脑动脉瘤非治愈性显微手术:包裹、残留与复发率的系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析纳入64项研究,量化脑动脉瘤非治愈性显微手术的三种情形:包裹率3.5%(95%CI 2.7%-4.2%,I²=88%)、夹闭后残留率6.4%(95%CI 5.2%-7.6%,I²=93%)、完全闭塞后复发率2.1%(95%CI 1.2%-3.1%,I²=58%),总非治愈手术率为12.0%(95%CI 11.5%-12.5%)。Egger检验提示无显著发表偏倚,Meta回归显示包裹率随时间显著下降,而残留率和复发率无显著变化。
要点
- 脑动脉瘤开放显微手术非治愈性治疗总率约为12.0%(95%CI 11.5%-12.5%)。
- 包裹率为3.5%(95%CI 2.7%-4.2%),夹闭后残留率为6.4%(95%CI 5.2%-7.6%)。
- 完全闭塞后复发率为2.1%(95%CI 1.2%-3.1%),包裹率随时间显著下降。
核心结论
- 脑动脉瘤开放显微手术约12%为非治愈性治疗,该指标可用于患者咨询和其他治疗方式的基准。
研究设计与样本
- PRISMA指导的系统文献综述与Meta分析,检索MEDLINE和Cochrane Library数据库,纳入详细报告动脉瘤包裹率、影像确认残留率及确认完全闭塞后复发率的研究,采用随机效应模型计算合并率,并对每项分析评估统计异质性和发表偏倚,给出I²值和Egger检验p值。
- 共64项研究符合纳入标准进入最终分析。
主要发现
- 41项研究中573/15,715个动脉瘤被包裹,包裹率为3.5%(95%CI 2.7%-4.2%,I²=88%)。
- 43项研究中906/13,902个动脉瘤存在残留瘤颈或瘤顶充盈,残留率为6.4%(95%CI 5.2%-7.6%,I²=93%)。
- 15项研究中71/2,568个最初完全闭塞的动脉瘤出现复发,复发率为2.1%(95%CI 1.2%-3.1%,I²=58%)。
- 总非治愈手术率为12.0%(95%CI 11.5%-12.5%)。
- Egger检验提示纳入研究间无显著发表偏倚;Meta回归分析显示报告的动脉瘤包裹率随时间显著下降,而动脉瘤残留率和复发率无显著变化。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为该非治愈性治疗率指标可用于患者咨询,并作为其他治疗方式的基准。
局限性
- 本研究受纳入研究间高度异质性的限制。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Microsurgery for cerebral aneurysms is called definitive, yet some patients undergo a craniotomy that results in noncurative treatment. Furthermore, the overall rate of noncurative microsurgery for cerebral aneurysms is unclear. The objective of this study was to complete a systematic review and meta-analysis to quantify three scenarios of noncurative treatment: aneurysm wrapping, postclipping remnants, and late regrowth of completely obliterated aneurysms. METHODS: A PRISMA-guided systematic literature review of the MEDLINE and Cochrane Library databases and meta-analysis was completed. Studies were included that detailed rates of aneurysm wrapping, residua confirmed with imaging, and regrowth after confirmed total occlusion. Pooled rates were subsequently calculated using a random-effects model. An assessment of statistical heterogeneity and publication bias among the included studies was also completed for each analysis, with resultant I2 values and p values determined with Egger's test. RESULTS: Sixty-four studies met the inclusion criteria for final analysis. In 41 studies, 573/15,715 aneurysms were wrapped, for a rate of 3.5% (95% CI 2.7%-4.2%, I2 = 88%). In 43 studies, 906/13,902 aneurysms had residual neck or dome filling, for a rate of 6.4% (95% CI 5.2%-7.6%, I2 = 93%). In 15 studies, 71/2568 originally fully occluded aneurysms showed regrowth, for a rate of 2.1% (95% CI 1.2%-3.1%, I2 = 58%). Together, there was a total rate of noncurative surgery of 12.0% (95% CI 11.5%-12.5%). Egger's test suggested no significant publication bias among the studies. Meta-regression analysis revealed that the reported rate of aneurysm wrapping has significantly declined over time, whereas the rates of aneurysm residua and recurrence have not significantly changed. CONCLUSIONS: Open microsurgery for cerebral aneurysm results in noncurative treatment approximately 12% of the time. This metric may be used to counsel patients and as a benchmark for other treatment modalities. This investigation is limited by the high degree of heterogeneity among the included studies.
引用
- Schartz D, Mattingly TK, Rahmani R, et al. Noncurative microsurgery for cerebral aneurysms: a systematic review and meta-analysis of wrapping, residual, and recurrence rates. J Neurosurg. 2021. PMID: 34798602. doi:10.3171/2021.9.JNS211698
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。