脑刺激与诱发的记忆
该文为批判性叙述综述,讨论脑电刺激(EBS)在清醒患者中诱发的体验性现象是否可能为「合成建构」而非真实记忆提取,并结合当前实证文献与来源归因理论分析假记忆假说。作者认为EBS及患者与神经外科医生互动中的情境需求可能共同创造心理事件并影响其解释,从而产生假记忆;该假说可解释文献中的若干不一致,值得神经外科医生认真考虑。
要点
- EBS及医患互动中的情境需求可能共同创造心理事件并影响解释,从而可能产生假记忆。
- 假记忆假说可解释体验性报告碎片化、EBS在对照研究中可诱发记忆提取错误等现象。
- 作者认为体验性现象可能 largely 为「合成建构」,值得神经外科医生认真考虑。
核心结论
- 体验性现象可能 largely 为「合成建构」的假说值得神经外科医生认真考虑。
研究设计与样本
- 批判性叙述综述,讨论假记忆假说与当前实证文献及来源归因理论的关系。
主要发现
- EBS以及患者与神经外科医生互动中的情境需求可能共同导致心理事件的产生并影响其解释,从而可能产生假记忆。
- 假记忆假说为当前文献中若干明显不一致提供潜在解释,包括体验性报告碎片化、EBS在对照研究中可诱发记忆提取错误、Penfield的体验性现象诱发在现代极少被重复、以及诱发体验性现象的技术在记忆障碍治疗中的效用有限。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Since the late 1930s, electric brain stimulation (EBS) in awake patients has been known to occasionally elicit patient descriptions of a form of memory flashbacks, known as experiential phenomena. One understanding of these sensations are as caused by an augmentation of the capacity for memory retrieval. However, an alternative hypothesis holds that memory flashbacks during EBS are "synthetic constructions" in the form of mental events, falsely interpreted as memories. METHODS: A critical narrative review is used to discuss the false memory hypothesis in relation to the current empirical literature and source attribution theory. RESULTS: EBS as well as situational demands in the form of interaction between patient and neurosurgeon may both lead to the creation of mental events and influence their interpretation in a way that may create false memories. The false memory hypothesis provides a potential explanation for several apparent inconsistencies in the current literature such as (a) the fragmented nature of experiential reports, (b) the ability of EBS to induce memory retrieval errors in controlled studies, (c) that Penfield's elicitations of experiential phenomena are so rarely replicated in the modern era, and (d) the limited utility of techniques that elicit experiential phenomena in the treatment of memory disorders. CONCLUSIONS: The hypothesis that experiential phenomena may largely be "synthetic constructions" deserves serious consideration by neurosurgeons.
引用
- Sjöberg RL. Brain stimulation and elicited memories. Acta Neurochir (Wien). 2022. PMID: 35804269. doi:10.1007/s00701-022-05307-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。