老年三叉神经痛患者接受手术、放射外科及经皮手术后再手术发生率及医疗资源利用情况
基于MarketScan数据库2000至2016年数据,纳入993例≥65岁三叉神经痛患者(放射外科430例、经皮手术432例、手术131例),比较不同治疗方式的长期医疗资源利用。经皮手术组再手术率及合并支付费用最高,手术组最低,放射外科居中。
要点
- 经皮手术组术后1、2、5年再手术率分别为41%、48%、57%,高于放射外科组(11%、18%、29%)和手术组(6%、9%、11%)。
- 经皮手术组术后1、2、5年合并支付分别为手术组的1.8、1.9、2.0倍,放射外科组为1.4、1.5、1.5倍。
- 术后5年合并支付:经皮手术组79753美元(IQR 46013,144064)vs 放射外科组61016美元(IQR 27114,117097)vs 手术组41074美元(IQR 25392,87952),p<0.0001。
核心结论
- 经皮手术和放射外科是大多数老年三叉神经痛患者常用的治疗方法,但手术治疗在术后5年内可持久控制疼痛且再手术需求最少,放射外科次之,经皮手术再次之。
- 经皮手术治疗三叉神经痛在所有时间点均导致最高的医疗资源利用和再手术需求。
- 作者认为,在为老年三叉神经痛患者选择适当治疗方式时,临床决策应考虑这些发现。
研究设计与样本
- 查询MarketScan数据库,使用国际疾病分类第九版和现行操作术语,纳入2000至2016年年龄≥65岁、接受手术、放射外科或经皮手术治疗且索引操作后随访至少5年的三叉神经痛患者。
- 共纳入993例患者,其中放射外科430例(43%),经皮手术432例(44%),手术131例(13%)。
- 分析结局包括入院、门诊服务和药物续配。
主要发现
- 总体中位年龄74岁,女性占64%,90%有Medicare保险,17%的Elixhauser指数≥3。
- 手术组患者较年轻(中位年龄71岁),合并症指数≥3的比例为24%,高于放射外科组(13%)和经皮手术组(17%)。
- 索引操作后1、2、5年,经皮手术组任何再手术率分别为41%、48%、57%,放射外科组分别为11%、18%、29%,手术组分别为6%、9%、11%。
- 经皮手术组术后1、2、5年合并支付分别为手术组的1.8、1.9、2.0倍;放射外科组分别为手术组的1.4、1.5、1.5倍。
- 术后5年合并支付:经皮手术组79753美元(IQR 46013,144064)vs 放射外科组61016美元(IQR 27114,117097)vs 手术组41074美元(IQR 25392,87952),p<0.0001。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,在为老年三叉神经痛患者选择适当治疗方式时,临床决策应考虑这些关于再手术率和医疗资源利用的发现。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Management of trigeminal neuralgia (TN) in elderly patients poses significant challenges. The impact of different treatment modalities (surgery, radiosurgery [RS], and percutaneous techniques [PTs]) on healthcare utilization is not well defined in the management of TN in elderly patients. The aim of this study was to compare the long-term healthcare utilization metrics of different interventions in the management of elderly patients with TN. METHODS: The MarketScan database was queried using the International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision and Current Procedural Terminology, from 2000 to 2016. TN patients ≥ 65 years of age managed using surgery, RS, and PTs with at least 5 years of follow-up after the index procedure were included. Outcomes analyzed were hospital admissions, outpatient services, and medication refills. RESULTS: Of 993 patients, 43% (n = 430) underwent RS, 44% (n = 432) had PTs, and only 13% (n = 131) underwent surgery for TN. Overall, the median age of patients was 74 years old, 64% were females, 90% had Medicare insurance, and 17% had an Elixhauser index ≥ 3. Patients in the surgery group were younger (median age 71 years) with a higher comorbidity index (≥ 3; 24%) compared with patients undergoing RS and PTs (13% and 17%, respectively). At 1, 2, and 5 years after the index procedure, 41%, 48%, and 57% of patients in the PT cohort underwent any repeat procedure compared with 11%, 18%, and 29% for the RS cohort, and 6%, 9%, and 11% for the surgical cohort, respectively. Also, patients in the PT cohort incurred 1.8, 1.9, and 2.0 times the combined payment at 1, 2, and 5 years, respectively, compared with the surgery cohort. Similarly, patients who underwent RS for TN incurred 1.4, 1.5, and 1.5 times the combined payment at 1, 2, and 5 years, respectively, compared with the surgery cohort. At 5 years after the index procedure, combined payments for the PT cohort were $79,753 (IQR $46,013, $144,064) compared with $61,016 (IQR $27,114, $117,097) for the RS cohort and $41,074 (IQR $25,392, $87,952) for the surgery cohort (p < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: PTs followed by RS were the common procedures used in the majority of elderly patients with TN. However, surgery for TN resulted in durable control with the least need for reoperations up to 5 years after the index procedure, followed by RS and PTs. PTs for TN resulted in the highest utilization of healthcare resources and need for reoperations at all time points. These findings should be considered in clinical decision-making when selecting appropriate treatment modalities in elderly patients with TN.
引用
- Sharma M, Ball T, Wang D, et al. Incidence of repeat procedures and healthcare utilization following surgery, radiosurgery, and percutaneous procedures in elderly patients with trigeminal neuralgia. J Neurosurg. 2022. PMID: 35090128. doi:10.3171/2021.12.JNS211880
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。