ASPECT脑积水系统:一种用于临床的非层级描述系统
本文批判性回顾ICD系统在脑积水分类中的科学性与功能性局限,并提出由六个临床关键因素组成的ASPECT脑积水描述系统:A解剖、S症状、P既往干预、E病因、C并发症、T发病时间与当前年龄;该系统可系统、细致、适用地描述脑积水患者,有望解决既往分类的主要问题,为标准化治疗和研究提供新机会。
要点
- ICD-10与ICD-11脑积水诊断仅纳入少数因素且基于不同临床指标,同一病例可对应多个诊断。
- ASPECT系统由解剖、症状、既往干预、病因、并发症、发病时间与当前年龄六个关键因素组成。
- ASPECT系统为脑积水的系统化、细致且适用的描述工具,有望为标准化治疗和研究提供新机会。
核心结论
- ASPECT脑积水系统是对脑积水患者系统、细致且适用的描述,有望解决既往分类的主要问题,为标准化治疗和研究提供新机会。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为批判性综述,回顾ICD系统在脑积水分类中的科学性与功能性局限,并提出新的描述系统。
主要发现
- ICD-10与ICD-11脑积水诊断仅纳入少数因素,且基于不同临床指标,导致同一病例可适用多个诊断。
- 相似患者可能被不同诊断描述,而临床不同的患者可能被诊断为相同。
- ICD分类对脑积水的诊断造成不必要的分散,使其对研究和临床决策用处有限。
关键数值与推荐
- ASPECT系统包含六个临床关键因素:A解剖、S症状、P既往干预、E病因、C并发症、T发病时间与当前年龄。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
In patients with hydrocephalus, prognosis and intervention are based on multiple factors. This includes, but is not limited to, time of onset, patient age, treatment history, and obstruction of cerebrospinal fluid flow. Consequently, several distinct hydrocephalus classification systems exist. The International Classification of Diseases (ICD) is universally applied, but in ICD-10 and the upcoming ICD-11, hydrocephalus diagnoses incorporate only a few factors, and the hydrocephalus diagnoses of the ICD systems are based on different clinical measures. As a consequence, multiple diagnoses can be applied to individual cases. Therefore, similar patients may be described with different diagnoses, while clinically different patients may be diagnosed identically. This causes unnecessary dispersion in hydrocephalus diagnostics, rendering the ICD classification of little use for research and clinical decision-making. This paper critically reviews the ICD systems for scientific and functional limitations in the classification of hydrocephalus and presents a new descriptive system. We propose describing hydrocephalus by a system consisting of six clinical key factors of hydrocephalus: A (anatomy); S (symptomatology); P (previous interventions); E (etiology); C (complications); T (time-onset and current age). The "ASPECT Hydrocephalus System" is a systematic, nuanced, and applicable description of patients with hydrocephalus, with a potential to resolve the major issues of previous classifications, thus providing new opportunities for standardized treatment and research.
引用
- Milan JB, Jensen TSR, Nørager N, et al. The ASPECT Hydrocephalus System: a non-hierarchical descriptive system for clinical use. Acta Neurochir (Wien). 2022. PMID: 36427098. doi:10.1007/s00701-022-05412-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。