迈向蛛网膜下腔出血风险预测分级:基于机器学习的动脉瘤破裂评分
研究设计位置特异性与集成学习模型预测动脉瘤终生破裂风险,用纵向数据建立线性回归模型预测动脉瘤增长评分,并用Apriori算法识别与蛛网膜下腔出血强相关的危险因素;整合Apriori算法与机器学习模型输出开发ARCP评分,并与PHASES、UIATS评分及神经外科医生团队评分比较。PHASES与UIATS评分敏感度分别为22%和35%,特异度分别为76%和79%;ARCP模型验证表现优于神经外科医生对照组。
要点
- PHASES评分敏感度22%、特异度76%;UIATS评分敏感度35%、特异度79%。
- 大脑中动脉模型精确率93%、召回率90%;前交通动脉83%、80%;床突上段颈内动脉80%、80%。
- 集成方法精确率与召回率均为80%;ARCP验证表现优于神经外科医生对照组。
核心结论
- PHASES和UIATS评分是较弱的预测工具,ARCP评分能够识别并对与蛛网膜下腔出血相关的危险因素进行分级。
研究设计与样本
- 设计位置特异性模型与集成学习模型以开发终生破裂风险,利用纵向数据建立基于线性回归的模型预测动脉瘤增长评分,并使用Apriori算法识别与蛛网膜下腔出血强相关的危险因素。
- 通过整合Apriori算法与机器学习模型的输出开发ARCP评分,并与PHASES、UIATS评分及神经外科医生多学科团队评分进行比较。
主要发现
- PHASES评分敏感度22%、特异度76%;UIATS评分敏感度35%、特异度79%。
- 位置特异性模型中,大脑中动脉精确率93%、召回率90%;前交通动脉精确率83%、召回率80%;床突上段颈内动脉精确率80%、召回率80%。
- 集成方法精确率与召回率均为80%。
- 模型验证显示ARCP表现优于神经外科医生对照组。
- 数据驱动知识产生61种危险因素组合的比较,其中11种为轻度、8种为中度、41种为重度,1种为关键因素。
关键数值与推荐
- PHASES评分敏感度22%、特异度76%;UIATS评分敏感度35%、特异度79%。
- 大脑中动脉模型精确率93%、召回率90%;前交通动脉模型精确率83%、召回率80%;床突上段颈内动脉模型精确率80%、召回率80%。
- 集成方法精确率与召回率均为80%。
- 61种危险因素组合中,11种为轻度、8种为中度、41种为重度,1种为关键因素。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Existing approaches neither provide an accurate prediction of subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) nor offer a quantitative comparison among a group of its risk factors. To evaluate the population, hypertension, age, size, earlier subarachnoid hemorrhage, and location (PHASES) and unruptured intracranial aneurysm treatment score (UIATS) scores and develop an Artificial Intelligence-based 5-year and lifetime aneurysmal rupture criticality prediction (ARCP) score for a set of risk factors. METHODS: We design various location-specific and ensemble learning models to develop lifetime rupture risk, employ the longitudinal data to develop a linear regression-based model to predict an aneurysm's growth score, and use the Apriori algorithm to identify risk factors strongly associated with SAH. We develop ARCP by integrating output of Apriori algorithm and ML models and compare with PHASES and UIATS scores along with the scores of a multidisciplinary team of neurosurgeons. RESULTS: The PHASES and UIATS scores show sensitivities of 22% and 35% and specificities of 76% and 79%, respectively. Location-specific models show precision and recall of 93% and 90% for the middle cerebral artery, 83% and 80% for the anterior communicating artery, and 80% and 80% for the supraclinoid internal carotid artery, respectively. The ensemble method shows both precision and recall of 80%. The validation of the models shows that ARCP performs better than our control group of neurosurgeons. Data-driven knowledge produces comparisons among 61 risk factor combinations, 11 ranked minor, 8 moderate, and 41 severe, and 1 of which is a critical factor. CONCLUSIONS: The PHASES and UIATS are weak predictors, and the ARCP score can identify, and grade, risk factors associated with SAH.
引用
- Malik K, Alam F, Santamaria J, et al. Toward Grading Subarachnoid Hemorrhage Risk Prediction: A Machine Learning-Based Aneurysm Rupture Score. World Neurosurg. 2022. PMID: 36410705. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2022.11.065
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。