外科医生输入可提升登记数据价值:美国脊柱登记系统的早期经验
研究比较了美国脊柱登记系统(ASR)中外科医生标注的诊断指征与医院报告的ICD-10编码在腰椎手术中的一致性。在5926例单纯减压病例中,椎管狭窄的一致率为89%,腰椎间盘突出和/或神经根病为78%;在5663例腰椎融合病例中,脊椎滑脱的一致率为76%,其他诊断指征一致性较差。结论提示标准ICD-10编码可能不足以明确腰椎退行性疾病减压或融合的手术指征。
要点
- 单纯减压病例中,外科医生与ICD-10编码对椎管狭窄的一致率为89%。
- 腰椎融合病例中,脊椎滑脱的一致率为76%,其他诊断指征一致性较差。
- 标准ICD-10编码可能不足以明确腰椎退行性疾病的手术指征。
核心结论
- 外科医生标注的诊断指征与医院报告的ICD-10编码在单纯减压病例中一致性最好。
- 融合病例中脊椎滑脱组与ICD-10编码一致性最好(76%),其他病例因多诊断或缺乏反映病理的ICD-10编码而一致性较差。
- 研究提示标准ICD-10编码可能不足以明确腰椎退行性疾病减压或融合的手术指征。
研究设计与样本
- 美国脊柱登记系统(ASR)数据收集包含标注每个手术外科医生特定诊断指征的选项。
- 纳入2020年1月至2022年3月治疗的病例,比较外科医生标注诊断与标准ASR电子病历数据提取生成的ICD-10诊断。
- 单纯减压病例主要分析神经压迫病因,腰椎融合病例主要分析可能需要融合的结构性病理。
主要发现
- 在5926例单纯减压病例中,外科医生与ASR ICD-10编码对椎管狭窄的一致率为89%,对腰椎间盘突出和/或神经根病的一致率为78%。
- 外科医生和数据库均指示无结构性病理(即无)提示需要融合的病例占88%。
- 在5663例腰椎融合病例中,脊椎滑脱的一致率为76%,其他诊断指征的一致性较差。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Clear diagnostic delineation is necessary for the development of a strong evidence base in lumbar spinal surgery. Experience with existing national databases suggests that International Classification of Diseases, Tenth Edition (ICD-10) coding is insufficient to support that need. The purpose of this study was to assess agreement between surgeon-specified diagnostic indication and hospital-reported ICD-10 codes for lumbar spine surgery. METHODS: Data collection for the American Spine Registry (ASR) includes an option to denote the surgeon's specific diagnostic indication for each procedure. For cases treated between January 2020 and March 2022, surgeon-delineated diagnosis was compared with the ICD-10 diagnosis generated by standard ASR electronic medical record data extraction. For decompression-only cases, the primary analysis focused on the etiology of neural compression as determined by the surgeon versus that determined on the basis of the related ICD-10 codes extracted from the ASR database. For lumbar fusion cases, the primary analysis compared structural pathology, which may have required fusion, as determined by the surgeon versus that determined on the basis of the extracted ICD-10 codes. This allowed for identification of agreement between surgeon delineation and extracted ICD-10 codes. RESULTS: In 5926 decompression-only cases, agreement between the surgeon and ASR ICD-10 codes was 89% for spinal stenosis and 78% for lumbar disc herniation and/or radiculopathy. Both the surgeon and database indicated no structural pathology (i.e., none) suggesting the need for fusion in 88% of cases. In 5663 lumbar fusion cases, agreement was 76% for spondylolisthesis but poor for other diagnostic indications. CONCLUSIONS: Agreement between surgeon-specified diagnostic indication and hospital-reported ICD-10 codes was best for patients who underwent decompression only. In the fusion cases, agreement with ICD-10 codes was best in the spondylolisthesis group (76%). In cases other than spondylolisthesis, agreement was poor due to multiple diagnoses or lack of an ICD-10 code that reflected the pathology. This study suggested that standard ICD-10 codes may be inadequate to clearly define the indications for decompression or fusion in patients with lumbar degenerative disease.
引用
- Glassman SD, Carreon LY, Asher AL, et al. Surgeon input can increase the value of registry data: early experience from the American Spine Registry. J Neurosurg Spine. 2023. PMID: 37209078. doi:10.3171/2023.4.SPINE23135
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。