文献速递小儿神经外科与脑积水

脊柱裂在线患者教育视频的可靠性与质量

Reliability and Quality of Online Patient Education Videos for Spina Bifida.
PubMed 文献 · World Neurosurg · 2023-06-22

研究于2022年2月在YouTube以脊柱裂、脊柱裂治疗、脊柱裂手术3个关键词检索,取每个关键词前35条视频共105条,58条符合纳入标准并由两名小儿神经外科医生用DISCERN量表评估;仅3条(6.5%)得分3至4分,仅1条(2.1%)平均分大于4分,视频受欢迎程度与DISCERN评分无显著相关,作者建议大学、医院和学术学会发布可靠视频教育内容。

要点

  • 58条纳入视频中仅3条(6.5%)DISCERN得分3至4分,提示可靠但缺少重要信息。
  • 仅1条(2.1%)视频平均分大于4分,为高质量信息来源。
  • 视频受欢迎程度与DISCERN评分无显著相关(按观看次数P=0.361/0.401,按点赞数P=0.459/0.606)。

核心结论

  • 患者及其家属在YouTube搜索脊柱裂信息时通常会遇到低质量的教育内容。
  • 作者建议大学、医院和学术学会参照DISCERN等获批工具发布可靠的视频教育内容,以支持和优化患者教育。

研究设计与样本

  • 2022年2月在YouTube平台以脊柱裂、脊柱裂治疗、脊柱裂手术3个关键词检索,评估每个检索词前35条视频,共105条。
  • 58条视频符合纳入标准,由两名具有6年小儿神经外科经验的独立神经外科医生使用DISCERN量表评估内容。

主要发现

  • 58条纳入视频中,3条(6.5%)DISCERN得分在3至4分之间,提示视频可靠但缺少重要信息。
  • 仅1条(2.1%)视频平均分大于4分,指高质量信息来源。
  • 视频受欢迎程度与是否由健康专业人员发布或是否含手术内容无相关性。
  • 视频受欢迎程度与DISCERN评分之间相关性不显著(按观看次数P=0.361/0.401,按点赞数P=0.459/0.606)。

关键数值与推荐

  • DISCERN得分3至4分:3条视频(6.5%),提示可靠但缺少重要信息。
  • DISCERN平均分大于4分:1条视频(2.1%),指高质量信息来源。
  • 视频受欢迎程度与DISCERN评分相关性:按观看次数P=0.361/0.401,按点赞数P=0.459/0.606。

临床怎么用

  • 作者建议大学、医院和学术学会发布可靠的视频教育内容,以支持和优化患者教育,并参照DISCERN等获批工具。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: There is a growing trend among patients and their families to seek medical information online. Among the world's most popular websites, YouTube is ranked second. Our aim was to assess the reliability and quality of YouTube videos on spina bifida. METHODS: Researchers searched the YouTube platform using 3 search keywords in February 2022. These were spina bifida, spina bifida treatment, and spina bifida surgery. The content of the first 35 videos for each search term was evaluated using the DISCERN scale. Two independent neurosurgeons with 6 years of experience in pediatric neurosurgery evaluated the content of the videos. RESULTS: Of the total 105 videos, 58 met the inclusion criteria and were evaluated. Of these videos, 3 (6.5%) received a score between 3 and4. This suggests that the video is reliable but missing important information. Only one (2.1%) of the videos had a mean score of >4, which refers to a high-quality source of information. It has been found that the popularity of the video was not correlated with whether it was broadcasted by health professionals or whether it has surgical content. The correlation between video popularity and DISCERN score was not significant (P = 0.361/0.401 based on the number of views; P = 0.459/0.606 based on the number of likes). CONCLUSION: Based on the results of this study, patients and their families will generally encounter low-quality educational content on YouTube when searching for information about spina bifida. Since videos on spina bifida are insufficient, we recommend to universities, hospitals, and academic societies publish reliable video education content to support and optimize patient education, in line with approved tools such as DISCERN.

来源:World Neurosurg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Arpa A, Aydin Ozturk P. Reliability and Quality of Online Patient Education Videos for Spina Bifida. World Neurosurg. 2023. PMID: 37355172. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2023.06.058

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。