对改良H指数的文献计量分析及应用:考察高排名学术机构神经外科教职员工的研究产出
该研究提出纳入关键作者身份的改良h指数(hm),并分析其与传统h指数的关系及在不同专业类别中的变化。研究纳入排名前32的学术神经外科项目的225名临床教职员工,中位h指数为48,中位hm为32,中位差值为15;美国国立卫生研究院资助和亚专业与h到hm的显著变化相关。作者认为hm可作为反映关键学术产出的补充指标。
要点
- 在225名神经外科教职员工中,中位h指数为48(IQR 39-61),中位hm为32(IQR 24-43)。
- h指数与hm的中位差值为15(IQR 10-23),中位hm/h为64%(IQR 57-74)。
- 美国国立卫生研究院资助和亚专业(神经肿瘤、神经重症和脑血管)与h到hm的显著变化相关。
核心结论
- h指数可能受非关键作者身份影响,使用关键贡献的hm可作为反映神经外科关键学术产出的补充指标。
- 决定招聘或晋升的领导者应考虑基于非关键作者贡献的产出差异。
研究设计与样本
- 基于当前文献,收集并计算排名前32的学术神经外科项目中临床神经外科教职员工的h指数和hm。
- hm使用个人为第一、第二、最后或共同通讯作者的文章计算。
- 根据主席身份、领导身份、神经外科亚专业和美国国立卫生研究院资助身份进一步识别个体。
- 最终数据集纳入225名医生。
主要发现
- 225名医生的中位h指数为48(四分位距[IQR] 39-61),中位hm为32(IQR 24-43)。
- h指数与hm的中位差值为15(IQR 10-23)。
- 中位hm/h为64%(IQR 57-74)。
- 美国国立卫生研究院资助和亚专业(神经外科肿瘤学、神经重症监护和脑血管)与h到hm的显著变化相关。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: A major critique of the h-index is that it may be inflated by noncritical authorship. We propose a modified h-index (hm), incorporating critical authorship, complementary to the h-index. We analyze its relationship to the traditional h-index, and how each varies across professional categories relevant to academic neurosurgery. This analysis is not meant to critique authorship decisions, affect career development, alter academic legacy, or imply that the concepts of team science or midlevel authorship contributions are not valuable. METHODS: H-indices and hms were gathered and computed for clinical neurosurgical faculty at the top 32 ranked academic neurosurgical programs based on the current literature. Hm was computed for faculty at each program, using articles in which the individual was first, second, last, or co-corresponding author. Individuals were further identified based on chair status, leadership status, neurosurgical subspecialty, and National Institutes of Health funding status. Further analysis was performed to determine factors influencing h-index and hm. RESULTS: The median h-index for the 225 physicians included in the final dataset is 48 (interquartile range [IQR], 39-61), whereas the median hm was 32 (IQR, 24-43). The median difference between h-index and hm is 15 (IQR, 10-23). The median hm/h was 64% (IQR, 57-74). National Institutes of Health funding and subspecialty (neurosurgical oncology, neurocritical care, and cerebrovascular) were associated with significant change from h to hm. CONCLUSIONS: The h-index can be influenced by noncritical authorship, and hm, using critical contributions, can be used as a complement reflecting critical academic output in neurosurgery. Leaders deciding on hiring or promotion should consider disparities in productivity predicated on noncritical authorship contributions.
引用
- Rainone GJ, Nugent JG, Yeradi M, et al. Bibliometric Analysis and Applications of a Modified H-Index Examining the Research Productivity of Neurosurgery Faculty at High-Ranking Academic Institutions. World Neurosurg. 2023. PMID: 37952889. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2023.11.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。