尿阴离子间隙:常见误解
本文综述指出,1986年和1988年两项研究提出尿阴离子间隙(UAG)与尿氨排泄(UNH4)呈强负相关并可用于间接评估UNH4,但该观点存在错误。稳态下UAG反映Na、K、Cl摄入,与UNH4无一致关系;UAG正常值因饮食钾摄入增加及含非氯阴离子钠盐添加剂广泛使用而显著升高。
要点
- 稳态下UAG反映Na、K、Cl摄入,而非尿氨排泄。
- UAG与UNH4的相关性为偶然,不能外推至其他情况。
- UAG正常值已显著升高,解读时需考虑饮食因素。
核心结论
- UAG不能作为尿氨排泄的间接指标,原研究存在设计错误。
- 稳态下UAG反映Na、K、Cl摄入,与UNH4无一致关系。
- UAG正常值已显著升高,解读需考虑饮食钾及非氯阴离子钠盐摄入增加。
研究设计与样本
- 综述,分析已发表证据以揭示原假说及研究设计的错误。
主要发现
- 1986年和1988年两项研究报道代谢性酸中毒患者UAG与UNH4强负相关,但该相关性为偶然。
- 稳态下UAG反映Na、K、Cl摄入,摄入与尿排出差异提示选择性肾外丢失或非稳态。
- UNH4在无肾功能不全时主要取决于每日酸负荷,与UAG无一致关系。
- 过去数十年UAG正常值显著升高,主要因饮食钾摄入增加及含非氯阴离子钠盐添加剂广泛使用。
临床怎么用
- 不应使用UAG间接评估尿氨排泄。
- 解读UAG时需考虑当前正常值已升高及饮食因素。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Two papers, one in 1986 and another one in 1988, reported a strong inverse correlation between urinary anion gap (UAG) and urine ammonia excretion (UNH4) in patients with metabolic acidosis and postulated that UAG could be used as an indirect measure of UNH4 This postulation has persisted until now and is widely accepted. In this review, we discuss factors regulating UAG and examine published evidence to uncover errors in the postulate and the design of the original studies. The essential fact is that, in the steady state, UAG reflects intake of Na, K, and Cl. Discrepancy between intake and urinary output of these electrolytes (i.e, UAG) indicates selective extrarenal loss of these electrolytes or nonsteady state. UNH4 excretion, which depends, in the absence of renal dysfunction, mainly on the daily acid load, has no consistent relationship to UAG either theoretically or in reality. Any correlation between UAG and UNH4, when observed, was a fortuitous correlation and cannot be extrapolated to other situations. Furthermore, the normal value of UAG has greatly increased over the past few decades, mainly due to increases in dietary intake of potassium and widespread use of sodium salts with anions other than chloride as food additives. The higher normal values of UAG must be taken into consideration in interpreting UAG.
引用
- Uribarri J, Oh MS. The Urine Anion Gap: Common Misconceptions. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2021. PMID: 33769949. doi:10.1681/ASN.2020101509
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。