成人胶质瘤患者多模式治疗后的认知结局:一项荟萃分析
该荟萃分析系统检索7098篇文献,最终分析37项研究、4078例患者,评估成人胶质瘤患者治疗后1年各认知测验的特异性结局。纵向设计中语义流畅性对认知下降最敏感,无间隔测试者MMSE、顺背数字、音位与语义流畅性随时间下降;横断面研究中患者多项测验表现差于对照。作者认为未来纵向试验需充分校正练习效应。
要点
- 纵向设计中语义流畅性对检测认知下降最敏感。
- 无间隔测试者MMSE、顺背数字、音位与语义流畅性随时间下降。
- 横断面研究中患者MMSE、倒背数字、语义流畅性、Stroop速度干扰任务、连线测验B及手指敲击表现差于对照。
核心结论
- 胶质瘤患者治疗后1年认知表现显著低于常模,特定测验可能更敏感。
- 认知下降随时间发生,但纵向设计中因间隔测试所致练习效应易被忽视。
- 作者认为未来纵向试验有必要充分校正练习效应。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索获得7098篇文章供筛选。
- 共审阅83项研究,其中37项纳入荟萃分析,涉及4078例患者。
- 按认知测验分别进行随机效应荟萃分析,纵向与横断面设计研究分开分析。
- 采用以间隔测试为调节变量的荟萃回归分析,探讨纵向设计中练习的影响。
主要发现
- 纵向设计中,语义流畅性是检测随时间认知下降最敏感的测验。
- 在无间隔测试的患者中,MMSE、顺背数字、音位流畅性与语义流畅性表现随时间下降。
- 横断面研究中,患者MMSE、倒背数字、语义流畅性、Stroop速度干扰任务、连线测验B及手指敲击表现差于对照。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Cognitive functioning is increasingly assessed as a secondary outcome in neuro-oncological trials. However, which cognitive domains or tests to assess, remains debatable. In this meta-analysis, we aimed to elucidate the longer-term test-specific cognitive outcomes in adult glioma patients. METHODS: A systematic search yielded 7098 articles for screening. To investigate cognitive changes in glioma patients and differences between patients and controls 1-year follow-up, random-effects meta-analyses were conducted per cognitive test, separately for studies with a longitudinal and cross-sectional design. A meta-regression analysis with a moderator for interval testing (additional cognitive testing between baseline and 1-year posttreatment) was performed to investigate the impact of practice in longitudinal designs. RESULTS: Eighty-three studies were reviewed, of which 37 were analyzed in the meta-analysis, involving 4078 patients. In longitudinal designs, semantic fluency was the most sensitive test to detect cognitive decline over time. Cognitive performance on mini-mental state exam (MMSE), digit span forward, phonemic and semantic fluency declined over time in patients who had no interval testing. In cross-sectional studies, patients performed worse than controls on the MMSE, digit span backward, semantic fluency, Stroop speed interference task, trail-making test B, and finger tapping. CONCLUSIONS: Cognitive performance of glioma patients 1 year after treatment is significantly lower compared to the norm, with specific tests potentially being more sensitive. Cognitive decline over time occurs as well, but can easily be overlooked in longitudinal designs due to practice effects (as a result of interval testing). It is warranted to sufficiently correct for practice effects in future longitudinal trials.
引用
- De Roeck L, Gillebert CR, van Aert RCM, et al. Cognitive outcomes after multimodal treatment in adult glioma patients: A meta-analysis. Neuro Oncol. 2023. PMID: 36809489. doi:10.1093/neuonc/noad045
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。