使用三维打印脑肿瘤模型进行术前规划后切除目标的变化
本研究让32名神经外科医生从10个制造模型中随机选择两个三维打印脑肿瘤模型,按标准化问卷进行术前规划,比较基于二维磁共振成像与基于三维打印模型的规划结果。在64个随机生成的病例中,12例(18.8%)切除目标发生变化。肿瘤位于轴内、手术体位需要俯卧位以及神经外科医生手术灵巧时,切除范围变化率更高;位于大脑后部的三维打印模型2、4和10变化率高。三维打印脑肿瘤模型可用于术前规划以有效确定切除范围。
要点
- 64个随机病例中12例(18.8%)切除目标发生变化。
- 轴内肿瘤、需俯卧位及术者手术灵巧时切除范围变化率更高。
- 位于大脑后部的模型2、4和10切除范围变化率高。
核心结论
- 三维打印脑肿瘤模型可用于术前规划以有效确定切除范围。
研究设计与样本
- 32名神经外科医生(14名主治医师、11名专科培训医师、7名住院医师)从10个制造模型中随机选择两个三维打印脑肿瘤模型,按标准化问卷进行术前规划。
主要发现
- 64个随机生成的病例中,12例(18.8%)切除目标发生变化。
- 肿瘤位于轴内、手术体位需要俯卧位以及神经外科医生手术灵巧时,切除范围变化率更高。
- 位于大脑后部的三维打印模型2、4和10切除范围变化率高。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Conventional 2-Dimensional magnetic resonance imaging-based neuronavigation systems can improve the maximal safe resection in brain tumor surgery but can be unintuitive. A 3-Dimensional (3D)-printed brain tumor model allows for a more intuitive and stereoscopic understanding of brain tumors and adjacent neurovascular structures. This study aimed to identify the clinical efficacy of a 3D-printed brain tumor model in presurgical planning by focusing on differences in the extent of resection (EOR). METHODS: Thirty two neurosurgeons (14 faculty members, 11 fellows, 7 residents) randomly selected the two 3D-printed brain tumor models from the 10 manufactured models and performed presurgical planning following a standardized questionnaire. To compare the 2-Dimensional magnetic resonance imaging-based planning results with the 3D-printed model-based planning results, we analyzed the changing patterns and characteristics of the EOR. RESULTS: Of 64 randomly generated cases, the resection goal changed in 12 cases (18.8%). When the tumor was located intra-axially, the surgical posture required a prone position, and when the neurosurgeon was dexterous in surgery, there was a higher rate of EOR changes. 3D-printed models 2, 4, and 10, which all represented tumors in the posterior of the brain, had high rates of changing EOR. CONCLUSIONS: A 3D-printed brain tumor model could be utilized in presurgical planning to effectively determine the EOR.
引用
- Kim KM, Byun YH, Kang H, et al. Changes of Resection Goal After Using 3-Dimensional Printing Brain Tumor Model for Presurgical Planning. World Neurosurg. 2023. PMID: 37302706. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2023.06.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。