锥形钻头用于优化脑室外引流管置入的概念验证研究
该概念验证研究设计并制造了30°和45°锥形钻头,在模拟实验室和3具人尸体上测试其用于脑室外引流管置入的性能。结果显示锥形钻头在Likert评分上显著优于标准钻头,作为补救策略时导管角度调整范围增大6至9倍,硬脑膜意外穿刺率为零。
要点
- 30°和45°锥形钻头的Likert评分中位数分别为4.7和4,显著高于标准钻头的1.7(p<0.0001)。
- 锥形钻头作为补救策略时,导管角度调整范围比标准钻头增大6至9倍,硬脑膜意外穿刺率为零。
- 30°和45°锥形钻头的钻孔时间显著长于标准钻头(p=0.036和p=0.002)。
核心结论
- 30°锥形钻头可单独安全使用或作为补救工具,可能提高脑室外引流管置入的信心、可视化、靶向性和精确度,同时基本消除意外硬脑膜穿刺的可能性,且总手术时间增加极小。
研究设计与样本
- 设计并制造30°和45°锥形钻头,在模拟实验室环境和3具颅骨、硬脑膜及脑组织完整的人尸体上进行测试,由神经外科受训人员使用Likert量表型问题对钻头性能进行多维度评分。
主要发现
- 实验室中,标准钻头与30°和45°锥形钻头邻近钻孔处的最高钻孔温度无显著差异(p=0.631和p=0.326)。
- 45°锥形钻头在钻孔部位正下方的最高温度显著高于标准钻头(p=0.043),标准钻头与30°锥形钻头之间无显著差异(p=0.783)。
- 尸体测试中,30°和45°锥形钻头的钻孔时间显著长于标准钻头(p=0.036和p=0.002)。
- 锥形30°(中位数[IQR] 4.7[3.3-5])和45°(4[2-5])钻头的Likert评分显著高于标准钻头(1.7[1-2.5],p<0.0001),表明性能显著更好。
- 锥形钻头作为补救策略使用时,脑室外引流导管角度调整范围比标准钻头增大6至9倍,硬脑膜意外穿刺率为零。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为30°锥形钻头可单独安全使用或作为补救工具,可能提高脑室外引流管置入的信心、可视化、靶向性和精确度,同时基本消除意外硬脑膜穿刺的可能性,且总手术时间增加极小。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Despite external ventricular drain (EVD) procedures being commonplace in neurosurgical practice, suboptimal placement rates remain high, and complications are not uncommon. The angle of the EVD catheter insertion and the accuracy of the drill hole placement are major factors determining successful EVD placement that are dependent on the drill bit morphology. The standard cylindrical 2-fluted twist drill bit creates a relatively deep and narrow drill hole that requires precise positioning, has limited visibility of the drill hole bottom and restricted catheter angular adjustment range, and poses the risk of inadvertent dural puncture. To overcome the standard problems associated with EVD drill bit morphology, the authors propose novel cone-shaped drill bits for EVD placement. METHODS: Conical drill bits of 30° and 45° were designed, manufactured, and tested in a simulated laboratory setting as well as in three human cadavers with intact skull, dura mater, and brain. Drill bit performance was rated by neurosurgical trainees across various domains using Likert scale-type questions. RESULTS: In the laboratory, maximum drilling temperatures adjacent to the drill hole were recorded and compared for the standard drill bit and the 30° and 45° conical drill bits and were not significantly different (p = 0.631 and p = 0.326, respectively). The maximum temperature recorded directly underneath the drilling site for the 45° drill bit was significantly higher than the temperature of the standard drill bit (p = 0.043). The differences between the standard and 30° drill bits were not significant (p = 0.783). Upon cadaver testing, the drilling times with 30° and 45° conical drill bits were significantly longer than those with the standard drill bit (p = 0.036 and p = 0.002, respectively). Likert scale scores were significantly higher for the conical 30° (median [IQR] 4.7 [3.3-5]) and 45° (4 [2-5]) drill bits than for the standard drill bit (1.7 [1-2.5], p < 0.0001), indicating significantly better performance. Conical drill bits used as a "rescue" strategy allowed for an EVD catheter angular adjustment range 6 to 9 times greater than that for the standard drill bit and resulted in a zero inadvertent dural puncture rate. CONCLUSIONS: The 30° conical drill bit can be safely used on its own or as a rescue tool to potentially achieve improved confidence, visualization, targeting, and precision of EVD placement while essentially eliminating the possibility of unintentional dural puncture with minimal increase in the total procedure time.
引用
- Ravina K, Yang N, Brocoum S, et al. Conical drill bit for optimized external ventricular drain placement: a proof-of-concept study. J Neurosurg. 2023. PMID: 36790016. doi:10.3171/2022.12.JNS221719
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。