确立未来脑积水研究的优先事项排序
脑积水协会采用James Lind Alliance(JLA)验证方法,通过两轮调查和虚拟研讨会,从890名受访者的3703条回答中经146条长清单、49条短清单和21条优先条目,最终形成排名前20的脑积水研究优先事项清单。
要点
- 采用JLA方法,经两轮调查和共识研讨会形成前20项脑积水研究优先事项排序。
- 第一轮调查获890名受访者3703条回答,形成146条优先声明长清单。
- 短清单49条均经非系统文献综述验证为研究不确定性,最终确定前20项排序。
核心结论
- 通过广泛收集脑积水社区意见并采用迭代共识流程,制定了排名前20的脑积水研究优先事项清单。
- 脑积水协会将用此排序清单指导未来研究项目,并鼓励医疗和科学界同样采用。
研究设计与样本
- 采用James Lind Alliance(JLA)验证方法,由脑积水协会实施两轮调查并举办最终优先事项研讨会。
- 第一轮调查收集开放式回答,据此制定优先声明长清单并整合为短清单,经非系统文献综述验证为研究不确定性。
- 第二轮调查要求社区成员从短清单中选出前10项优先事项。
- 最终优先事项排序在培训引导员团队主持的虚拟研讨会上通过迭代共识流程完成。
主要发现
- 第一轮调查收集890名受访者的3703条回答,形成146条优先声明长清单。
- 整合后的短清单包含49条研究优先声明,均经非系统文献综述验证为脑积水研究中的不确定性。
- 第二轮调查分析确定前21条研究优先声明,经虚拟研讨会共识形成最终排名前20的脑积水研究优先事项清单。
- 最终清单显示多个领域需求明显:开发无创和/或一次性疗法、减轻当前治疗负担、改进脑积水筛查和诊断、改善生活质量、改善护理可及性。
关键数值与推荐
- 第一轮调查:890名受访者提供3703条回答。
- 长清单:146条优先声明。
- 短清单:49条研究优先声明,均验证为研究不确定性。
- 第二轮调查确定前21条研究优先声明,最终共识形成排名前20的优先事项清单。
临床怎么用
- 脑积水协会将使用该排序清单指导未来研究项目,并鼓励医疗和科学界同样采用。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The aim of this initiative was to develop a ranked list of hydrocephalus research priorities as determined by the hydrocephalus patient community in conjunction with the healthcare and scientific community. METHODS: Using the validated methodology published by the James Lind Alliance (JLA), the Hydrocephalus Association (HA) administered two surveys and hosted a final prioritization workshop. Survey One solicited open-ended responses from the community. From these responses, a long list of priority statements was developed. This list was then consolidated into a short list of research priority statements, which, after a nonsystematic literature review, were verified as being research uncertainties. Survey Two asked the community members to select their top 10 priorities from the short list. The final prioritization leading to a final ranked top 20 list of hydrocephalus research priorities took place at a virtual workshop led by a team of trained facilitators, by means of an iterative process of consensus building. RESULTS: From Survey One, 3703 responses from 890 respondents were collected, leading to a long list of 146 priority statements. The consolidated short list contained 49 research priority statements, all of which were verified as uncertainties in hydrocephalus research. From an analysis of Survey Two responses, the top 21 research priority statements were determined. A consensus on these statements was reached at the virtual workshop, leading to a final ranked top 20 list of hydrocephalus research priorities, within which needs were apparent in several areas: development of noninvasive and/or one-time therapies, reduction of the burden of current treatments, improvement of the screening and diagnosis of hydrocephalus, improved quality of life, and improved access to care. CONCLUSIONS: By gathering extensive input from the hydrocephalus community and using an iterative process of consensus building, a ranked list of the top 20 hydrocephalus research priorities was developed. The HA will use this ranked list to guide future research programs and encourages the healthcare and scientific community to do the same.
引用
- Jakopin NE, Myong E, Bogucki T, et al. Establishing ranked priorities for future hydrocephalus research. J Neurosurg. 2022. PMID: 36681979. doi:10.3171/2022.10.JNS22753
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。