拓扑数据分析及Mapper在基于三维形状分析的脑动脉瘤破裂状态判别中的应用
本研究对216个分叉部动脉瘤(90个破裂)的三维旋转血管造影模型提取12个尺寸/形状特征和18个增强影像组学特征,用Mapper拓扑数据分析构建图结构并计算MDS。破裂动脉瘤对的平均MDS显著大于未破裂对(0.055±0.027 vs 0.039±0.015,P<.0001),MDS阈值0.0417判别破裂状态的AUC=0.73(特异性80%,敏感性60%)。将MDS纳入多变量分析后AUC=0.82,优于单独尺寸/形状(AUC=0.76)和增强影像组学(AUC=0.78)。
要点
- 破裂动脉瘤对的平均MDS显著大于未破裂对(0.055±0.027 vs 0.039±0.015,P<.0001)。
- MDS阈值0.0417判别破裂状态:AUC=0.73,特异性80%,敏感性60%。
- 含MDS的多变量分析AUC=0.82,优于单独尺寸/形状(0.76)和增强影像组学(0.78)。
核心结论
- 提出Mapper拓扑数据分析用于动脉瘤评估的新应用,在破裂状态分类方面结果有前景。
- 纳入Mapper的多变量分析获得高准确度,鉴于分叉部动脉瘤形态学分类困难,这一点尤为重要。
- 本概念验证研究需未来进一步研究以优化Mapper功能用于动脉瘤研究。
研究设计与样本
- 来自三维旋转血管造影的216个分叉部动脉瘤(90个破裂),从血管结构分割并评估12个尺寸/形状特征和18个增强影像组学特征。
- 使用Mapper将均匀致密动脉瘤模型表示为图结构,并以图形状指标描述。
- 基于形状指标计算动脉瘤对之间的Mapper相异度评分(MDS),较低MDS描述相似形状,高MDS表示不共享共同特征的形状。
- 对每个动脉瘤评估破裂/未破裂平均MDS评分(分别表示动脉瘤在形状上与破裂/未破裂数据集的「距离」)。
- 报告所有特征判别破裂状态的单变量和多变量统计。
主要发现
- 破裂动脉瘤对的平均MDS显著大于未破裂对(0.055±0.027 vs 0.039±0.015,P<.0001)。
- 低MDS提示与破裂动脉瘤相反,未破裂动脉瘤具有相似的形状特征。
- 确定MDS阈值0.0417用于破裂状态分类(AUC=0.73,特异性80%,敏感性60%);在该预测模型下,MDS评分<0.0417将识别为未破裂状态。
- MDS判别破裂状态的统计性能与nonsphericity和影像组学Flatness相似(AUC=0.73),优于其他特征。
- 与未破裂相比,破裂动脉瘤更细长(P<.0001)、更扁平(P<.0001)且nonsphericity更高(P<.0001)。
关键数值与推荐
- MDS阈值0.0417判别破裂状态:AUC=0.73,特异性80%,敏感性60%。
- 含MDS的多变量分析AUC=0.82,优于单独尺寸/形状多变量分析(AUC=0.76)和单独增强影像组学多变量分析(AUC=0.78)。
- 破裂动脉瘤对的平均MDS为0.055±0.027,未破裂对为0.039±0.015(P<.0001)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 本概念验证研究需未来进一步研究以优化Mapper功能用于动脉瘤研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Topological data analysis (TDA), which identifies patterns in data through simplified topological signatures, has yet to be applied to aneurysm research. We investigate TDA Mapper graphs (Mapper) for aneurysm rupture discrimination. METHODS: Two hundred sixteen bifurcation aneurysms (90 ruptured) from 3-dimensional rotational angiography were segmented from vasculature and evaluated for 12 size/shape and 18 enhanced radiomics features. Using Mapper, uniformly dense aneurysm models were represented as graph structures and described by graph shape metrics. Mapper dissimilarity scores (MDS) were computed between pairs of aneurysms based on shape metrics. Lower MDS described similar shapes, whereas high MDS represented shapes that do not share common characteristics. Ruptured/unruptured average MDS scores (how "far" an aneurysm is shape-wise to ruptured/unruptured data sets, respectively) were evaluated for each aneurysm. Rupture status discrimination univariate and multivariate statistics were reported for all features. RESULTS: The average MDS for pairs of ruptured aneurysms were significantly larger compared with unruptured pairs (0.055 ± 0.027 vs 0.039 ± 0.015, P < .0001). Low MDS suggest that, in contrast to ruptured aneurysms, unruptured aneurysms have similar shape characteristics. An MDS threshold value of 0.0417 (area under the curve [AUC] = 0.73, 80% specificity, 60% sensitivity) was identified for rupture status classification. Under this predictive model, MDS scores <0.0417 would identify unruptured status. MDS statistical performance in discriminating rupture status was similar to that of nonsphericity and radiomics Flatness (AUC = 0.73), outperforming other features. Ruptured aneurysms were more elongated ( P < .0001), flatter ( P < .0001), and showed higher nonsphericity ( P < .0001) compared with unruptured. Including MDS in multivariate analysis resulted in AUC = 0.82, outperforming multivariate analysis on size/shape (AUC = 0.76) and enhanced radiomics (AUC = 0.78) alone. CONCLUSION: A novel application of Mapper TDA was proposed for aneurysm evaluation, with promising results for rupture status classification. Multivariate analysis incorporating Mapper resulted in high accuracy, which is particularly important given that bifurcation aneurysms are challenging to classify morphologically. This proof-of-concept study warrants future investigation into optimizing Mapper functionality for aneurysm research.
引用
- Lauric A, Ludwig CG, Malek AM, et al. Topological Data Analysis and Use of Mapper for Cerebral Aneurysm Rupture Status Discrimination Based on 3-Dimensional Shape Analysis. Neurosurgery. 2023. PMID: 37387576. doi:10.1227/neu.0000000000002570
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。