脑肿瘤进展与假性进展及放射性坏死鉴别诊断影像学检查准确性研究的伞状综述与网络Meta分析
该伞状综述与网络Meta分析系统检索PubMed和Embase,汇总17种影像模态鉴别脑肿瘤复发与治疗后放射效应的证据,纳入32项合格研究,仅1项结果可信度高。网络Meta分析显示18F-FET PET在17种技术中排名最高且具统计学显著性,MRS(Cho/NAA)和18F-DOPA PET显示最高敏感性和阴性似然比,APT MRI作为唯一非核医学成像排名高于DSC但无统计学显著性。结论认为现有证据仍无定论。
要点
- 18F-FET PET在17种影像技术中排名最高且具统计学显著性。
- MRS(Cho/NAA)和18F-DOPA PET显示最高敏感性和阴性似然比。
- APT MRI是唯一排名高于DSC的非核医学成像,但无统计学显著性。
核心结论
- 关于哪种影像模态最适合鉴别放射性坏死与治疗后放射效应,现有证据仍无定论。
- 基于现有证据,网络Meta分析将FET PET列为该任务的最佳方法。
- APT MRI作为非核医学替代方案显示出有前景的结果。
研究设计与样本
- 伞状综述与网络Meta分析,系统检索PubMed和Embase。
- 纳入32项合格研究,汇总17种不同影像模态的证据。
- 使用AMSTAR-2工具评估合格研究的质量。
- 采用随机效应模型重新计算每项Meta分析的效应量、敏感性、特异性、阳性和阴性似然比及诊断比值比。
- 采用网络Meta分析比较影像技术,并使用多维尺度法和累积排名曲线下面积视觉评估进行排名。
主要发现
- 仅1项纳入研究结果可信度高,21%的纳入Meta分析存在显著异质性,9%存在小研究效应。
- MRS Cho/NAA、Cho/Cr、DWI和DSC之间的比较研究最多。
- MRS(Cho/NAA)和18F-DOPA PET显示最高敏感性和阴性似然比。
- 18F-FET PET在17种研究技术中排名最高且具统计学显著性。
- APT MRI是唯一排名高于DSC的非核医学成像模态,但无统计学显著性。
局限性
- 仅1项纳入研究结果可信度高。
- 21%的纳入Meta分析存在显著异质性。
- 9%的纳入Meta分析存在小研究效应。
- 关于哪种影像模态最适合鉴别放射性坏死与治疗后放射效应,现有证据仍无定论。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: In this study we gathered and analyzed the available evidence regarding 17 different imaging modalities and performed network meta-analysis to find the most effective modality for the differentiation between brain tumor recurrence and post-treatment radiation effects. METHODS: We conducted a comprehensive systematic search on PubMed and Embase. The quality of eligible studies was assessed using the Assessment of Multiple Systematic Reviews-2 (AMSTAR-2) instrument. For each meta-analysis, we recalculated the effect size, sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative likelihood ratios, and diagnostic odds ratio from the individual study data provided in the original meta-analysis using a random-effects model. Imaging technique comparisons were then assessed using NMA. Ranking was assessed using the multidimensional scaling approach and by visually assessing surface under the cumulative ranking curves. RESULTS: We identified 32 eligible studies. High confidence in the results was found in only one of them, with a substantial heterogeneity and small study effect in 21% and 9% of included meta-analysis respectively. Comparisons between MRS Cho/NAA, Cho/Cr, DWI, and DSC were most studied. Our analysis showed MRS (Cho/NAA) and 18F-DOPA PET displayed the highest sensitivity and negative likelihood ratios. 18-FET PET was ranked highest among the 17 studied techniques with statistical significance. APT MRI was the only non-nuclear imaging modality to rank higher than DSC, with statistical insignificance, however. CONCLUSION: The evidence regarding which imaging modality is best for the differentiation between radiation necrosis and post-treatment radiation effects is still inconclusive. Using NMA, our analysis ranked FET PET to be the best for such a task based on the available evidence. APT MRI showed promising results as a non-nuclear alternative.
引用
- Dagher R, Gad M, da Silva de Santana P, et al. Umbrella review and network meta-analysis of diagnostic imaging test accuracy studies in Differentiating between brain tumor progression versus pseudoprogression and radionecrosis. J Neurooncol. 2024. PMID: 38212574. doi:10.1007/s11060-023-04528-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。