IMPACT与CRASH预后模型在当代多中心创伤性脑损伤队列中的表现:TRACK-TBI研究
本研究基于2014-2018年前瞻性18中心TRACK-TBI队列,在441例符合IMPACT标准及831例符合CRASH标准的创伤性脑损伤患者中评估两模型性能。两模型对死亡和不良结局均有良好区分度,但总体高估死亡风险及部分不良结局风险。作者认为需更新预后模型以纳入当代创伤性脑损伤管理及病例构成变化。
要点
- IMPACT模型总体高估死亡率(校准截距-0.79),对不良结局预测可接受。
- CRASH模型总体高估死亡率(截距-1.06)及不良结局(截距-0.60)。
- 两模型区分度良好,c-statistic分别为0.84/0.83及0.92/0.88。
核心结论
- IMPACT与CRASH模型对死亡和不良结局具有足够的区分度,但观察到对死亡和不良结局的高估,凸显需更新预后模型以纳入当代创伤性脑损伤管理及病例构成变化。
- 作者认为阐明生存率增加、结局、治疗强度与中心特定实践之间关系的研究,将有助于改进特定创伤性脑损伤亚组(如老年人)的模型,这些亚组可能受益于纳入血液生物标志物、神经影像特征和治疗数据。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性18中心TRACK-TBI研究,入组年份2014-2018,纳入年龄≥17岁、就诊于一级创伤中心并在创伤性脑损伤后24小时内接受头部CT的受试者。
- IMPACT模型分析纳入符合GCS评分3-12分且有6个月GOSE数据的受试者441例;CRASH模型分析纳入符合GCS评分3-14分且有2周死亡率数据和6个月GOSE数据的受试者831例。
- 分析在总体队列中进行,并按创伤性脑损伤严重程度(重度/中度/轻度分别定义为GCS评分3-8/9-12/13-14分)、年龄(17-64岁或≥65岁)及入组前5位中心进行分层。
- 不良结局定义为GOSE评分1-4分;应用原始IMPACT和CRASH模型系数,通过校准(截距和斜率)与区分度(c-statistic)评估模型性能。
主要发现
- 总体IMPACT模型高估死亡率(截距-0.79,95%CI -1.05至-0.53;斜率1.37,95%CI 1.05至1.69),对不良结局预测可接受(截距0.07,95%CI -0.14至0.29;斜率1.19,95%CI 0.96至1.42),区分度良好(c-statistic分别为0.84和0.83)。
- CRASH模型高估死亡率(截距-1.06,95%CI -1.36至-0.75;斜率0.96,95%CI 0.79至1.14)及不良结局(截距-0.60,95%CI -0.78至-0.41;斜率1.20,95%CI 1.03至1.37),区分度良好(c-statistic分别为0.92和0.88)。
- 在重度和中度创伤性脑损伤亚组中,IMPACT模型高估死亡率、对不良结局预测可接受,区分度良好(c-statistic≥0.81)。
- 在重度和中度创伤性脑损伤亚组中,CRASH模型高估死亡率,在轻度创伤性脑损伤亚组中死亡率预测可接受,区分度良好(c-statistic≥0.86);在重度和轻度创伤性脑损伤亚组中高估不良结局,区分度尚可(c-statistic≥0.78),而中度创伤性脑损伤亚组校准呈非线性。
- 在≥65岁受试者中,模型表现不一(IMPACT-死亡率:截距0.28,斜率0.68,c-statistic 0.68;CRASH-不良结局:截距-0.97,斜率1.32,c-statistic 0.88;IMPACT-不良结局和CRASH-死亡率校准呈非线性);在入组前5位中心间观察到死亡率和不良结局的模型性能差异。
关键数值与推荐
- IMPACT模型适用标准:GCS评分3-12分且有6个月GOSE数据(n=441)。
- CRASH模型适用标准:GCS评分3-14分且有2周死亡率数据和6个月GOSE数据(n=831)。
- 不良结局定义:GOSE评分1-4分。
- 创伤性脑损伤严重程度定义:重度GCS评分3-8分,中度GCS评分9-12分,轻度GCS评分13-14分。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为需更新预后模型以纳入当代创伤性脑损伤管理及病例构成变化。
- 作者认为阐明生存率增加、结局、治疗强度与中心特定实践之间关系的研究,将有助于改进特定创伤性脑损伤亚组(如老年人)的模型,这些亚组可能受益于纳入血液生物标志物、神经影像特征和治疗数据。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The International Mission on Prognosis and Analysis of Clinical Trials in Traumatic Brain Injury (IMPACT) and Corticosteroid Randomization After Significant Head Injury (CRASH) prognostic models for mortality and outcome after traumatic brain injury (TBI) were developed using data from 1984 to 2004. This study examined IMPACT and CRASH model performances in a contemporary cohort of US patients. METHODS: The prospective 18-center Transforming Research and Clinical Knowledge in Traumatic Brain Injury (TRACK-TBI) study (enrollment years 2014-2018) enrolled subjects aged ≥ 17 years who presented to level I trauma centers and received head CT within 24 hours of TBI. Data were extracted from the subjects who met the model criteria (for IMPACT, Glasgow Coma Scale [GCS] score 3-12 with 6-month Glasgow Outcome Scale-Extended [GOSE] data [n = 441]; for CRASH, GCS score 3-14 with 2-week mortality data and 