指南与共识脊柱脊髓外科

脊柱外科专家证人证言:专业组织指南与推荐意见综述

Expert Witness Testimony in Spine Surgery: A Review of Guidelines and Recommendations From Professional Organizations.
指南 / 共识 · Neurosurgery · 2022-11-18

本文综述了脊柱外科专业学会为担任专家证人的脊柱外科医生制定的指南,检索了Gale Directory Library、PubMed和灰色文献,纳入26个学会,其中10个有公开指南。现有指南在资格、准备、作证和报酬4个领域存在显著异质性,且缺乏标准化和全面的材料。

要点

  • 26个脊柱相关学会中仅10个有公开的专家证人指南
  • 仅3个学会的指南覆盖资格、准备、作证和报酬全部4个领域
  • 8个学会设有专业合规程序,但整体指南仍缺乏标准化

核心结论

  • 脊柱外科专业学会提供的专家证人指南仍然匮乏,现有推荐虽有用但缺乏标准化和全面性。
  • 由外科医生、律师和患者利益相关方组成的联合委员会可能有助于改进指南。

研究设计与样本

  • 综述:检索Gale Directory Library、PubMed和灰色文献,纳入26个与美国和北美相关及部分国际脊柱外科专业学会,提取有公开专家证人指南的学会并分析4个领域。

主要发现

  • 纳入的26个学会中,10个有公开的专家证人指南:4个为普通神经外科、2个为普通骨科、4个为脊柱专科。
  • 3个学会的指南覆盖全部4个领域(资格、准备、作证、报酬),2个学会仅覆盖其中1个领域。
  • 8个学会设有专业合规程序。

关键数值与推荐

  • 分析领域为:资格、准备、作证、报酬,以及是否存在专业合规程序。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 现有推荐在细节和范围上有限,且各学会间存在显著异质性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Most professional spine societies have enacted formal guidelines for spine surgeons providing expert witness services. However, there is significant heterogeneity in existing recommendations, with most societies providing information that is limited in detail and scope. OBJECTIVE: To provide a review of guidelines published by professional spine societies for spine surgeons serving as expert witnesses. METHODS: The Gale Directory Library, PubMed, and the grey literature were queried for national or international professional societies related to spine surgery. The search was focused on societies in the United States and North America, but also included well recognized international organizations in the field of spine surgery. Included societies with publicly available guidelines regarding expert witness services were extracted for 4 domains: (1) qualifications, (2) preparations, (3) testimony, and (4) compensation as well as the presence of a professional compliance program, defined as any official subcommittee aimed toward investigating claims of unethical behavior. RESULTS: Although most professional spine societies share general themes with respect to expert witness guidelines, important differences exist. Of the 26 societies included, 10 included publicly available guidelines: 4 of which were general neurosurgery societies, 2 general orthopedic surgery, and 4 spine specific. Three societies included the guidelines on all 4 domains (ie, qualifications, preparations, testimony, and compensation), and 2 societies included only 1 of the 4 domains. Eight societies possess a professional compliance program. CONCLUSION: There remains a paucity in expert witness guidelines provided by professional spine societies. Although existing recommendations are useful, there is a lack of standardized and comprehensive materials for spine surgeons providing expert witness testimony to reference. Moving forward, joint committees comprising surgeons, attorneys, and patient stakeholders may help improve the guidelines.

来源:Neurosurgery,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Zhang JK, Botterbush KS, Mercier P, et al. Expert Witness Testimony in Spine Surgery: A Review of Guidelines and Recommendations From Professional Organizations. Neurosurgery. 2022. PMID: 36705513. doi:10.1227/neu.0000000000002226

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。