巴基斯坦神经外科医生与急诊神经外科服务的地理分布
该调查覆盖307名神经外科医生和74个中心(覆盖率93.3%),绘制巴基斯坦神经外科医生密度与急诊神经外科服务地图。全国神经外科医生密度为0.14/10万,旁遮普省和信德省分别有42.3%(130名)和35.8%(110名)神经外科医生,卡拉奇和拉合尔集中了全国44%(135名)的神经外科医生。几何分布高度偏向城市中心,加剧了急诊神经外科服务可及性的差距。
要点
- 巴基斯坦神经外科医生密度为0.14/10万,低于世界神经外科联盟(WFNS)推荐的1/20万标准。
- 旁遮普省和信德省分别有42.3%(130名)和35.8%(110名)神经外科医生,城市中心集中了近四分之三的神经外科中心。
- 创伤性脑损伤管理在65个中心(87.8%)提供,CT扫描仪在74个中心(97%)配备,MRI在55个中心(72%)配备。
核心结论
- 神经外科医生与神经外科设施的地理分布高度偏向城市中心,加剧了及时急诊神经外科服务可及性的差距。
- 巴基斯坦需要四倍于当前的神经外科医生数量才能弥合神经外科人力缺口。
研究设计与样本
- 调查问卷在307名神经外科医生中发放,数据使用SPSS v21分析,神经外科医生和急诊神经外科服务数量使用ArcGIS Pro 3.0.0软件绘制在人口密度地图上。
主要发现
- 307名在74个中心工作的神经外科医生回复调查,覆盖率为93.3%。
- 巴基斯坦当前神经外科医生密度为0.14/10万。
- 旁遮普省和信德省分别有42.3%(130名)和35.8%(110名)神经外科医生,这两个省的城市地区集中了近四分之三的神经外科中心。
- 卡拉奇和拉合尔容纳了全国44%(135名)的神经外科医生,密度分别为0.29和0.51名/10万。
- 创伤性脑损伤管理在65个中心(87.8%)提供;CT扫描仪在74个中心(97%)配备,MRI在55个中心(72%)配备,血管造影室在37个中心(49%)配备,C臂透视机在69个中心(93.2%)配备。
关键数值与推荐
- 世界神经外科联盟(WFNS)建议神经外科医生密度至少为1/20万人口以实现最佳神经外科护理可及性。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: According to the World Federation of Neurosurgical Societies (WFNS), a minimum neurosurgery workforce density should be 1 per 200,000 population for optimum access to neurosurgical care. Pakistan lags behind in the number of neurosurgeons, and disproportionate geographical distribution further increases disparity. Our objective was to geographically map the density of neurosurgeons and emergency neurosurgical services (ENS) in Pakistan. METHODS: This survey was circulated among 307 neurosurgeons. Data were analyzed using SPSS v21. The number of neurosurgeons and ENS were plotted on the population density map using ArcGIS Pro 3.0.0 software. RESULTS: Three hundred and seven neurosurgeons working at 74 centers responded to our survey (93.3% coverage). The current density of neurosurgeons in Pakistan is 0.14/100,000. The 2 more populous provinces, Punjab and Sindh, have 42.3% (130) and 35.8% (110) neurosurgeons, respectively. They also housed nearly 3 quarters of all the neurosurgery centers in urban districts. Karachi and Lahore accommodate 135 (44%) of all the country's neurosurgeons, having 0.29 and 0.51 neurosurgeons/100,000 respectively. Management of traumatic brain injury is offered at 65 centers (87.8%). Nearly all centers are equipped with computed tomography (CT) scan machine (74; 97%), but magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) facility is available at 55 (72%) centers and 37 (49%) centers have angiography suites. Sixty nine centers (93.2%) have C-arm fluoroscopes available. CONCLUSIONS: The geographical mapping of neurosurgeons and neurosurgical facilities is highly skewed towards urban centers, increasing disparity in access to timely neurosurgical emergency services. Four times more neurosurgeons are required in Pakistan to bridge the gap in neurosurgical workforce.
引用
- Bakhshi SK, Shah Z, Khalil M, et al. Geographical Distribution of Neurosurgeons and Emergency Neurosurgical Services in Pakistan. World Neurosurg. 2023. PMID: 37683928. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2023.08.133
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。