文献速递脊柱脊髓外科

2013年至2018年北京脊柱手术后医疗过失诉讼分析

Medical Malpractice Litigation After Spine Surgery in Beijing Between 2013 and 2018.
PubMed 文献 · World Neurosurg · 2023-05-03

该研究分析2013年1月至2018年12月北京脊柱手术后医疗过失诉讼,检索两个在线法律数据库,纳入64例案件。最常见诉因为知情同意不足(53.1%,n=34),其次为需再次手术(40.2%,n=26)。脊柱外科医生在13例(20.3%)中成功辩护,其余51例(79.7%)结案,平均赔偿22,597美元,显著低于原告诉求的11,3762美元(P<0.05)。

要点

  • 最常见诉因为知情同意不足(53.1%,n=34)。
  • 脊柱外科医生在13例(20.3%)中成功辩护,无赔偿。
  • 51例(79.7%)结案,平均赔偿22,597美元,显著低于诉求的11,3762美元(P<0.05)。

核心结论

  • 该研究全面总结了北京脊柱手术后医疗过失诉讼情况;鉴于脊柱手术快速增长及相关诉讼负担,脊柱外科医生了解脊柱手术潜在法律影响有价值。
  • 最常见诉因为知情同意不足;作者认为在中国脊柱外科医生应更重视与患者沟通,并基于异常影像而非病史和体格检查决定是否行脊柱手术,以帮助降低诉讼率并改善患者体验。

研究设计与样本

  • 检索两个在线法律数据库Wusong和Weike,获取2013年1月至2018年12月北京涉及脊柱手术的法院判决。
  • 共识别186例法律案件,排除122例因不相关或信息不足,最终纳入64例案件进行描述性分析。

主要发现

  • 64例案件中患者男性占40.6%,原告平均年龄53.2±18.6岁。
  • 最常见诉因为知情同意不足(53.1%,n=34),其次为需再次手术(40.2%,n=26)、对手术结果不满意(17.6%,n=11)、术后瘫痪(15.6%,n=10)和术后感染(15.6%,n=10)。
  • 最常见原发疾病为腰椎管狭窄(28.1%,n=18),其次为脊柱肿瘤(18.8%,n=12)、颈椎病(17.2%,n=11)、椎体骨折(14.1%,n=9)、畸形(12.5%,n=8)和其他(9.3%,n=6)。
  • 脊柱外科医生在13例(20.3%)中成功辩护,无赔偿支付;其余51例(79.7%)结案,平均赔偿22,597美元,显著低于原告诉求的平均赔偿11,3762美元(P<0.05)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,在中国脊柱外科医生应更重视与患者沟通,并基于异常影像而非病史和体格检查决定是否行脊柱手术,以帮助降低诉讼率并改善患者体验。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to analyze the characteristics of alleged medical malpractice litigation involving spine surgery in Beijing between 2013 and 2018. METHODS: Two online legal databases, Wusong and Weike, were queried for court verdicts involving spine surgery from January 2013 to December 2018 in Beijing. For all included cases, data pertaining to defendants, plaintiffs, case outcomes, allegations, and verdicts were abstracted, and descriptive analyses were performed. RESULTS: A total of 186 legal cases were identified, and 122 cases were excluded because of irrelevance or insufficient information. Of the patients in the 64 cases included in this investigation, 40.6% were male. The mean age of the plaintiffs was 53.2 ± 18.6 years. The most common complaint addressed in this study is inadequate consent (53.1%; n = 34), followed by additional surgery required (40.2%; n = 26), being unsatisfied with the outcome of surgery (17.6%; n = 11), postoperative paralysis (15.6%; n = 10), and postoperative infection (15.6%; n = 10). The most common primary disease among all the cases is lumbar spinal stenosis (28.1%; n = 18), followed by spinal tumor (18.8%; n = 12), cervical spondylosis (17.2%; n = 11), vertebral fracture (14.1%; n = 9), deformity (12.5%; n = 8), and others (9.3%; n = 6). Spine surgeons successfully defended themselves in 13 cases (20.3%), which resulted in no indemnity payment. The remaining 51 cases (79.7%) were closed with an average verdict payout of U.S. $22,597, which was significantly lower than the average compensation claimed by the plaintiff (U.S. $11,3762) (P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: This study comprehensively summarized the medical alleged malpractice litigation after spine surgery in Beijing. Given the rapid growth rate of spine surgery and the burden of related alleged medical malpractice litigation, it is valuable for spine surgeons to understand the potential legal impact of spine surgery. The most common complaint addressed in this study is inadequate consent. The findings in the present study highlight that in China, spine surgeons should pay more attention to communication with patients and perform spine surgery based on abnormal imaging as opposed to what the history and physical examination dictate, which can help reduce the litigation rate and improve the patient experience.

来源:World Neurosurg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hu D, Liu H, Xiao S, et al. Medical Malpractice Litigation After Spine Surgery in Beijing Between 2013 and 2018. World Neurosurg. 2023. PMID: 37146878. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2023.04.082

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。