颅内脑膜瘤的体积测量:线性法、平面法与机器学习多参数基于体素的形态学测量方法的比较
该回顾性影像数据库分析纳入69例患者共85个脑膜瘤,比较线性法(ABC/2)、平面法和多参数机器学习半自动基于体素的形态学测量(VBM)的体积测量准确性。三种方法所得肿瘤体积存在显著差异(p < 0.001),平面法和线性法分别有79%和63%的患者高估实际体积;VBM不受肿瘤形状属性影响,而平面法和线性法倾向于高估体积。
要点
- 线性法、平面法和VBM测得的脑膜瘤体积存在显著差异(p < 0.001)。
- 平面法和线性法分别有79%和63%的患者高估实际体积。
- VBM体积测量不受肿瘤形状属性影响,而平面法和线性法倾向于高估体积。
核心结论
- 半自动VBM体积测量用于脑膜瘤不受肿瘤形状属性影响,而平面法和线性法倾向于高估肿瘤体积。
- 有必要在线性测量前考虑肿瘤圆度,以便为每位患者个体化选择最合适的方法。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性影像数据库分析,在作者所在机构进行。
- 纳入确诊脑膜瘤且术前头颅磁共振成像适合进行体积分析的患者,共69例患者(85个肿瘤)。
- 肿瘤分割后,图像经自动计算形状属性(球形度、圆度、扁平度和伸长率)。
主要发现
- 线性法测得肿瘤体积为13.82 cm3(范围0.13-163.74 cm3),平面法为11.66 cm3(范围0.17-196.2 cm3),VBM法为10.24 cm3(范围0.17-190.32 cm3),三种方法间差异显著(p < 0.001)。
- 平面法与线性法相对于VBM法的体积中位误差分别为1.08 cm3和11.61%,以及0.23 cm3和5.5%。
- 平面法和线性法分别有79%和63%的患者高估实际体积。
- 相关性研究显示手动与计算机方法之间具有极好的可靠性和体积一致性。
- 更大和更扁平的肿瘤在平面法上准确性更高,而圆度较低的肿瘤对线性法准确性有负面影响。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,半自动VBM体积测量用于脑膜瘤不受肿瘤形状属性影响。
- 作者认为,有必要在线性测量前考虑肿瘤圆度,以便为每位患者个体化选择最合适的方法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To compare the accuracy of three volumetric methods in the radiological assessment of meningiomas: linear (ABC/2), planimetric, and multiparametric machine learning-based semiautomated voxel-based morphometry (VBM), and to investigate the relevance of tumor shape in volumetric error. METHODS: Retrospective imaging database analysis at the authors' institutions. We included patients with a confirmed diagnosis of meningioma and preoperative cranial magnetic resonance imaging eligible for volumetric analyses. After tumor segmentation, images underwent automated computation of shape properties such as sphericity, roundness, flatness, and elongation. RESULTS: Sixty-nine patients (85 tumors) were included. Tumor volumes were significantly different using linear (13.82 cm3 [range 0.13-163.74 cm3]), planimetric (11.66 cm3 [range 0.17-196.2 cm3]) and VBM methods (10.24 cm3 [range 0.17-190.32 cm3]) (p < 0.001). Median volume and percentage errors between the planimetric and linear methods and the VBM method were 1.08 cm3 and 11.61%, and 0.23 cm3 and 5.5%, respectively. Planimetry and linear methods overestimated the actual volume in 79% and 63% of the patients, respectively. Correlation studies showed excellent reliability and volumetric agreement between manual- and computer-based methods. Larger and flatter tumors had greater accuracy on planimetry, whereas less rounded tumors contributed negatively to the accuracy of the linear method. CONCLUSION: Semiautomated VBM volumetry for meningiomas is not influenced by tumor shape properties, whereas planimetry and linear methods tend to overestimate tumor volume. Furthermore, it is necessary to consider tumor roundness prior to linear measurement so as to choose the most appropriate method for each patient on an individual basis.
引用
- Dos Santos Silva J, Schreiner CA, de Lima L, et al. Volumetric measurement of intracranial meningiomas: a comparison between linear, planimetric, and machine learning with multiparametric voxel-based morphometry methods. J Neurooncol. 2022. PMID: 36058985. doi:10.1007/s11060-022-04127-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。