微创手术治疗脊柱畸形的复杂性核对表:微创国际脊柱研究组专家共识
微创国际脊柱研究组采用改良德尔菲法,由10名微创脊柱畸形手术专家制定脊柱畸形复杂性核对表(SDCC),涵盖X线、MRI、CT及患者相关四类特征,共识别影响微创手术复杂性的影像学与患者因素,并给出评分4分者微创治疗具挑战性、开放手术可能更优的共识。
要点
- SDCC涵盖X线、MRI、CT及患者相关四类特征,用于快速评估微创脊柱畸形手术复杂性。
- 脊柱骨盆特征、内固定端点及既往内固定/融合与复杂性增加相关。
- 任何特征评分为4分的患者,微创治疗具挑战性,开放手术可能更优。
核心结论
- SDCC是影响微创脊柱畸形手术复杂性相关影像学与患者特征的综合列表,可快速评估微创手术能否有效安全实施。
- 任何特征评分为4分的患者,微创治疗具挑战性,开放手术可能更优。
研究设计与样本
- 采用改良德尔菲法,由10名微创脊柱畸形手术专家参与制定并完善SDCC。
- SDCC包含X线、磁共振成像、计算机断层扫描3个影像学类别和1个患者相关类别,通过首轮圆桌讨论识别特征,第二轮讨论确定影响复杂性最大的特征。
主要发现
- X线类别确定13个特征,脊柱骨盆特征、内固定端点及既往内固定/融合与复杂性增加相关。
- 椎体旋转(以Nash-Moe分级反映)增加显著复杂性。
- MRI类别5个特征中,腰大肌解剖和椎管狭窄增加复杂性最多。
- CT类别3个特征中,既往融合是被选择最多的变量。
- 患者相关类别5个特征中,骨质疏松和体重指数对复杂性影响最大。
关键数值与推荐
- 任何特征评分为4分的患者,应视为微创治疗具挑战性,开放手术可能更优。
临床怎么用
- SDCC可用于快速评估关键因素,判断微创手术能否有效安全实施。
- 任何特征评分为4分的患者,微创治疗具挑战性,开放手术可能更优。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: We developed a spinal deformity complexity checklist (SDCC) to assess the difficulty in performing a circumferential minimally invasive surgery (MIS) for adult spinal deformity. METHODS: A modified Delphi method of panel experts was used to construct an SDCC checklist of radiographic and patient-related characteristics that could affect the complexity of surgery via MIS approaches. Ten surgeons with expertise in MIS deformity surgery were queried to develop and refine the SDCC with 3 radiographic categories (x-ray, magnetic resonance imaging, computed tomography) and 1 patient-related category. Within each category, characteristics affecting MIS complexity were identified by initial roundtable discussion. Second-round discussion determined which characteristics substantially impacted complexity the most. RESULTS: Thirteen characteristics within the x-ray category were determined. Spinopelvic characteristics, endpoints of instrumentation, and prior hardware/fusion were associated with increased complexity. Vertebral body rotation-as reflected by the Nash-Moe grade-added significant complexity. Psoas anatomy and spinal stenosis added the most complexity for the 5 magnetic resonance imaging characteristics. There were 3 characteristics in the CT category with pre-exisiting fusion, being the variable most highly selected. Of the 5 patient-related characteristics, osteoporosis and BMI were found to most affect complexity. CONCLUSIONS: The SDCC is a comprehensive list of pertinent radiographic and patient-related characteristics affecting complexity level for MIS deformity surgery. The value of the SDCC is that it allows rapid assessment of key factors when determining whether MIS surgery can be performed effectively and safely. Patients with scores of 4 in any characteristic should be considered challenging to treat with MIS; open surgery may be a better alternative.
引用
- Anand N, Mummaneni PV, Uribe JS, et al. Spinal Deformity Complexity Checklist for Minimally Invasive Surgery: Expert Consensus from the Minimally Invasive International Spine Study Group. World Neurosurg. 2023. PMID: 36841536. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2023.02.082
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。