运动性头部损伤中头部CT阳性发现的运动员能否重返赛场
这项回顾性单机构队列研究纳入2017年11月至2022年4月区域脑震荡中心就诊的12至23岁运动员2061名,其中226名(11.0%)接受头部CT,9名(4.0%)CT阳性。CT阳性运动员重返学习与重返赛场时间均长于CT阴性对照,但症状缓解时间无差异,所有CT阳性运动员均非手术治疗并成功重返赛场。
要点
- 在区域脑震荡中心接受急性头部CT的运动员中,CT阳性发现率为4.0%。
- CT阳性运动员重返学习17.0天 vs 对照4.0天,重返赛场73.0天 vs 对照27.0天。
- CT阳性与对照的症状缓解时间无差异,全部CT阳性运动员均成功重返赛场。
核心结论
- 在区域脑震荡中心接受急性头部CT的运动员中,CT阳性发现率为4.0%。
- 尽管CT阳性运动员重返学习和重返赛场时间更长,但症状缓解时间与CT阴性者相似。
- 所有CT阳性运动员均成功重返赛场,尽管对CT阳性运动员采取更保守的处理,临床结局与CT阴性者相似。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性单机构队列研究,纳入2017年11月至2022年4月区域脑震荡中心就诊的12至23岁运动员共2061名。
- 队列按头部CT阳性与阴性(对照)二分,比较急性损伤特征及以重返学习天数、症状缓解和重返赛场天数衡量的恢复情况。
- 采用χ²检验和Mann-Whitney U检验进行统计分析。
主要发现
- 2061名运动员中226名(11.0%)接受头部CT,9名(4.0%)CT阳性。
- CT阳性发现包括4例(44.4%)硬膜下血肿、1例(11.1%)硬膜外血肿、2例(22.2%)面部骨折、1例(11.1%)软组织挫伤和1例(11.1%)海绵状血管畸形。
- 全部9名(100.0%)CT阳性运动员均接受非手术治疗,并在中位(IQR)73.0(55.0-82.0)天成功重返赛场。
- CT阳性组与对照组在意识丧失或遗忘方面未见差异。
- Mann-Whitney U检验显示重返学习(17.0 vs 4.0天;U=45.0,P=.016)和重返赛场(73.0 vs 27.0天;U=47.5,P=.007)存在差异,但症状缓解无差异。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The literature on athletes with positive head computed tomography (HCT) findings in the setting of sport head injuries remains sparse. OBJECTIVE: To report the proportions of athletes with a positive HCT and compare acute injury characteristics and recovery between those with and without a positive HCT. METHODS: A retrospective, single-institution, cohort study was performed with all athletes aged 12 to 23 years seen at a regional concussion center from 11/2017 to 04/2022. The cohort was dichotomized into positive vs negative HCT (controls). Acute injury characteristics (ie, loss of consciousness and amnesia) and recovery, as measured by days to return-to-learn (RTL), symptom resolution, and return-to-play (RTP) were compared. χ 2 and Mann-Whitney U tests were performed. RESULTS: Of 2061 athletes, 226 (11.0%) received an HCT and 9 (4.0%) had positive findings. HCT findings included 4 (44.4%) subdural hematomas, 1 (11.1%) epidural hematoma, 2 (22.2%) facial fractures, 1 (11.1%) soft tissue contusion, and 1 (11.1%) cavernous malformation. All 9 (100.0%) athletes were treated nonoperatively and successfully returned-to-play at a median (IQR) of 73.0 (55.0-82.0) days. No differences in loss of consciousness or amnesia were seen between positive HCT group and controls. The Mann-Whitney U test showed differences in RTL (17.0 vs 4.0 days; U = 45.0, P = .016) and RTP (73.0 vs 27.0 days; U = 47.5, P = .007) but not in symptom resolution. Our subanalysis showed no differences across all recovery metrics between acute hemorrhages and controls. CONCLUSION: Among athletes seen at a regional concussion center who underwent an acute HCT, positive findings were seen in 4%. Although athletes with a positive HCT had longer RTL and RTP, symptom resolution was similar between those with a positive and negative HCT. All athletes with a positive HCT successfully returned to play. Despite a more conservative approach to athletes with a positive HCT, clinical outcomes are similar between those with and without a positive HCT.
引用
- Jo J, Williams KL, Jonzzon S, et al. Positive Head Computed Tomography Findings in the Setting of Sport Head Injuries: Can These Athletes Return-to-Play? Neurosurgery. 2023. PMID: 37166195. doi:10.1227/neu.0000000000002520
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。