单纯伤口闭合与手术治疗平民颅脑枪伤的对比
本单中心回顾性研究比较了67例平民颅脑枪伤患者中单纯伤口闭合(SWC,17例)与手术(50例)的神经结局和并发症。SWC组影像学占位效应和额窦受累发生率更低,但30、60、90天扩展格拉斯哥结局量表评分≥5的比例及感染、脑脊液瘘、癫痫、再手术率两组无显著差异。作者认为经严格选择的患者中SWC可考虑为安全有效的积极治疗。
要点
- SWC组影像学占位效应3/17(17.6%)低于手术组31/50(62%),p=0.002。
- SWC组额窦受累0/17(0%)低于手术组14/50(28%),p=0.01。
- 两组30、60、90天GOS-E≥5比例及感染、癫痫、再手术率均无显著差异。
核心结论
- SWC与手术组之间存在重要的临床相关差异,经严格选择的平民颅脑枪伤患者中SWC可考虑为安全有效的积极治疗。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心、回顾性研究,基于前瞻性维护的机构创伤性脑损伤和创伤登记数据库。
- 纳入67例急性平民颅脑枪伤成人患者(疑似或确诊硬脑膜穿透),其中SWC组17例(25.4%),手术组50例(74.6%)。
- 排除非 firearm 穿透伤、初始GCS评分3分、初始GCS评分4分且瞳孔无反应以及就诊后48小时内死亡的患者。
主要发现
- SWC组影像学占位效应发生率3/17(17.6%)低于手术组31/50(62%),绝对差44.4,95%CI -71.9至16.8,p=0.002。
- SWC组额窦受累发生率0/17(0%)低于手术组14/50(28%),绝对差28,95%CI -50.4至5.6,p=0.01。
- 30天GOS-E评分≥5的比例SWC组4/11(36.4%)与手术组12/35(34.3%)无显著差异,OR 1.1,95%CI 0.3-4.5,p>0.99。
- 60天GOS-E评分≥5的比例SWC组2/7(28.6%)与手术组8/26(30.8%)无显著差异,OR 0.9,95%CI 0.3-3.4,p>0.99。
- 90天GOS-E评分≥5的比例SWC组3/8(37.5%)与手术组12/26(46.2%)无显著差异,OR 0.7,95%CI 0.1-3.6,p>0.99。
关键数值与推荐
- 感染发生率SWC组1/17(5.9%)与手术组6/50(12%)无显著差异,OR 0.5,95%CI 0.1-4.1,p=0.67。
- 脑脊液瘘发生率SWC组2/11(11.6%)与手术组3/50(6%)无显著差异,OR 2.1,95%CI 0.3-13.7,p=0.60。
- 癫痫发生率SWC组3/17(17.6%)与手术组9/50(18%)无显著差异,OR 1,95%CI 0.2-4.1,p>0.99。
- 再手术率SWC组3/17(17.6%)与手术组4/50(8%)无显著差异,OR 2.5,95%CI 0.5-12.4,p=0.36。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,在经严格选择的平民颅脑枪伤患者亚组中,SWC可考虑为安全有效的积极治疗。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: A carefully selected subset of civilian cranial gunshot wound (CGSW) patients may be treated with simple wound closure (SWC) as a proactive therapy, but the appropriate clinical scenario for using this strategy is unknown. The aim of this study was to compare SWC and surgery patients in terms of their neurological outcomes and complications, including infections, seizures, and reoperations. METHODS: This was a single-center, retrospective review of the prospectively maintained institutional traumatic brain injury and trauma registries. Included were adults who sustained an acute CGSW defined as suspected or confirmed dural penetration. Excluded were nonfirearm penetrating injuries, patients with an initial Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) score of 3, patients with an initial GCS score of 4 and nonreactive pupils, and patients who died within 48 hours of presentation. RESULTS: A total of 67 patients were included; 17 (25.4%) were treated with SWC and 50 (74.6%) were treated with surgery. The SWC group had a lower incidence of radiographic mass effect (3/17 [17.6%] SWC vs 31/50 [62%] surgery; absolute difference 44.4, 95% CI -71.9 to 16.8; p = 0.002) and lower incidence of involvement of the frontal sinus (0/17 [0%] SWC vs 14/50 [28%] surgery; absolute difference 28, 95% CI -50.4 to 5.6; p = 0.01). There were no differences in the frequency of Glasgow Outcome Scale-Extended scores ≥ 5 between the SWC and surgery groups at 30 days (4/11 [36.4%] SWC vs 12/35 [34.3%] surgery; OR 1.1, 95% CI 0.3-4.5; p > 0.99), 60 days (2/7 [28.6%] SWC vs 8/26 [30.8%] surgery; OR 0.9, 95% CI 0.3-3.4; p > 0.99), and 90 days (3/8 [37.5%] SWC vs 12/26 [46.2%] surgery; OR 0.7, 95% CI 0.1-3.6; p > 0.99). There were no differences in the incidence of infections (1/17 [5.9%] SWC vs 6/50 [12%] surgery; OR 0.5, 95% CI 0.1-4.1; p = 0.67), CSF fistulas (2/11 [11.6%] SWC vs 3/50 [6%] surgery; OR 2.1, 95% CI 0.3-13.7; p = 0.60), seizures (3/17 [17.6%] SWC vs 9/50 [18%] surgery; OR 1, 95% CI 0.2-4.1; p > 0.99), and reoperations (3/17 [17.6%] SWC vs 4/50 [8%] surgery; OR 2.5, 95% CI 0.5-12.4; p = 0.36) between the SWC and surgery groups. CONCLUSIONS: There were important clinically relevant differences between the SWC and surgery groups. SWC can be considered a safe and efficacious proactive therapy in a carefully selected subset of civilian CGSW patients.
引用
- Krueger EM, Benveniste RJ, Lu VM, et al. Simple wound closure compared with surgery for civilian cranial gunshot wounds. J Neurosurg. 2022. PMID: 35901757. doi:10.3171/2022.5.JNS22617
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。