .004) or more children ( P = .034). Women reported significantly greater responsibility for child and domestic care ( P < .001). There were no gender differences in work-life balance, feeling supported at work, or having enough time to do things outside of work. CONCLUSION: Despite little difference in workload and professional responsibilities, women held more domestic responsibilities and experienced and witnessed more racial and sexual discrimination in the workplace. Surprisingly, there were no reported differences in work-life balance or feeling supported at work between genders. These findings suggest that factors unique to female neurosurgeons may contribute to continued gender disparity in the field.
引用
- Granek L, Muzyka L, Limoges N, et al. Gender Differences in the Pediatric Neurosurgical Workforce: Professional Practice, Work-Life Balance, and Beyond. Neurosurgery. 2024. PMID: 38483170. doi:10.1227/neu.0000000000002895
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。