6-month GOSE data [n = 831]). Analyses were conducted in the overall cohort and stratified on the basis of TBI severity (severe/moderate/mild TBI defined as GCS score 3-8/9-12/13-14), age (17-64 years or ≥ 65 years), and the 5 top enrolling sites. Unfavorable outcome was defined as GOSE score 1-4. Original IMPACT and CRASH model coefficients were applied, and model performances were assessed by calibration (intercept [< 0 indicated overprediction; > 0 indicated underprediction] and slope) and discrimination (c-statistic). RESULTS: Overall, the IMPACT models overpredicted mortality (intercept -0.79 [95% CI -1.05 to -0.53], slope 1.37 [1.05-1.69]) and acceptably predicted unfavorable outcome (intercept 0.07 [-0.14 to 0.29], slope 1.19 [0.96-1.42]), with good discrimination (c-statistics 0.84 and 0.83, respectively). The CRASH models overpredicted mortality (intercept -1.06 [-1.36 to -0.75], slope 0.96 [0.79-1.14]) and unfavorable outcome (intercept -0.60 [-0.78 to -0.41], slope 1.20 [1.03-1.37]), with good discrimination (c-statistics 0.92 and 0.88, respectively). IMPACT overpredicted mortality and acceptably predicted unfavorable outcome in the severe and moderate TBI subgroups, with good discrimination (c-statistic ≥ 0.81). CRASH overpredicted mortality in the severe and moderate TBI subgroups and acceptably predicted mortality in the mild TBI subgroup, with good discrimination (c-statistic ≥ 0.86); unfavorable outcome was overpredicted in the severe and mild TBI subgroups with adequate discrimination (c-statistic ≥ 0.78), whereas calibration was nonlinear in the moderate TBI subgroup. In subjects ≥ 65 years of age, the models performed variably (IMPACT-mortality, intercept 0.28, slope 0.68, and c-statistic 0.68; CRASH-unfavorable outcome, intercept -0.97, slope 1.32, and c-statistic 0.88; nonlinear calibration for IMPACT-unfavorable outcome and CRASH-mortality). Model performance differences were observed across the top enrolling sites for mortality and unfavorable outcome. CONCLUSIONS: The IMPACT and CRASH models adequately discriminated mortality and unfavorable outcome. Observed overestimations of mortality and unfavorable outcome underscore the need to update prognostic models to incorporate contemporary changes in TBI management and case-mix. Investigations to elucidate the relationships between increased survival, outcome, treatment intensity, and site-specific practices will be relevant to improve models in specific TBI subpopulations (e.g., older adults), which may benefit from the inclusion of blood-based biomarkers, neuroimaging features, and treatment data.
引用
- Yue JK, Lee YM, Sun X, et al. Performance of the IMPACT and CRASH prognostic models for traumatic brain injury in a contemporary multicenter cohort: a TRACK-TBI study. J Neurosurg. 2024. PMID: 38489823. doi:10.3171/2023.11.JNS231425
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。